Chaker v Tompsett (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: CHAKER v TOMPSETT (No 2) [2011] NSWSC 992
Hearing dates:12 August 2011
Decision date: 01 September 2011
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: HOEBEN J
Decision:

Report admissible with deletions.

Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - Further medical report obtained for retrial - contents inconsistent with evidence at first trial - admissibility - report raising new issues already rejected - report admissible subject to deletion of rejected material.
Category:Procedural and other rulings
Parties: Patricia Chaker - Plaintiff
Elizabeth Tompsett - Defendant
Representation: Ms M Avenell - Plaintiff
Ms J Sandford - Defendant
TressCox Lawyers - Plaintiff
Lamrocks Solicitors & Attorneys - Defendant
File Number(s):2011/00065254

Judgment

  1. HIS HONOUR:

Nature of proceedings

The defendant seeks an order that the plaintiff not be allowed to rely upon the report of Dr G Mark Malouf, dated 22 June 2011, either in whole or in part on the retrial of this matter. So that the matter could be finalised without undue delay, I directed that it was not necessary to file and serve a motion to that effect and that the Court would allow the application to be made orally.

Factual background

  1. The factual background to the proceedings generally and to this application is set out in Patricia Chaker v Elizabeth Tompsett [2011] NSWSC 135. This judgment should be read with that judgment.

  1. The effect of that judgment was to disallow certain paragraphs in an Amended Statement of Claim sought to be filed on behalf of the plaintiff. The basis for the rejection of those paragraphs was that they raised issues which were new and which had not been considered in the first trial.

  1. The evidence that was placed before the Court on this application was a letter of instruction from the plaintiff's solicitors to Dr Malouf, dated 8 June 2011 (exhibit M1); the report of Dr Malouf of 22 June 2011 (exhibit M2) and a redacted extract of the evidence given by Dr Malouf in the first trial on 21 March 2007 (exhibit M3).

  1. The letter of instruction (exhibit M1), posed three questions for Dr Malouf. The first asked Dr Malouf to make an assumption, which was contrary to the evidence given by the defendant in the first trial. The second asked Dr Malouf to assume that certain evidence was given by the defendant at the first trial and to then comment on whether that evidence and subsequent conduct of the defendant was consistent with reasonable care and skill of a general surgeon in 2003. The third asked Dr Malouf to express an opinion as to whether the development of lymphoedema by the plaintiff would have been avoided had the defendant referred her to him or some other similarly qualified surgeon before operating.

Submissions

  1. The defendant raised these issues with Dr Malouf's report:

(i) The expressions of opinion in the report contradicted evidence given by Dr Malouf at the first trial.

(ii) The report raised issues which were rejected when the amendments to the Statement…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Chaker v Tompsett (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NSWSC 992
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Chaker v Tompsett (No 2), the matter was heard before the Supreme Court of Victoria. The dispute between the parties revolves around the admissibility of a further medical report obtained for the retrial. This report contains contents that are inconsistent with the evidence presented at the first trial. The court was required to determine whether the report was admissible and, if so, whether certain parts of it could be excluded on the basis that they raised issues that had already been rejected in the first trial.

The primary legal issues before the court were the admissibility of the new medical report and the potential exclusion of parts of the report that introduced new issues which had already been dismissed. The court considered whether the new evidence could be admitted without prejudice to the defendant and whether the introduction of these new issues was permissible. The court also had to evaluate the impact of the inconsistencies between the new report and the evidence presented at the first trial.

In its decision, the court held that the further medical report was admissible for the retrial but subject to certain conditions. Specifically, the court ruled that any parts of the report that raised new issues which had already been rejected in the first trial were to be excluded. The court found that while the new report could be used, it needed to be carefully curated to avoid prejudicing the defendant. This approach ensured that the trial remained focused on the evidence and issues that had already been considered and determined.

The court's final order was that the further medical report was admissible in the retrial, subject to the exclusion of content that introduced new issues already rejected. This decision balanced the need for updated evidence with the necessity to maintain the integrity and fairness of the retrial process.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established