CATINARI v Ashford Apartments P/L

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Appeal from a Master: Civil)

CATINARI v ASHFORD APARTMENTS P/L & ANOR

[2013] SASC 187

Judgment of The Honourable Justice David

29 November 2013

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - INTERFERENCE WITH DISCRETION OF COURT BELOW - IN GENERAL

CORPORATIONS - FORMATION - REGISTRATION OR INCORPORATION - DEREGISTRATION

The first respondent applied pursuant to s 601AH(2) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) for an order that ASIC reinstate the registration of a company. The appellant, the former director of the company the subject of the application, was joined as second defendant and actively opposed the application. A Master granted the order that ASIC reinstate the registration of the company and ordered the appellant to pay the costs of the first respondent’s application.

Held: appeal dismissed - the Master was correct in regarding the first respondent as a ‘person aggrieved’ by the deregistration of the company – Master’s reasons do not indicate any error in approach to the exercise of the discretion or award of costs.

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 601AH(2), s 601AA, referred to.
Newfront Pty Limited (Deregistered) (ACN 053 228 489) [2008] SASC 127; Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Australian Securities & Investments Commission (2000) 174 ALR 688; Ashford Apartments Pty Ltd v Australian Securities & Investments Commission & Anor (Judge Withers, 17 July 2013, unreported); Ashford Apartments Pty Ltd v Australian Securities & Investments Commission & Anor (No 2) (Judge Withers, 16 August 2013, unreported); Re G A and R J Elliot Pty Limited; Ex parte Mitcham (1978) 3 ACLR 523; Piccoli Tesori Pty Limited (2006) 151 FCR 109; GIS Electrical Pty Limited v Melsom (2002) 172 FLR 218; Jason Newham v Australian Securities and Investment Commission (2000) 35 ACSR 147, considered.

CATINARI v ASHFORD APARTMENTS P/L & ANOR
[2013] SASC 187

Appeal from a Master

  1. DAVID J:   This is an appeal against the decision of a Master granting an application for the reinstatement of the registration of a company pursuant to s 601AH(2) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (“the Act”).

    Introduction

  2. The appellant is the former director of Commercial & General Projects Pty Limited (ACN 085 133 197) (“the company”), being the company whose registration the first respondent has sought to reinstate.  The first respondent in this matter engaged the company in January 2006 to undertake certain construction works, which are now the subject of Magistrates Court proceedings.  The second respondent, the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (“ASIC”), did not wish to be appear or be heard before the Master or on the appeal and will abide my decision.

  3. In January 2006 the first respondent entered into a contract with the company for the construction of an apartment complex in Ashford.  Practical completion of the apartment complex was achieved, though it is a matter of contention as to precisely when.  Regardless, in around December 2011 (subsequent to practical completion being achieved), the first respondent raised with the company a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CATINARI v Ashford Apartments P/L and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] SASC 187
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Catinari v Ashford Apartments P/L involves the appellant challenging the decision of the Master, who ordered the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) to reinstate the registration of a company and directed the appellant to pay the first respondent’s costs on a party/party basis. The Master's decision was based on the authority of section 601AH of the Corporations Act, which allows the Court to order the reinstatement of a company's registration if it is satisfied that it is just to do so. The Master first determined that the first respondent had standing to apply for reinstatement as a person aggrieved by the deregistration and then exercised his discretion to order reinstatement based on four criteria, finding it just and in the public interest for the company to be reinstated.

The central legal issues before the court were whether the Master correctly interpreted the criteria for determining if it was just to reinstate the company's registration and whether he erred in finding the first respondent to be a person aggrieved by the deregistration. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the Master's decision to award costs on a party/party basis was appropriate. The appellant argued that the Master’s decision to reinstate the company's registration and the award of costs were incorrect, but the court found no error in the Master’s approach or reasoning.

The court held that the Master was correct in considering the first respondent a 'person aggrieved' by the deregistration, aligning with the precedent set by Gray J. Furthermore, the Master's exercise of discretion to order the reinstatement was based on a comprehensive analysis of the four criteria outlined in relevant case law. The court found that the Master’s decision to reinstate the company was just, given the circumstances of the case, and that the costs award was appropriate. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed, affirming the Master's decision in its entirety.

Orders

Orders of the court

Held: appeal dismissed - the Master was correct in regarding the first respondent as a ‘person aggrieved’ by the deregistration of the company – Master’s reasons do not indicate any error in approach to the exercise of the discretion or award of costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The appellant now appeals against both the order that ASIC reinstate the registration of the company and the order that the appellant pay the first respondent’s costs on a party/party basis.The decision of the Master The Master delivered judgment in respect of the application for reinstatement of the company on 17 July 2013. The Master referred to the power in section 601AH of the Act. Section 601AH provides:(2)The Court may make an order that ASIC reinstate the registration of a company if:(a)an application for reinstatement is made to the Court by:(i)a person aggrieved by the deregistration;(ii)a former liquidator of the company; and(b)the Court is satisfied that it is just that the company’s registration be reinstated. The Master then proceeded on the basis that he first had to determine whether the first respondent had standing as “a person aggrieved by the deregistration” to make the application and, second, whether in the circumstances it was “just that the company’s registration be reinstated.” The Master dealt with those two issues in turn. In respect of the first issue as to the first respondent’s standing to make the application, the Master set out and adopted the analysis of Gray J in Newfront Pty Limited (Deregistered) (ACN 053 228 489)[1] and concluded:[2]On that analysis the plaintiff is entitled to be treated as a person aggrieved.[1] [2008] SASC 127.[2] Ashford Apartments Pty Ltd v Australian Securities & Investments Commission & Anor (Judge Withers, 17 July 2013, unreported) at [13]. In respect of the second issue, the Master referred to and considered each of the four criteria identified by Austin J in Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Australian Securities & Investments Commission.[3][3] (2000) 174 ALR 688. The Master used the four criteria as the framework for the exercise of his discretion and, in his reasons for determining that it was “just that the company’s registration be reinstated”, the Master stated:[4][16] Criteria one is the circumstances in which the company came to be dissolved. These are circumstances which cast no merit on the second defendant or on the company. The application for the company’s deregistration was lodged with ASIC at a time when the second defendant knew that the company was involved in a dispute and where there was an alleged outstanding liability yet no mention was made of this in the application to ASIC ... In my view, the second defendant’s conduct in obtaining deregistration of the company in the circumstances in which he did, in not notifying the plaintiff of the application made notwithstanding the extensive correspondence entered into, and notwithstanding his awareness that the plaintiff had issued proceedings against the company, entirely lacks merit.[17]It was argued by the second defendant that there was no utility in reinstating the company – criteria two. The company had no insurance from which the applicant’s claim could be met and had no assets. However, it is accepted that there is an indemnity agreement with the company’s parent company such that if the company (Projects) has any liability as asserted by the plaintiff, then the parent company is obliged to indemnify in respect of that liability and to meet the plaintiff’s claim.[18]In my view, it is appropriate and necessary that the company (Projects) be reinstated to be continued as a defendant in the action instituted by the plaintiff. This will ensure that the pre-trial processes normally available to the litigant are available to the plaintiff to require disclosure by the contracting company and if appropriate to seek admissions from the contracting company. It will allow the Court or make findings in respect of the liability or otherwise of the company.[19]It is suggested by the second defendant that prejudice will be suffered by him if the company is reinstated – criteria three – because it would be necessary for a liquidator to be appointed as he is not prepared to continue in the role as director. On a court order for reinstatement, the second defendant will again become the director of the company. How the company chooses to conduct itself from that time is a matter for the company. That does not, in my view, impact upon the appropriateness of ordering its reinstatement.[20]It was suggested that the plaintiff will be able to obtain the relief it seeks by pursuing the parent company on the performance guarantee it provided. It is at least arguable that guarantee only sounds in remedy to the plaintiff if liability is found on the part of the deregistered company ... In all the circumstances it is in the public interest that the company be reregistered to enable the plaintiff’s claim to proceed in an orderly fashion. [4] Ashford Apartments Pty Ltd v Australian Securities & Investments Commission & Anor (Judge Withers, 17 July 2013, unreported) at [16] – [20].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.