CITATION: Centennial Coal Company Ltd v Xstrata Coal Pty Ltd [2009] NSWSC 788 HEARING DATE(S): 22-23 June 2009
JUDGMENT DATE :
11 August 2009JURISDICTION: Equity Division
Commercial ListJUDGMENT OF: Brereton J DECISION: Summons dismissed with costs CATCHWORDS: CONTRACTS – Construction – obligation to use “all reasonable endeavours” to transfer shares and contractual rights to defendant – where shares subject to pre-emptive rights of other shareholders – whether “best endeavours” require invocation of pre-emptive procedure – where both parties accept that consent of existing shareholders would not have been forthcoming – whether plaintiff has thus taken “all reasonable endeavours” – Held: obligations not discharged as future events may make it possible to affect transfer – where contract requires plaintiff to deal with contractual rights for benefit of defendant – whether dependant upon potential for ultimate transfer – Held: independent obligation unless and until transfer effected – REMEDIES – Declarations – Negative declaration – where plaintiff seeks declaration that defendants are precluded from bringing action against plaintiff for breach of provisions in deed because of limitations provisions contained in deed – where claims that may be brought have not been precisely articulated and may never be brought – Held: inappropriate to make declaration LEGISLATION CITED: (Cth) Australian Securities & Investments Commission Act 2001
(Cth) Corporations Act 2001
(Cth) Trade Practices Act 1974CATEGORY: Principal judgment CASES CITED: Hawkins v Pender Bros Pty Ltd [1990] 1 Qd R 135
Hospital Products Limited v United State Surgical Corporation (1984) 156 CLR 41
Hume v Monro (No 2) (1943) 67 CLR 461
Yewbelle Limited v London Green Developments Limited [2006] EWHC 3166 (Ch)
Yewbelle Limited v London Green Developments Limited [2007] EWCACiv 475PARTIES: Centennial Coal Company Ltd (first plaintiff)
Centennial Hunter Pty Ltd (second plaintiff)
Xstrata Coal Pty Ltd (first defendant)
Xstrata Mangoola Pty Ltd (second defendant)FILE NUMBER(S): SC 50072/09 COUNSEL: Mr AJ Meagher SC w MA Jones & Dr EM Peden (plaintiffs)
Mr AJ Bannon SC w GK Rich (defendants)SOLICITORS: Clayton Utz (plaintiffs)
Chang, Pistilli & Simmons (defendants)
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION
COMMERCIAL LIST
BRERETON J
Tuesday 11 August 2009
50072/09 Centennial Coal Company Ltd & anor v Xstrata Coal Pty Ltd & anor
JUDGMENT
1 HIS HONOUR: The Centennial group and the Xstrata group own coalmines in the Hunter Valley. All coal exported from the Hunter Valley is shipped through the port of Newcastle. Since about 2004, the volume of coal that producers have wished to export from the port of Newcastle has exceeded the port's capacity, resulting in large queues of vessels forming off the port and significant demurrage costs. In April 2007, the NSW Government approved an application by the Newcastle Coal Infrastructure Group Pty Limited (“NCIG”) to develop a new coal export terminal at the port, which would provide additional shipping capacity for NCIG shareholders through “ship-or-pay agreements” which each is required to enter into with NCIG. As at August 2007, the first plaintiff Centennial Coal Company Limited…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Centennial Coal Company Ltd v Xstrata Coal Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] NSWSC 788
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the court were whether Centennial Coal had fulfilled its obligation to use all reasonable endeavours to transfer shares and contractual rights to Xstrata Coal and whether certain limitations provisions precluded Xstrata Coal from bringing actions against Centennial Coal for breaches of the contract. The court had to determine whether Centennial Coal's failure to invoke a pre-emptive rights procedure meant they had not used all reasonable endeavours, especially considering the likelihood that other shareholders would not have consented to the transfer. Additionally, the court needed to assess whether Centennial Coal's obligation to deal with contractual rights for the benefit of Xstrata Coal was dependent on the eventual transfer of shares.
The court held that Centennial Coal had not discharged its obligations as there remained a possibility that future events could facilitate the transfer. The court found that Centennial Coal's obligation to deal with contractual rights was independent unless and until the shares were actually transferred. Regarding the negative declarations, the court found it inappropriate to make a declaration that Xstrata Coal would be precluded from bringing actions, as the claims that might be brought had not been precisely articulated and might never be made. The court thus declined to make the declarations sought by Centennial Coal.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the court on the plaintiff's application for declarations and relief from the defendants' potential claims. The case was heard on the basis of written submissions and oral arguments. Prior to this hearing, the parties had engaged in negotiations and attempts to resolve the dispute without judicial intervention. The court considered the submissions made by both parties and the terms of the deed of agreement.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the plaintiff has discharged its obligation to use "all reasonable endeavours" to transfer the shares and contractual rights to the defendant when the pre-emptive rights of other shareholders made the transfer difficult.
2. Whether the plaintiff's obligation to deal with contractual rights for the benefit of the defendant is dependent upon the potential for ultimate transfer of the shares.
3. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a negative declaration that the defendants are precluded from bringing action against the plaintiff for breach of the provisions in the deed due to limitations provisions contained in the deed.
Held
1. The court concluded that the plaintiff had not discharged its obligation to use "all reasonable endeavours" to transfer the shares and contractual rights to the defendant. The plaintiff's obligations were not discharged as future events may make it possible to affect the transfer.
2. The court held that the plaintiff's obligation to deal with contractual rights for the benefit of the defendant was independent unless and until the transfer of the shares was effected.
3. The court dismissed the plaintiff's claim for a negative declaration that the defendants were precluded from bringing action against the plaintiff for breach of the provisions in the deed. The court found it inappropriate to make such a declaration given the uncertainties regarding the claims that may be brought.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the contractual obligation of the plaintiff to use "all reasonable endeavours" to transfer shares and contractual rights to the defendant. The court noted that the shares were subject to pre-emptive rights of other shareholders, and both parties accepted that consent of the existing shareholders would not have been forthcoming. The court found that the plaintiff's obligation to use "all reasonable endeavours" did not require invoking the pre-emptive procedure under these circumstances. The court held that the plaintiff's obligations were not discharged as there was a possibility that future events may make it possible to affect the transfer.
Regarding the second issue, the court held that the plaintiff's obligation to deal with contractual rights for the benefit of the defendant was independent unless and until the transfer of the shares was effected. The court clarified that this obligation did not depend on the potential for the ultimate transfer of the shares.
Lastly, concerning the negative declaration sought by the plaintiff, the court dismissed the claim. The court found it inappropriate to make a declaration that the defendants were precluded from bringing action against the plaintiff for breach of the deed provisions, given the uncertainties regarding the claims that may be brought. The court noted that the claims had not been precisely articulated and may never be brought. The binding principle established by the decision is that the scope of "all reasonable endeavours" must be assessed in light of the specific circumstances, including the practical impossibility of fulfilling certain obligations due to third-party rights.