Cavill v The Commissioner of Water Resources

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

[1989] QLC 50

 
LAND COURT, BRISBANE.

9th November, 1989.

Re: In the matter of appeals under Section 12 of the Water Act 1926 - 1987

Lindsay Roy Cavill

- v -

The Commissioner of Water Resources

(A88-22)

Lindsay Roy Cavill and Joy Verine Cavill

- v -

The Commissioner of Water Resources

(A89-21)

D E C I S I O N

(Hearing at Townsville)

On 16th February, 1988 the abovenamed made application to the Commissioner of Water Resources for a waterworks licence to authorise the installation of a 80 mm centrifugal pump in Major Creek adjacent to Lot 1 Registered Plan No. 40915, Parish of Magenta to irrigate 14 hectares of mixed crops on that parcel of land and 16 hectares of fruit trees and small crops on Lots 1 and 2 on Registered Plan No. 709204, Parish of Rokeby. The application was duly advertised and a number of objections were received. By letter dated 28th February, 1989 the applicants were advised that the Commissioner had decided to grant separate licences addressing the total works applied for in relation to each parcel of land. His decision for separate licences followed a search indicating that Lindsay Roy Cavill was the Registered Proprietor of Lot 1 on RP40915, Parish of Magenta and Lindsay Roy Cavill and Joy Verine Cavill were the Registered Proprietors of Lots 1 and 2 on RP709204, Parish of Rokeby. Accordingly they were deemed separate properties by the Commissioner. The licences which were issued on 6th March, 1989 were issued subject to the general standard conditions of such licences and were also subject to special conditions. Licence 48961 which authorised the 80 mm centrifugal pump adjacent to Lot

1 on RP40915, Parish of Magenta is to supply water to that lot from Major Creek for the

irrigation of miscellaneous vegetables. The special conditions applying to this licence are:-

"1.051The work authorised by this licence shall be installed and used only on the storage of the work authorised by licence number 45114.

1.052Only one pump may be used at any time under the authority of this licence and licence number 48961.

Special Condition:

Notwithstanding the above conditions diversion of water under the authority of this licence may continue whilst surface flows occur of a magnitude precluding, within reason, the construction of the works authorised under Licence no. 45114 and from a spear inserted into the bed sands when water from the storage of the works authorised under Licence No. 45114 has been depleted. Surface flows precluding construction will be considered as those preventing other licencees constructing similar works within Major Creek."

Licence 48961-1 also issued on 6th March, 1989 for an 80 mm centrifugal pump adjacent to Lot 1 on RP40915, Parish of Magenta to pump water from Major Creek for the purpose of irrigating miscellaneous vegetables/fruit trees on Lots 1 and 2 on RP709204, Parish of Rokeby. The special conditions attached to this licence are:-

"1.031Diversion of water under the authority of this licence is prohibited whenever the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cavill v The Commissioner of Water Resources and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1989] QLC 50
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Land Court of Queensland, Lindsay Roy Cavill and Joy Verine Cavill, the appellants, appealed against the Commissioner of Water Resources, the respondent, challenging the granting of two separate waterworks licences for properties situated on Major Creek. The appellants contended that the Commissioner had unfairly treated them by issuing separate licences for their properties, which they argued should be considered as a single farming operation. The appellants further argued that the special conditions imposed on the licences were unreasonable and prejudicial.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the Commissioner had the authority to issue separate licences for the appellants' properties and whether the special conditions attached to the licences were justified. The court considered whether the Commissioner had correctly exercised his discretion under Section 12(vii) of the Water Act and whether the special conditions imposed were necessary for the protection of water resources and other licence holders.

The court found that the Commissioner had the statutory authority to issue separate licences for each property, as the properties were not contiguous and were registered under different titles. The court held that the Commissioner's decision to treat the applications separately was within his discretion and there was no evidence to suggest that the decision was unfair or unjust. Furthermore, the court concluded that the special conditions attached to the licences were reasonable and necessary to ensure the sustainable use of water resources and to prevent over-allocation of water from Major Creek. The special conditions were found to be beneficial to the licencees and in line with previous decisions of the Land Court.

The appeals were dismissed, and the decision of the Commissioner was affirmed. The court held that the appellants had failed to demonstrate that the licences or the special conditions were unjust or inappropriate within the scope of the appeal grounds. The court emphasised that the construction of the sand dam and the use of pipelines across the road reservation were matters for the appellants to decide, and the court had no jurisdiction to compel or prevent such actions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established