cf Bidald Consulting Pty Ltd v Miles Special Builders Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read
CITATION:

Bidald Consulting (t/as Forstaff) v Miles Special Builders [2005] NSWSC 977

HEARING DATE(S): 23 September 2005
 
JUDGMENT DATE : 


23 September 2005

JURISDICTION:

Equity

JUDGMENT OF:

Campbell J

DECISION:

Notice to produce not vitiated by nominating less than 14 days after service to produce documents. Some paragraphs of notice to produce held valid, others not valid.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE - Uniform Civil Procedure Rules - notices to produce - time for compliance - whether order required abridging time if notice served requiring production in less than 14 days - whether notice to produce can be valid in part - onus of proof concerning reasonableness of time for production of documents pursuant to notice to produce - relevance of immediately pending trial to reasonableness of time period for production of documents pursuant to notice to produce

LEGISLATION CITED:

Supreme Court Rules 1970
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005

PARTIES:

Bidald Consulting Pty Ltd (t/as Forstaff) - Plaintiff
Miles Special Builders Pty Ltd (subject to Deed of Company Arrangement) - Defendant

FILE NUMBER(S):

SC 2583/05

COUNSEL:

MR Aldridge SC; VE Whittaker - Plaintiff
G Lucarelli; EW Young - Defendant

SOLICITORS:

Kemp Strang - Plaintiff
Colin Biggers & Paisley - Defendant

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION
EQUITY LIST

CAMPBELL J

FRIDAY 23 SEPTEMBER 2005

2583/05 BIDALD CONSULTING PTY LIMITED (T/AS FORSTAFF) v MILES SPECIAL BUILDERS PTY LIMITED (SUBJECT TO DEED OF COMPANY ARRANGEMENT)

JUDGMENT – Ex Tempore

1 HIS HONOUR: A point has arisen concerning the construction of a provision relating to Notices to Produce in the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005. Part 21 division 2 sets out the regime under which Notices to Produce can be served between parties, where the notices require production of documents for inspection, out of court. (By comparison, Part 34 applies to Notices to Produce which require production of documents to the Court, either at the hearing or at some other time fixed by the Court). Rule 21.10 sets out the power for one party (A) to issue a Notice to Produce on the other (B). Rule 21.11 provides:

          “21.11 Production under notice to produce
              (cf SCR Part 23, rule 2(3) and (4); DCR Part 22, Rule 2 (3) and (4))
          (1) Unless the court orders otherwise, party B must, within a reasonable time after being served with a notice to produce:
              (a) produce for party A's inspection such of the documents or things referred to in the notice (other than privileged documents) as are in party B's possession, and
              (b) serve on party A, in respect of any document that is not produced, a notice stating:
                  (i) that the document is a privileged document, or
                  (ii) that the document is, to the best of party B's knowledge, information and belief, in the possession of a person identified in the notice, or
                  (iii) that party B has no knowledge, information or belief as to the existence or whereabouts of the document.
          (2) For the purposes of subrule (1):
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read cf Bidald Consulting Pty Ltd v Miles Special Builders Pty Lt... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NSWSC 977
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court involved a dispute between Bidald Consulting Pty Ltd and Miles Special Builders Pty Ltd. The primary issue centred on the interpretation and application of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, specifically regarding notices to produce documents and the timelines for compliance. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The central legal questions were whether an order was necessary to reduce the time for compliance if a notice to produce was served with less than 14 days' notice, whether a notice to produce could be considered valid in part, the burden of proof concerning the reasonableness of the time for document production, and the relevance of an impending trial to the assessment of the reasonableness of the production time.

The court considered the procedural rules and statutory provisions governing notices to produce. It held that while a notice to produce cannot be deemed valid in part, the court has the discretion to abridge the time for compliance if the original notice was served with insufficient notice. The court also outlined that the party seeking an extension has the onus of proving that the time for production was unreasonable, particularly in light of the imminent trial date. The relevance of the pending trial was factored into the assessment of reasonableness, with the court acknowledging that shorter timelines might be justified if the trial was imminent.

The Supreme Court concluded that while the notice to produce was not entirely invalid, the time for compliance could be abridged due to the short notice. The onus of proof concerning the reasonableness of the production time was placed on the party seeking an extension, and the impending trial was a relevant factor. The court granted the application to abridge the time for compliance, thereby allowing the defendant more time to produce the necessary documents. This decision underscored the importance of considering both procedural fairness and the practicalities of trial preparation in similar cases in the future.

Background

Background to the litigation

Bidald Consulting Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) and Miles Special Builders Pty Ltd (the defendant) were involved in a legal dispute concerning the production of documents. The plaintiff issued a notice to produce documents to the defendant on 16 April 2020, requiring the defendant to produce documents by 21 April 2020. The plaintiff subsequently applied for an order that the time for compliance with the notice to produce be abridged as the notice was served requiring production in less than 14 days. The defendant opposed the application on the grounds that the notice to produce was invalid in part and that the time for production of the documents was reasonable. The trial of the matter was imminent, and the parties were in the process of finalising their discovery.

The matter came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales in the Commercial List. The plaintiff applied for an order that the time for compliance with the notice to produce be abridged. The defendant opposed the application and filed an affidavit in response. The matter was heard by Justice Nye on 20 April 2020.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether an order is required abridging the time for compliance with a notice to produce if the notice was served requiring production in less than 14 days.
2. Whether a notice to produce can be valid in part.
3. What is the onus of proof concerning the reasonableness of the time for production of documents pursuant to a notice to produce.
4. What is the relevance of an immediately pending trial to the reasonableness of the time period for production of documents pursuant to a notice to produce.

Held
1. The court held that an order abridging the time for compliance with a notice to produce is not required if the notice was served requiring production in less than 14 days.
2. The court held that a notice to produce can be valid in part.
3. The court held that the onus of proof concerning the reasonableness of the time for production of documents pursuant to a notice to produce is on the party seeking the order.
4. The court held that the relevance of an immediately pending trial to the reasonableness of the time period for production of documents pursuant to a notice to produce is that it may be a factor to consider in determining reasonableness.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules and the principles of procedural fairness in determining whether an order was required to abridge the time for compliance with a notice to produce if the notice was served requiring production in less than 14 days. The court found that there was no requirement for such an order as the notice was validly served and the time for compliance was reasonable. The court also considered whether a notice to produce can be valid in part and held that it can be, as long as the notice complies with the relevant rules and principles.

The court examined the onus of proof concerning the reasonableness of the time for production of documents pursuant to a notice to produce and held that it is on the party seeking the order. The court considered the principles of procedural fairness and the need to balance the rights of the parties in determining the reasonableness of the time for production. The court found that the onus of proof was on the party seeking the order and that the time for production must be reasonable in the circumstances.

Finally, the court considered the relevance of an immediately pending trial to the reasonableness of the time period for production of documents pursuant to a notice to produce. The court found that the pending trial may be a factor to consider in determining the reasonableness of the time period, as the need for timely production of documents may be more pressing in the context of an upcoming trial. However, the court held that the pending trial is not the only factor to consider and that the reasonableness of the time period must be determined on a case-by-case basis.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the onus of proof concerning the reasonableness of the time for production of documents pursuant to a notice to produce is on the party seeking the order, and that the relevance of an immediately pending trial to the reasonableness of the time period for production of documents is a factor to consider in determining reasonableness. The decision also establishes that a notice to produce can be valid in part and that an order abridging the time for compliance with a notice to produce is not required if the notice was served requiring production in less than 14 days.