CGJ v Commissioner of Victims Rights

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read


Civil and Administrative Tribunal

New South Wales

Case Name: 

CGJ v Commissioner of Victims Rights

Medium Neutral Citation: 

[2016] NSWCATAD 154

Hearing Date(s): 

27 May 2016

Date of Orders:

15 July 2016

Decision Date: 

15 July 2016

Jurisdiction: 

Administrative and Equal Opportunity Division

Before: 

M Riordan, Senior Member

Decision: 

1. The time for filing the application is extended to 11 November 2015.
 
2. The decision of the Senior Assessor dated 1 December 2015 is set aside. In substitution for that decision the following decision is made:

“1. The applicant is eligible for a Category C recognition payment in the sum of $5,000.
 
2. The applicant is eligible for a special grant in the sum of $5,000”

Catchwords: 

Administrative Review – Statutory interpretation - Jurisdiction to determine application for administrative review – Victims Rights and Support – Act of violence – Recognition payment

Legislation Cited: 

Victims Support and Rehabilitation Act 1996
Victims Rights and Support Act 2013
Victims Rights and Support Regulation 2013
Victims Rights and Support Amendment (Transitional Claims) Regulation 2015
Administrative Decisions Review Act 1997
Civil and Administrative Decisions Act 2013 (No. 2)

Cases Cited: 

CEL v Commissioner of Victims Rights [2016] NSWCATAD 83

Category: 

Principal judgment

Parties: 

CGJ (Applicant)
Commissioner of Victims Rights (Respondent)

Representation: 

Solicitors:
CGJ (Applicants Mother)
Victims Services (Respondent)

File Number(s): 

1510709

Publication Restriction: 

A non-publication Order is made under s 64 (1) of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (No. 2) (NSW) in respect of the names of private individuals, and other information which might identify them.

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. In these proceedings, which were commenced by an application (‘the Application”) filed on 11 November 2015, the applicant sought administrative review of a decision made by a delegate of the Respondent in respect of an Application for Compensation that was lodged on behalf of the applicant (known by the pseudonym “CGJ”).

Background

  1. On 17 May 2012, CGJ’s mother lodged an Application for Compensation on his behalf under the provisions of the Victims Support and Rehabilitation Act 1996 (“the old Act”), which alleged that he was the primary victim of acts of violence (domestic/family violence) that were perpetrated by his father over a period of time between 1 January 2000 and June 2011, at Merrylands, NSW. The copy of the application that is before me is incomplete and as paragraphs 34 to 38 (inclusive) are missing, I cannot ascertain the resulting compensable injuries. However, the application asserts that CGJ suffered “severe anxiety” as a result of the abuse, which suggests that he claimed compensation for the injuries of “domestic violence” and “psychological/psychiatric injury - category 2”.

  2. I note that CGJ was legally represented by Takchi & Associates in relation to the application and internal review, but he is not legally represented in relation to his current application for administrative review.

    Evidence

  3. The application for compensation asserts that the acts of violence were reported to NSW Police in about August 2011. There is no Police COPS Event report in the documents before me in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CGJ v Commissioner of Victims Rights and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NSWCATAD 154
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

CGJ sought administrative review of a decision to dismiss his application for a recognition payment under the Victims Rights and Support Act 2013 (NSW). CGJ argued that he was the primary victim of domestic violence and thus eligible for the payment. The Commissioner of Victims Rights dismissed CGJ’s application on the basis that there was insufficient evidence to show that CGJ was the primary victim of an act of violence. CGJ sought internal review of the dismissal, but the Senior Assessor also dismissed the review. CGJ then sought judicial review of the Senior Assessor’s decision.

The central legal issues were whether CGJ was the primary victim of an act of violence on the balance of probabilities, and whether there were any s 44 factors that would lead to the decline of victims support or a reduction in the amount payable.

The Court found that CGJ had established that he was the primary victim of an act of violence. The Court found that the evidence, consisting primarily of CGJ’s statutory declaration, was sufficient to satisfy the balance of probabilities test. The Court also found that there were no s 44 factors that would lead to the decline of victims support or a reduction in the amount payable. Accordingly, the Court set aside the decision of the Senior Assessor and determined that CGJ was eligible for a Category C recognition payment in the sum of $5,000 and a special grant in the sum of $5,000. The time for filing the application was extended to 11 November 2015.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The time for filing the application is extended to 11 November 2015.

2. The decision of the Senior Assessor dated 1 December 2015 is set aside. In substitution for that decision the following decision is made:

“1. The applicant is eligible for a Category C recognition payment in the sum of $5,000.

2. The applicant is eligible for a special grant in the sum of $5,000”

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I note that CGJ was legally represented by Takchi & Associates in relation to the application and internal review, but he is not legally represented in relation to his current application for administrative review.Evidence The application for compensation asserts that the acts of violence were reported to NSW Police in about August 2011. There is no Police COPS Event report in the documents before me in relation to this claim. However, I note that a COPS Event report dated 19 May 2011 was lodged in relation to an application made by CGJ’s mother. This indicates that CG’s brother complained to Police regarding a domestic violence incident that occurred that day, when the alleged offender attended at his mother’s home and started an argument. CGJ’s mother stated that the alleged offender was not happy with their relationship and that he was always finding an excuse to fight with herself and CGJ’s older brother and that he had threatened to shoot the whole family and then himself. He had also been threatening them regularly over the past few months. The alleged offender was arrested and Police applied for an urgent AVO. On 13 June 2013, CGJ signed a Statutory Declaration, in which he stated that he is a victim of “domestic abuse” and that he was exposed to severe emotional, physical and verbal abuse by the alleged offender during his “infant years”. He was also exposed to the alleged offender’s physical abuse of his mother. He said that the abuse affected his day-to-day ability to go to school and to make friends and that he had difficulty concentrating and dwelled on the abuse and his fear of the alleged offender. He also felt very angry towards the alleged offender for what he had done to himself, his mother and his brothers. However, CGJ’s solicitors did not lodge any medical evidence in support of the application.Applicable Legislation On 7 May 2013, the New South Wales Government introduced legislation that changed the form of support provided to victims of violent crime in New South Wales. The Old Act was repealed and replaced by the Victims Rights and Support Act 2013 (“the Act”). The Act commenced on 3 June 2013. Cl 4 and cl 5 of sch 2 effectively provide that an application for compensation that was lodged under the old Act but not finally determined by 7 May 2013 should be determined under the Act as if it was an application for victims support under the Act. For the purposes of this decision, I have assumed that the Respondent advised CGJ’s solicitors that the application would be determined under the new Act as if it was an application for victims support. However, there is no letter to that effect in the documents that are before me.Decision at First Instance On 14 April 2014, an Assessor (Client Claims) determined that CGJ had not established that he was the primary victim of an act of violence and dismissed the application. The Assessor determined (relevantly):8. After carefully reading all of the evidence on file before me, unfortunately I am not satisfied there is sufficient evidence to support the applicant being the primary victim of an act of violence in this matter.9. I have had regard to the COPS reports on the applicant’s mother’s file. I note COPS events appear on file none of which suggest the applicant was a primary victim but otherwise could infer that he had witnessed violence between his parents.10. I have carefully read/perused the statutory declaration by the applicant. Whilst I accept wholeheartedly that (CGJ) had a very difficult relationship with his father, unfortunately there is very little contemporaneous or independent evidence before me that supports the applicant’s assertions of being subjected to domestic violence abuse over a protracted period as he contends. The applicant has not reported all matters to Police. Whilst I understand there may be reasons and circumstances for this, unfortunately this results in a lack of corroborative evidence. There is also no medical evidence on file suggesting the applicant suffered any harm.11. Ultimately there is insufficient scope or detail to what is mentioned in the reports or evidence for me to form an opinion against the offender for the alleged acts of violence.12. Therefore given all of the above, whilst I am sympathetic to the applicant after reading the applicant’s statutory declaration pertaining to his claims arising from his childhood, I am unable to find that there is sufficient evidence in this particular matter which substantiates the applicant being the primary victim of domestic violence alleged against this offender. Therefore, section 19 of the Act is not established on the balance of probabilities and the application is therefore dismissed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the purposes of this decision I have assumed that the Respondent served a copy of the Notice of Decision upon CGJ’s solicitors, but no letter to that effect is currently before me.Internal Review Decision On 13 May 2014, CGJ’s solicitors advised the Respondent in writing that they were ‘instructed to apply for an appeal’ against the decision and that they would file a further Statutory Declaration from CGJ in support of the ‘appeal’. I note that they referred to “the report of the counsellor”, but there is no such report in the documents before me, and that they stated that they were “prepared to obtain further medical evidence in support of the applicant, but note that the act now does not require the applicant to file independent medical evidence” and that they would lodge a further statutory declaration from CGJ in support of the “appeal”. On 17 June 2014, the Senior Assessor deferred the determination of the internal review to provide CGJ’s solicitors with an opportunity to submit further evidence. The Notice of Deferral indicates that the Notice of Decision was posted to CGJ’s solicitors on 5 May 2014 and that the internal review was listed for determination on or after 9 June 2014 and that any submissions or adjournment requests must be received by 4 June 2014. However, on 5 June 2014, CGJ’s solicitors wrote to the respondent and requested (inter alia) advice regarding ‘the status of the appeal and the documents to be lodged in support of the claimant’. I note that the Respondent addressed this in the Notice of Deferral as follows:8. The onus is on the applicant’s solicitor, as the applicant’s legal representative, to obtain and submit evidence in support of the claim for an internal review. It is plainly not within the scope of Victims Services’ role to advise the applicant’s solicitors what documents, if any, are to be lodged in support of an application for internal review. For the purposes of this decision I have assumed that the Respondent served a copy of the Notice of Deferral upon CGJ’s solicitors, but no letter to that effect is currently before me. On 2 July 2014, CGJ’s solicitors wrote to the Respondent advising that they were in the process of obtaining a report from the treating GP and that they would “serve this upon you upon receipt of same”. The Senior Assessor further deferred determination of the internal review on 11 August 2014 and 23 October 2014, each deferral being for a period of 2 months, to enable CGJ’s solicitors to lodge further evidence. For the purposes of this decision I have assumed that the Respondent served copies of the 2 further Notices of Deferral upon CGJ’s solicitors, but no letters to that effect are currently before me. However, CGJ’s solicitors did not submit any further evidence and on 1 December 2014, the Senior Assessor issued a Notice of Review Decision. The Senior Assessor determined that CGJ had not established that he was the primary victim of an act of violence on the balance of probabilities and dismissed the application. The Senior Assessor determined, relevantly:21. Having considered the documents on file, I am not satisfied on the balance of probabilities that the incidents occurred as indicated. The evidence consists of the applicant’s statutory declaration. The allegations are not sufficiently supported by evidence of an independent or corroborative nature.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I am satisfied that the application was lodged within the prescribed period and that CGJ is eligible for a special grant pursuant to cl 5 (3) of sch 2 of the Act.Section 44 Consideration I am required by the Act to consider whether there are any factors under s 44 of the Act that would lead me to decline victims support to the applicant or to reduce any amount payable. I am satisfied that no s 44 factors have been made out in this matter. Pursuant to s 63 (3) (c) of the ADR Act, I set aside the decision of the Senior Assessor dated 1 December 2014 and I make the following decision in substitution:(1)CGJ has established on the balance of probabilities that he was the primary victim of acts of violence that are a series of related acts and that he suffered injury as a result.(2)CGJ is eligible for a Category C recognition payment in the sum of $5,000.(3)CGJ is eligible for a special grant in the sum of $5,000.