Central City Pty Ltd v Montevento Holdings Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

CITATION:   CENTRAL CITY PTY LTD -v- MONTEVENTO HOLDINGS PTY LTD [2010] WASC 133

CORAM:   MASTER SANDERSON

HEARD:   11 MARCH & 22 APRIL 2010

DELIVERED          :   11 JUNE 2010

FILE NO/S:   COR 46 of 2009

BETWEEN:   CENTRAL CITY PTY LTD

Plaintiff

AND

MONTEVENTO HOLDINGS PTY LTD
Defendant

Catchwords:

Corporations law - Application to set aside statutory demand - Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Nil

Result:

Application dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:     Mr C M Slater

Defendant:     Ms K A Vernon

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:     Oldfield Legal

Defendant:     Butcher Paull & Calder

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Graywinter Properties Pty Ltd v Gas & Fuel Corporation Superannuation Fund (1996) 70 FCR 452

Maria Scaffidi (by her next friend The Public Trustee) v Scaffidi Holdings Pty Ltd [2010] WASC 29

  1. MASTER SANDERSON:  This is the plaintiff's application to set aside a statutory demand.  The first affidavit in support of the application was sworn by Giuseppe Diego Scaffidi on 12 March 2009.  Appearing as annexure GDS1 to that affidavit is a copy of the statutory demand.  The amount demanded is $1,439,010.  Attached to the demand is an affidavit sworn 20 February 2009 by of Mr Eugenio Scaffidi who is the director of the defendant and the brother of Mr Giuseppe Scaffidi.  In his affidavit Mr Eugenio Scaffidi explains that on or about 19 March 2005 the defendant lent to the plaintiff the sum of $1,800,000.  There has been repayment of part of that sum but according to Mr Eugenio Scaffidi the amount of the demand remains outstanding. 

  2. There is nothing in the affidavit which suggests the original loan was evidenced in writing.  Nor is there any reference to any terms as to repayment of the loan either written or oral.  However, Mr Eugenio Scaffidi's affidavit does say that the defendant is trustee of the Scaffidi Family Trust.  He also says that at the time the loan was made it was made by Scaffidi Holdings Pty Ltd which at that stage was the trustee of the Scaffidi Family Trust  He also annexes to his affidavit a copy of the Scaffidi Trust Financial Statements for the years ended 30 June 2006 and 30 June 2007.  In these financial statements the amount of the demand is shown as being due and payable by the debtor to the creditor. 

  3. In his affidavit Mr Giuseppe Scaffidi offers three reasons why the amount demanded is not payable.  First, he says the defendant is not in fact the trustee of the Scaffidi Family Trust.  He alleges the defendant was not properly appointed as trustee.  Second, he says the money advanced by the Scaffidi Family Trust to the defendant was not a loan but was an equity contribution.  He says pursuant to the terms upon which the equity contribution was made there is presently no obligation on the plaintiff to repay the Scaffidi Family Trust.  Thirdly, he says there are defects in the demand which should lead to the demand being set aside. 

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Central City Pty Ltd v Montevento Holdings Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] WASC 133
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Central City Pty Ltd v Montevento Holdings Pty Ltd, the primary focus was on the dispute concerning a statutory demand filed against Central City by Montevento. The matter was adjudicated by the Federal Court of Australia, highlighting the complexities surrounding corporations law and the procedural requirements for setting aside statutory demands. The crux of the dispute lay in Central City's application to have the statutory demand set aside, arguing that there existed an off-setting claim that should be considered. This argument was initially not raised in the initial affidavit supporting the application but was instead introduced in a subsequent affidavit.

The court was tasked with determining whether Central City's late introduction of the off-setting claim argument was permissible under the law. The key legal issue revolved around the procedural correctness of raising such an argument after the initial affidavit had been filed. The court referenced the precedent set in Graywinter Properties Pty Ltd v Gas & Fuel Corporation Superannuation Fund, where it was established that any argument supporting a plaintiff's position must be included in the initial affidavit. The court had to assess whether Central City's procedural misstep warranted the dismissal of their application to set aside the statutory demand.

In delivering the judgment, the court adhered to the established precedent, holding that any new arguments introduced in a subsequent affidavit after the initial application to set aside a statutory demand is impermissible. The court found that Central City's failure to include the off-setting claim argument in the initial affidavit meant that it could not be considered as a basis for setting aside the demand. Consequently, the court dismissed Central City's application to set aside the statutory demand. The court noted that it would hear submissions from both parties regarding the costs of the proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

Central City Pty Ltd issued a statutory demand to Montevento Holdings Pty Ltd for the payment of a debt. Montevento Holdings Pty Ltd subsequently filed an application to set aside the statutory demand, supported by an initial affidavit. After the application was filed and the initial affidavit was submitted, Central City Pty Ltd attempted to raise an off-setting claim in a subsequent affidavit, arguing that this off-setting claim could be the basis for setting aside the statutory demand. The matter proceeded to court to determine the validity of the application to set aside the statutory demand, with a focus on the timing and admissibility of the off-setting claim.

The case came before the court following the filing of an application to set aside a statutory demand by Montevento Holdings Pty Ltd. The application was supported by an initial affidavit. After this initial submission, Central City Pty Ltd attempted to introduce an off-setting claim in a subsequent affidavit. The court was required to determine the admissibility and effect of this subsequent off-setting claim on the application to set aside the statutory demand. The matter did not proceed through any prior tribunals or courts before reaching this court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the off-setting claim raised in a subsequent affidavit can be considered as a basis for setting aside the statutory demand.
2. Whether the procedural rule articulated in Graywinter Properties Pty Ltd v Gas & Fuel Corporation Superannuation Fund applies to the current case and mandates the dismissal of the application to set aside the statutory demand.

Held
1. The court held that the off-setting claim raised in a subsequent affidavit cannot be considered as a basis for setting aside the statutory demand.
2. The procedural rule articulated in Graywinter Properties Pty Ltd v Gas & Fuel Corporation Superannuation Fund applies to the current case and mandates the dismissal of the application to set aside the statutory demand.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Subsequent to the filing of the application to set aside the demand and the initial affidavit in support of that application the plaintiff purported to raise an argument there was an off‑setting claim. In Graywinter Properties Pty Ltd v Gas & Fuel Corporation Superannuation Fund (1996) 70 FCR 452 Sundberg J made it plain any argument to support a plaintiff's position must be put in the initial affidavit in support of the application. It is not open to a plaintiff to raise the matter in a subsequent affidavit. That is what has been done here. It is impermissible. Any alleged off‑setting claim cannot be the basis of setting aside this statutory demand. The plaintiff's application ought be dismissed. I will hear the parties as to costs.