CATACOUZINOS and VICTORIAN BUILDING AUTHORITY

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

CATACOUZINOS and VICTORIAN BUILDING AUTHORITY [2020] AATA 4553 (12 November 2020)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:          2019/4822

Re:CONSTANTINE CATACOUZINOS

APPLICANT

AndVICTORIAN BUILDING AUTHORITY

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:R. Cameron, Senior Member

Date:12 November 2020

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the reviewable decision.

................[sgd].............................

R. Cameron, Senior Member

Catchwords

MUTUAL RECOGNITION – application of Mutual Recognition Act 1992 (Cth) – Queensland registration not equivalent to the Victorian registration – Commercial Builder (Limited to Structural fit out work) refused – Commercial Builder (Limited to non- Structural fit out work) granted – activities carried out under each registration in Queensland and Victoria are substantially not the same – decision under review affirmed

Legislation
Building Act 1993 (Vic)
Mutual Recognition Act 1992 (Cth)

Mutual Recognition (Victoria) Act 1998

Cases

Yousefi and Victorian Building Authority [2018] AATA 3542

REASONS FOR DECISION

R CAMERON SENIOR MEMBER.

12 November 2020

INTRODUCTION

  1. The Applicant has carried on the vocational occupation as a shopfitter for almost 25 years. The Tribunal has no doubt about his experience and dedication to that trade.

  2. The Applicant is the current holder of a Trade Contractor licence issued by the Queensland Building and Construction Commission in the class or category, defined as “Shopfitting (Trade)”.

  3. The Respondent, the Victorian Building Authority (“VBA”) is the regulatory agency in the State of Victoria tasked with the function of regulating building practitioners.

  4. By notice lodged with the Respondent on 17 June 2019, the Applicant sought registration in the following categories of a building practitioner:

    (a)Commercial Builder (Limited to non-structural fit out work); and

    (b)Commercial Builder (Limited to structural fit out work).

  5. The Application by the Applicant to the VBA for registration as a building practitioner in the classes concerned on 17 June 2019, was made under the provisions of section 19 of the Mutual Recognition Act1992 (Cth) (“MR Act”).

  6. The Respondent considered the Application for registration made by the Applicant and the material lodged by him in support of it. After consideration of the Application and supporting material, on 16 July 2019, the Respondent granted an application for registration under the Mutual Recognition Scheme to the Applicant in the class of Commercial Builder (Limited to non-structural fit out work). However, it refused his application for registration under the Mutual Recognition Scheme (as the mutual recognition regime created by the MR Act is frequently called) as a building practitioner in the class or category of Commercial Builder (Limited to structural fit out work). Hereinafter referred to as “the reviewable decision”.[1]

    [1] The reviewable decision is at page 23 of the T documents.

  7. The grounds relied upon by the Respondent to refuse the Application for registration as a Commercial Builder (Limited to structural fit out work) were that it found that the Applicant’s Queensland registration was not equivalent to the registration sought in the State of Victoria. It further concluded that equivalence could not be achieved, as is sometimes the case by the imposition of appropriate conditions, or restrictions on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CATACOUZINOS and VICTORIAN BUILDING AUTHORITY and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 4553
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by the applicant for registration as a Commercial Builder (Limited to structural fit out work) in Victoria under the Mutual Recognition Scheme established by the *Mutual Recognition Act 1992* (Cth). The Victorian Building Authority (the respondent) had granted the applicant registration as a Commercial Builder (Limited to non-structural fit out work) but refused his application for registration as a Commercial Builder (Limited to structural fit out work), finding that his Queensland registration as a Shopfitting (Trade) contractor was not equivalent. The applicant sought a review of this decision.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the applicant met the requirements for registration in Victoria as a Commercial Builder (Limited to structural fit out work) under the Mutual Recognition Scheme. This required the Tribunal to determine if the activities authorised by the applicant's Queensland Shopfitting (Trade) licence were substantially the same as those authorised by a Victorian Commercial Builder (Limited to structural fit out work) registration. The Tribunal also considered whether a Ministerial Declaration under section 32 of the *Mutual Recognition Act 1992* could establish equivalence, noting that no such declaration covered the applicant's Queensland registration.

The Tribunal reasoned that equivalence is established by comparing the actual activities permitted by each registration, not the legal systems of registration themselves. The phrase "substantially the same" was interpreted to mean "in the main" or "as to the greater part." The Tribunal examined the scope of work for a Queensland Shopfitting (Trade) licence, characterising it as the final finishing works for commercial premises, typically involving interaction with the public before an occupancy certificate is issued. This was contrasted with the Victorian registration sought, which involved structural fit-out work.

Ultimately, the Tribunal affirmed the respondent's decision. It found that the activities authorised by the Queensland Shopfitting (Trade) registration were not substantially the same as those authorised by a Victorian Commercial Builder (Limited to structural fit out work) registration, and therefore, the applicant did not meet the requirements for registration in that class under the Mutual Recognition Scheme.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Respondent considered the Application for registration made by the Applicant and the material lodged by him in support of it. After consideration of the Application and supporting material, on 16 July 2019, the Respondent granted an application for registration under the Mutual Recognition Scheme to the Applicant in the class of Commercial Builder (Limited to non-structural fit out work). However, it refused his application for registration under the Mutual Recognition Scheme (as the mutual recognition regime created by the MR Act is frequently called) as a building practitioner in the class or category of Commercial Builder (Limited to structural fit out work). Hereinafter referred to as “the reviewable decision”.[1][1] The reviewable decision is at page 23 of the T documents. The grounds relied upon by the Respondent to refuse the Application for registration as a Commercial Builder (Limited to structural fit out work) were that it found that the Applicant’s Queensland registration was not equivalent to the registration sought in the State of Victoria. It further concluded that equivalence could not be achieved, as is sometimes the case by the imposition of appropriate conditions, or restrictions on the registration of the Applicant in that class of builder. Shortly after receipt of the reviewable decision on 25 July 2019, the Applicant wrote to the Registrar of the VBA seeking a reconsideration of the reviewable decision and then made this application to the Tribunal.[2][2] The Applicant’s letter of that date was in evidence before the Tribunal.THE ISSUE FOR DETERMINATION BY THE TRIBUNAL. The Tribunal considers, as the Respondent has identified in its Statement of Facts and Contentions, the issue for determination is whether the Applicant meets the requirements for registration in the prescribed class of Commercial Builder (Limited to structural fit out work) in the State of Victoria, pursuant to the Mutual Recognition Scheme created by the MR Act.THE HEARING. The Applicant appeared on his own behalf. He did not lodge with the Tribunal any further material beyond a copy of his letter to the Registrar of the Respondent dated 25 July 2019. The Tribunal had documentary evidence before it, consisting of the T documents. In addition, there was, as noted earlier, a Statement of Facts and Contentions. No one gave oral evidence of the hearing. Mr Glyn Ayres of counsel appeared on behalf of the Respondent. Both parties made submissions.THE MUTUAL RECOGNITION SCHEME. The Mutual Recognition Scheme is a creature of the MR Act whose principal purpose is articulated in section 3 of as being to enact legislation authorised by the Parliaments of States under paragraph (xxxvii) of section 51 of the Commonwealth Constitution. It is for the purpose of promoting the goal of freedom of movement of goods and service providers in a national market in Australia. It really goes without saying that it has been applied to enable a variety of professions, vocations and occupations to become extremely portable throughout the Commonwealth. Its goal is to promote trade and commerce.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Another means of establishing an equivalency is by a Ministerial Declaration made pursuant to section 32 “Declarations by Ministers” of the MR Act. This section provides that a Minister from each of 2 or more States may jointly declare, by notice in the Gazette, that specified occupations are equivalent, and may specify, or describe conditions that will achieve equivalence. Unfortunately for the Applicant, this section has no application because there is no Ministerial Declaration covering the Queensland Trade Contractor Licence in the class of Shopfitting (Trade) held by the Applicant for registration in Victoria.[5][5] The Respondent referred to Schedule 19 of the Mutual Recognition (Equivalence of Gaming and Other Occupations) Declaration 2009. (Pages 109-111 of the T documents.) Schedule 19 identifies the list or categories of occupations in the first State and its equivalence in a second State. An examination of that Declaration reveals that the Queensland registration of the Applicant is not identified therein. Therefore, the question is to be resolved by making a determination as to whether the activities authorised to be carried out under each registration in Queensland and Victoria are substantially the same.Are the activities authorised to be carried out under registration in Queensland in the class, Shopfitting (Trade) and Victoria in the class, Commercial Builder (Limited to structural fit out work) substantially the same? Answering this question requires a consideration of what meaning is to be applied to the term “substantially the same” when comparing a Queensland “Shopfitting (Trade)” class of registration and a Victorian class of registration namely “Commercial Builder (Limited to structural fit out work)”. Counsel for the Respondent helpfully referred the Tribunal in submissions to the decision of this Tribunal in Yousefi and Victorian Building Authority.[6] The learned Senior Member in that case provided a useful analysis of the approach to be adopted when answering this question. The following passages are largely taken from that decision as there is no reason to depart from them. There is no requirement that the activities be identical. The section directs attention to the activities to be carried on, not to the legal system of registration. In mutually recognising the equivalence of occupations, it is appropriate to consider whether the activities of the relevant occupations are ‘in the main’ or ‘as to the greater part’ the same. Whether the relevant activities are substantially the same is a question of fact.[6] [2018] AATA 3542 at [34]-[36]. Bearing in mind this approach to determining whether the activities are substantially the same, it is necessary to examine the scope of the work that attaches to the “Shopfitting (Trade)” registration in Queensland and the category of builder class “Commercial Builder (Limited to structural fit out work)” in Victoria. The Scope of Work covered by the Queensland registration of “Shopfitting (Trade) is found in the T documents.[7] For the purposes of these reasons, they need not be reproduced. The essential characteristics of the works enumerated in the document represent what one would expect in the customary definition of a shopfitter’s work. They are the works finally required to finish off or the completion of building works for commercial premises, usually retail or office, involving fairly regular interaction with the members of the public, prior to the issue of an Occupancy Certificate under the applicable building legislation.[7] Page 25 of the T Documents.