[2013] FWCA 2005 |
FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s 225 - Application for termination of an enterprise agreement after its nominal expiry date
Catalina Country Club Ltd
(AG2012/13817)
CATALINA COUNTRY CLUB ENTERPRISE AGREEMENT 2009
Licensed and registered clubs | |
DEPUTY PRESIDENT SAMS | SYDNEY, 17 APRIL 2013 |
Application to terminate expired agreement - opposition of bargaining representative - negotiations for a new agreement - starting point of a 4% wage increase from 1 December 2012 - one-on-one meetings - employer’s difficult financial position - cost savings, reduced hours and services - principles of enterprise bargaining - employer’s guarantee to maintain current rates of pay - limitations on terminating expired agreements - not contrary to the public interest - special and unique circumstances - views of the employees, employer and bargaining representative - application granted - retrospective operation - orders made.
BACKGROUND
[1] This decision will determine an application made under s 225 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (the ‘Act’), which seeks the Fair Work Commission’s (the ‘Commission’) approval to terminate the Catalina Country Club Enterprise Agreement 2009 [AE8713683] (the ‘Agreement’). The Agreement passed its nominal expiry date of 7 September 2012, but continues to operate unless, or until it ceases to operate by the circumstances envisaged by s 54(2) of the Act which are as follows:
‘(2) An enterprise agreement ceases to operate on the earlier of the following days:
(a) the day on which a termination of the agreement comes into operation under section 224 or 227;
(b) the day on which section 58 first has the effect that there is no employee to whom the agreement applies.
Note: Section 58 deals with when an enterprise agreement ceases to apply to an employee.’
[2] The application to terminate the Agreement was made on 28 November 2012 by Clubs NSW on behalf of the Catalina Country Club Ltd (the ‘Club’). The application is opposed by the Liquor and Hospitality Division - United Voice (the ‘Union’), a bargaining representative on behalf of a number of the employees of the Club.
[3] At the time of the hearing, the Club operated two sites in Batemans Bay, New South Wales - the Club and the Bowling Club - the latter being acquired by the Club in 2009/10 and which closed in late March 2013. Both sites presently employ 71 staff, 45 of whom are covered by the Agreement. They include the classifications one might ordinarily encounter in a registered club, such as bar stewards, waiters, cooks, general hands in the bar, kitchen and dining areas, gaming room attendants, security, clerical, reception and other administrative staff.
[4] For some months, the Club and the Union have been negotiating a new enterprise agreement. However, to date they have been unsuccessful. In a ballot of the employees, on 1 November 2012, a proposed agreement was rejected by a vote of 7 in favour and 21 against. As a result, the existing Agreement remains in place until replaced or terminated, pursuant to s 54(2)(a) of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Catalina Country Club Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] FWCA 2005
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Commission examined whether the employer's proposal for a new agreement, which included a 4% wage increase effective from 1 December 2012, was in line with the principles of enterprise bargaining. The employer had engaged in one-on-one meetings with the bargaining representative and had indicated its challenging financial situation, necessitating cost savings, reduced hours, and diminished services. The Commission assessed whether the employer's guarantee to maintain current rates of pay and the special and unique circumstances justified the termination of the expired agreement. The views of the employees, employer, and bargaining representative were considered in determining the application's outcome.
The Commission concluded that the employer's proposal was consistent with enterprise bargaining principles, and the special and unique circumstances warranted the termination of the expired agreement. The employer's financial situation and the necessity for cost savings did not render the application contrary to the public interest. The application was granted, with the orders to have retrospective effect from 1 December 2012.