Cels Enterprises, Inc v Pausewang Nominees Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Cels Enterprises, Inc to registration of trade mark application 937404(21, 35) - CHINESE LAUNDRY - filed in the name of Pausewang Nominees Pty Ltd.

Delegate: Jock McDonagh
Representation: Opponent: Barry Hess, instructed by Patent Attorney Services
Applicant: Ben Fitzpatrick, instructed by Davies Collison Cave
Decision: Section 52 opposition - grounds under sections 41, 42, 44 & 60 not established – registration allowed.  Costs awarded against the opponent.

Background

  1. The applicant, Pausewang Nominees Pty Ltd, applied to register the following trade mark:

Application Number:

937404

Priority date:

 11 December 2002

Goods:

(as amended)

Class 21:  Household or kitchen utensils and containers (not of precious metal or coated therewith); glassware, porcelain     and earthenware not included in other classes

Class 35: Wholesaling and retailing of household goods including cooking and other utensils and containers, crockery and cutlery; fabrics; manchester including bath towels, washers, tablecloths, serviettes and bed linen including sheets, pillow cases, doonas and pillows; bathroom accessories including brushes, combs, soap dishes and toothbrush containers; toiletry products; furniture

Trade Mark:

chinese laundry

Advertised: 19 June 2003
  1. The opponent, Cels Enterprises, Inc, filed notice of opposition to the trade mark's registration on 19 September 2003.  That notice listed variously 13 of the available grounds of opposition provided in the Trade Marks Act 1995 ("the Act"). 

  2. The opponent duly served and filed evidence in support. The applicant did not serve or file any evidence.

  3. By letter dated 19 May 2005, the opponent sought to serve and file further evidence in support of the opposition. By letter dated 1 June 2005, I advised that I did not intend to grant the request, but that I would entertain further submissions in respect of the proposed evidence at the hearing of the substantive matter.

  4. The matter came to a hearing before me, as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, in Melbourne on 9 June 2005. Mr Barry Hess of counsel, instructed by Patent Attorney Services, Attorneys, represented the opponent. Mr Ben Fitzpatrick of counsel instructed by Davies Collison Cave, Attorneys, represented the applicant.

    Evidence

  5. The evidence relating to the opposition consists of the following declarations:

Declarant Date declared Exhibits Known As
Evidence in Support
Robert L. Goldman 18.02.04 RLG1 Goldman
Brendan Ainsworth 01.06.04 Ainsworth 1
John Pembroke Page 11.06.04 JPP1 – JPP11 Page
Guru Kahlon 30.06.04 Kahlon
Chris Zammit 09.07.04 PD-1 to PD-6 Zammit
Brendan Ainsworth 19.06.04 Ainsworth 2
  1. The further evidence in support that the opponent sought to serve upon the applicant and file with this Office was an adverse examination report with respect to the opponent’s trademark application number 1041292 filed on 11 February 2005.  The trade mark examiner had cited the applicant’s registration number 406067 and the application 937404 against the registration and made some comments in respect of the cited marks.

  2. Counsel for the opponent referred to Ladd v Marshall (1954) 1 WLR 1487 as providing the relevant criteria to be applied in respect…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cels Enterprises, Inc v Pausewang Nominees Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] ATMO 51
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter came before Jock McDonagh, a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, concerning an opposition by Cels Enterprises, Inc. (the opponent) to the trade mark application of Pausewang Nominees Pty Ltd (the applicant). The dispute centred on the opponent's attempt to introduce further evidence, specifically an adverse examination report relating to its own trade mark application, into the opposition proceedings. The applicant opposed the admission of this evidence, raising concerns about its relevance and potential policy implications.

The primary legal issues before the delegate were whether the further evidence sought to be adduced by the opponent should be admitted, and if so, what weight it should be given. The opponent relied on the criteria established in *Ladd v Marshall* for the admission of fresh evidence, arguing that the examination report was relevant to grounds of opposition concerning the similarity of goods and that an examiner's opinion carried significant weight. Conversely, the applicant contended that the examiner's opinion was not relevant to the opposition proceedings and that admitting such evidence, particularly when it appeared the opponent had obtained a trade mark for the purpose of generating this report, would set an undesirable policy precedent.

The delegate refused to admit the further evidence. Applying the *Ladd v Marshall* criteria, the delegate found that the evidence, which came into existence more than two years after the applicant's priority date and over a year after the notice of opposition was filed, was unlikely to have an important effect on the outcome as it was not relevant to the opposition proceedings. While acknowledging the opponent's submissions, the delegate also agreed that it would be an unwise policy to accept such evidence late in proceedings, even without direct evidence of ulterior motives for the opponent's trade mark application. The delegate then considered the grounds of opposition pressed by the opponent, ultimately finding that the opponent had not established its grounds, including those under sections 44, 60, 42, and 41 of the relevant legislation.

Consequently, the delegate ordered that the applicant's trade mark could proceed to registration one month from the date of the decision, unless an appeal was filed. The delegate also awarded costs against the opponent in favour of the applicant.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The matter came to a hearing before me, as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, in Melbourne on 9 June 2005. Mr Barry Hess of counsel, instructed by Patent Attorney Services, Attorneys, represented the opponent. Mr Ben Fitzpatrick of counsel instructed by Davies Collison Cave, Attorneys, represented the applicant.Evidence The evidence relating to the opposition consists of the following declarations: The further evidence in support that the opponent sought to serve upon the applicant and file with this Office was an adverse examination report with respect to the opponent’s trademark application number 1041292 filed on 11 February 2005. The trade mark examiner had cited the applicant’s registration number 406067 and the application 937404 against the registration and made some comments in respect of the cited marks. Counsel for the opponent referred to Ladd v Marshall (1954) 1 WLR 1487 as providing the relevant criteria to be applied in respect of further evidence. These criteria are:· it should be shown that with reasonable diligence the evidence could not have been obtained earlier· it should be shown that the evidence is likely to have an important effect on the outcome· the evidence should be credible Counsel for the opponent stated that the first examination report was not received by the opponent until 9 May 2005. He stated that the report was relevant to grounds of opposition, especially with regard to similarity of goods. He further stated that the credibility of a trade mark examiner’s opinion regarding such matters must be considered as at a high level. Counsel for the applicant made strenuous submissions that the further evidence should not be allowed. He was particularly concerned about a policy issue that he considered arose where it appeared that the opponent had applied for a trade mark for the purposes of obtaining an adverse examination report to be used in evidence. Mr Fitzpatrick also submitted that the opinion of a trade mark examiner in respect of the opponent’s application was not relevant to the opposition matter. Alternatively, if the evidence were allowed, it should be given no weight, because it is merely opinion, an unreliable guide and well after the priority date of the applicant’s mark. Despite the helpful and erudite submissions from counsel for the opponent, I maintain my refusal to accept the further evidence. The evidence did not come into existence until more than two years after the priority date and over one year after the notice of opposition was filed. The opinion of a trade mark examiner in a first examination report is not likely to have an important effect on the outcome, because it is not relevant to these proceedings. Additionally, while I have no evidence to support a conclusion that the opponent filed application 1041292 for ulterior or collateral motives, I agree that it would be an unwise policy to accept evidence such as that proposed so late in proceedings.Grounds of Opposition In its notice of opposition the opponent set out variously 13 grounds of opposition. However, at the hearing the opponent only pressed four grounds of opposition as follows:·Section 44 (ground seven)·Section 60 (ground 12)·Section 42 (ground five)·Section 41 (ground three)Onus

Decision

Reasons for decision

I find, therefore, that I am not satisfied that the applicant's mark chinese laundry is not capable of distinguishing the goods and services nominated in the application. I find that the opponent has not established this ground of opposition.Decision The opponent has not established its grounds of opposition. Therefore, the applicant's trade mark may proceed to registration one month from the date of this decision. If the Registrar has been served with a notice of appeal before that time, I direct that registration shall not occur until the appeal has been decided or discontinued.Costs The applicant sought its costs. I see no reason why costs should not follow the general rule. I award costs against the opponent and direct that the opponent pay the costs of the applicant in accordance with the Official Scale (Schedule 8 of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995).Jock McDonaghHearing OfficerTrade Marks Hearings30 September 2005

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.