Cavanagh v Manning Valley Race Club Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 

CITATION:

Cavanagh v Manning Valley Race Club Limited [2023] NSWPIC 291

APPLICANT: Anthony Cavanagh
RESPONDENT: Moonee Valley Race Club Ltd
PRINCIPAL MEMBER: Glenn Capel
DATE OF DECISION: 20 June 2023
CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS COMPENSATION - Assessment of costs; Court of Appeal ordered the respondent to pay the applicant’s costs in respect of the substantive proceedings in the District Court and in the Court of Appeal in accordance with Schedule 7 of the Workers Compensation Regulation 2016; parties unable to reach agreement before and after a preliminary conference; applicant withdrew claim for some disbursements and sought the maximum costs in accordance with Schedule 7; disbursements agreed apart from the fees for an engineer’s report and an accountant who calculated interest; itemised bill quantified professional costs of $151,990.85 inclusive of GST; bill on assessment reduced to $118,533.25 inclusive of GST; Held – it was reasonable for the applicant to retain an expert engineer and an accountant; their fees were fair and reasonable and not unreasonably incurred; respondent ordered to pay $93,694.40 inclusive of GST being the maximum payable for professional costs in accordance with Schedule 7, plus disbursements as agreed or assessed, including the applicant’s cost assessor’s fees; respondent ordered to pay the Personal Injury Commission’s costs of the assessment.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:

The Commission notes:

1. The Consent Orders filed in the Supreme Court, Court of Appeal, in matter no. 2021/00199371 ordered that the respondent pay the applicant’s costs in respect of the substantive proceedings in the District Court and of the appeal in accordance with Schedule 7 of the Workers Compensation Regulation 2016.

The Commission orders:

2.     The respondent to pay to the applicant’s solicitor the following within 28 days of this assessment:

(a)    professional costs in the sum of $93,694.40 inclusive of GST;

(b)    disbursements in the sum of $44,159.47 inclusive of GST, and

(c)    costs of the assessment in the sum of $11,833.53 inclusive of GST in respect of the fees of National Costing Lawyers Pty Ltd.

3.      The respondent to pay to the Commission within 28 days of this assessment the following:

costs of the assessment in the sum of $4,801.30.

(a)     

STATEMENT OF REASONS

BACKGROUND

  1. Anthony Cavanagh (the applicant) sustained injury to his neck and right shoulder during the course of his employment with Manning River Race Club Ltd (the respondent) between June 1999 and 25 February 2011. He was incapacitated for work until 27 July 2018.

  2. Liability was accepted by Racing NSW (the insurer) and weekly compensation, lump sum compensation and medical expenses in the sum of $89,184.11 were paid.

  3. The applicant commenced proceedings for lump sum compensation in the Workers Compensation Commission (the Commission) on 27 June 2019 in matter no. 3173/19.

  4. In a Medical Assessment Certificate dated 22 October 2019, the applicant was assessed as having 27% whole person impairment of the cervical spine due to injury sustained on
    25 February 2011.

  5. On 20 January 2020, the applicant filed an Application for Mediation in matter no. 240/20 in the Commission.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cavanagh v Manning Valley Race Club Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWPIC 291
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Cavanagh v Manning Valley Race Club Limited was a case in which the applicant sought an assessment of costs under the Workers Compensation Regulation 2016 (NSW). The applicant, who had previously withdrawn some of their claims for disbursements, argued that the remaining costs were reasonable and necessary. The case was heard in the New South Wales Court of Appeal. The respondent, Manning Valley Race Club Limited, disputed the amount of the costs and argued that some of the fees were excessive and unreasonable. The applicant sought the maximum costs allowable under Schedule 7 of the Workers Compensation Regulation 2016, while the respondent argued that the fees should be reduced.

The primary issue before the court was whether the costs claimed by the applicant were reasonable and necessary, and whether the fees charged by the expert engineer and the accountant were fair and reasonable. The court had to determine if the costs were incurred in the ordinary course of the proceedings and if they were necessary and reasonable in the circumstances. The court also had to assess whether the fees claimed were in line with the rates set out in Schedule 7 of the Workers Compensation Regulation 2016.

The court held that it was reasonable for the applicant to retain an expert engineer and an accountant to assist with the proceedings. The court found that the fees charged by the expert engineer and the accountant were fair and reasonable and not unreasonably incurred. The court assessed the professional costs and reduced the amount claimed by the applicant. The court ordered the respondent to pay the maximum payable for professional costs in accordance with Schedule 7, plus the disbursements as agreed or assessed, including the applicant’s cost assessor’s fees. The court also ordered the respondent to pay the Personal Injury Commission’s costs of the assessment.

In conclusion, the court found in favour of the applicant and ordered the respondent to pay the costs claimed in the assessment. The court held that the costs claimed were reasonable and necessary, and that the fees charged by the expert engineer and the accountant were fair and reasonable. The court’s decision provides guidance on the assessment of costs in workers compensation cases and the factors that should be considered when determining whether costs are reasonable and necessary.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute between the applicant, Cavanagh, and the respondent, Manning Valley Race Club Limited, concerning the assessment of costs related to workers' compensation. The applicant, who had previously withdrawn a claim for some disbursements, sought the maximum allowable costs according to Schedule 7 of the Workers Compensation Regulation 2016. The applicant submitted an itemised bill for professional costs amounting to $151,990.85 inclusive of GST. This was subsequently reduced to $118,533.25 inclusive of GST following an assessment. The primary points of contention were the fees for an engineer's report and an accountant who calculated interest. The applicant argued it was reasonable to retain both an expert engineer and an accountant, and that their fees were fair and reasonable. The matter proceeded to the Court of Appeal following an inability of the parties to reach an agreement on costs both before and after a preliminary conference.

The matter originated in the District Court where the applicant initially pursued a claim for costs under workers' compensation. Following an unsuccessful attempt to reach an agreement on costs, the matter was appealed to the Court of Appeal. The applicant subsequently withdrew part of their claim for disbursements and sought the maximum allowable costs under Schedule 7. The Court of Appeal assessed the professional costs, reducing the amount claimed by the applicant. The Court of Appeal found it reasonable for the applicant to retain the expert engineer and the accountant, and that the fees charged were fair and reasonable. The Court ordered the respondent to pay the reduced amount of $93,694.40 inclusive of GST, which represented the maximum payable for professional costs in accordance with Schedule 7. Additionally, the respondent was ordered to pay the Personal Injury Commission's costs for the assessment.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was it reasonable for the applicant to retain an expert engineer and an accountant in the circumstances of this case?
2. Were the fees charged by the expert engineer and the accountant fair and reasonable?
3. Should the fees for the expert engineer and the accountant be considered as reasonably incurred costs?
4. What is the maximum amount payable for professional costs in accordance with Schedule 7 of the Workers Compensation Regulation 2016?
5. Should the respondent pay the Personal Injury Commission’s costs of the assessment?

Held
1. The court concluded that it was reasonable for the applicant to retain an expert engineer and an accountant in the circumstances of this case.
2. The court determined that the fees charged by the expert engineer and the accountant were fair and reasonable.
3. The court ruled that the fees for the expert engineer and the accountant should not be considered as unreasonably incurred costs.
4. The court established that the maximum amount payable for professional costs in accordance with Schedule 7 of the Workers Compensation Regulation 2016 was $93,694.40 inclusive of GST.
5. The court ordered the respondent to pay the Personal Injury Commission’s costs of the assessment.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In determining whether it was reasonable for the applicant to retain an expert engineer and an accountant, the court considered the complexity of the case and the necessity of expert evidence to properly assess the applicant's claims. Given the nature of the injuries and the technical nature of the evidence required, the court found that the retention of these experts was justified. The court then assessed the reasonableness of the fees charged by these experts, taking into account industry standards and the services provided. It concluded that the fees were commensurate with the services rendered and did not exceed what would be considered fair and reasonable in the circumstances. The court further held that these fees should not be categorised as unreasonably incurred costs, thereby allowing them to be claimed against the respondent. Regarding the maximum payable for professional costs, the court referred to Schedule 7 of the Workers Compensation Regulation 2016, which provides for a cap on such costs. The court determined that the applicant's costs, after assessment, did not exceed this cap. Finally, the court ordered the respondent to pay the Personal Injury Commission’s costs of the assessment, which was a matter of statutory obligation under the relevant legislation. This decision reinforces the importance of expert evidence in complex workers compensation cases and the need for a fair assessment of professional costs.