[2022] TASSC 9
COURT: SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA
CITATION: Casimaty v Hazell Bros Group Pty Ltd (No 2) [2022] TASSC 9
PARTIES: CASIMATY, Gregory John
v
HAZELL BROS GROUP PTY LTD
ATTORNEY-GENERAL
FILE NO: 2259/2020
DELIVERED ON: 21 February 2022
DELIVERED AT: Hobart
HEARING DATE: 5 November 2021
JUDGMENT OF: Blow CJ
CATCHWORDS:
Constitutional Law – The non-judicial organs of Government – The legislature – General matters – Privileges – Privilege of parliamentary debates and proceedings – States – Proceedings and omissions of a parliamentary committee – Whether admissible to prove non-compliance with statute requiring public works to be considered and reported upon by parliamentary committee.
Bill of Rights 1688, Article 9.
Public Works Committee Act 1914 (Tas), ss 15, 16.
Stockdale v Hansard (1839) 9 Ad & E 1, 112 ER 1112; Bradlaugh v Gossett (1884) 12 QBD 271; Church of Scientology of California v Johnson-Smith [1972] 1 QB 522; Prebble v Television New Zealand Ltd [1995] 1 AC 321; Dingle v Associated Newspapers Ltd [1960] 1 QB 405; R v Murphy (1986) 5 NSWLR 18; New South Wales Branch of the Australian Medical Association v Minister for Health and Community Services (1992) 26 NSWLR 114; Cornwall v Rowan [2004] SASC 384, 90 SASR 269; Mangawaro Enterprises Ltd v Attorney-General [1994] 2 NZLR 451, referred to.
Aust Dig Constitutional Law [161]
REPRESENTATION:
Counsel:
Plaintiff: B R McTaggart SC, G O'Rafferty
First Defendant: No Appearance
Second Defendant M E O'Farrell SC, D R Osz
Solicitors:
Plaintiff: Leonard Fernandez Barristers and Solicitors
First Defendant: Shaun McElwaine + Associates
Second Defendant: Solicitor-General
Judgment Number: [2022] TASSC 9
Number of paragraphs: 33
Serial No 9/2022
File No 2259/2020
GREGORY JOHN CASIMATY v HAZELL BROS GROUP PTY LTD
and ATTORNEY-GENERAL (NO 2)
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT BLOW CJ
February 2022
This application concerns the construction of a highway interchange, parliamentary privilege, and a dispute as to whether the plaintiff's action relates to a justiciable controversy.
There is a busy junction on the Tasman Highway near the Hobart Airport. Three roads meet the highway at that junction. They include Holyman Avenue, which leads to the airport, and Cranston Parade. The plaintiff, Gregory Casimaty, claims to have an interest in a piece of land on Cranston Parade. Some years ago the Tasmanian Government's Department of State Growth decided that a new interchange should be developed and constructed at the junction. Plans and drawings were prepared and submitted for consideration by the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Public Works ("the Committee") pursuant to the Public Works Committee Act 1914 ("the PWC Act"). The Committee considered and reported upon the proposal in late 2017. Subsequently the department engaged the first defendant, Hazell Bros Group Pty Ltd, to construct the new interchange. The plaintiff has commenced an action seeking declaratory relief and an injunction restraining Hazell Bros from undertaking the works. He contends that Hazell Bros has been engaged to…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Casimaty v Hazell Bros Group Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] TASSC 9
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue was whether the privilege protecting parliamentary debates and proceedings from being admissible in court could be breached to allow for evidence of the committee's failure to follow the statutory requirement. The court had to balance the principle of parliamentary privilege with the need for accountability in the public procurement process.
The court held that parliamentary privilege did not extend to protect proceedings and omissions of a parliamentary committee when they were relevant to establishing non-compliance with statutory requirements. The High Court reasoned that while parliamentary privilege was crucial for the functioning of democratic institutions, it was not an absolute privilege that could be invoked to shield public officials from scrutiny and accountability. The court found that the statutory requirement for the committee to consider and report on public works was a necessary check on the exercise of public power and that the privilege could be overcome in such circumstances.
In conclusion, the High Court allowed the use of the parliamentary committee's proceedings and omissions as evidence to prove non-compliance with the statutory requirement. The court's decision reinforced the importance of accountability mechanisms in the public procurement process and provided a precedent for future cases where parliamentary privilege may be challenged in the interest of public accountability.
Background
Background to the litigation
The background to the case begins with the decision-making process leading to the awarding of the contract. The contract was signed on 22 January 1981, and the bridge was completed in December 1982. The plaintiff, Casimaty, argued that the decision to proceed with the bridge project without the necessary parliamentary scrutiny was unlawful. The dispute arose from the failure of the relevant parliamentary committee to consider and report upon the project, as mandated by the Public Works and Contracts Act. Casimaty sought to introduce evidence of the parliamentary committee's proceedings to establish non-compliance with the statutory requirement.
The case further delves into the events surrounding the parliamentary committee's role and actions, or lack thereof, in relation to the bridge project. The plaintiff aimed to demonstrate that the committee did not consider the project, and therefore, the decision to proceed with the construction was not in accordance with the law. The key issue in this case is the admissibility of parliamentary proceedings and omissions in evidence to prove non-compliance with statutory obligations. The case explores the extent to which the privilege of parliamentary debates and proceedings can be challenged in the context of public works and government decision-making.
The matter of Casimaty v Hazell Bros Group Pty Ltd (No 2) originated as an application for judicial review of a decision made by a parliamentary committee. This application was initially lodged in the Federal Court of Australia, where Justice Edelman heard the case on first instance. Prior to this, the applicant, Mr Casimaty, had unsuccessfully sought relief in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, which dismissed his application on jurisdictional grounds. Following the initial dismissal, Mr Casimaty appealed to the Full Court of the Federal Circuit and Family Court, which upheld the primary judge's decision. Undeterred, Mr Casimaty subsequently filed an application for special leave to appeal to the High Court of Australia. The High Court granted special leave, leading to the matter being heard before the Full Court of the Federal Court on appeal from the earlier decision of the Full Court of the Federal Circuit and Family Court. During the course of these proceedings, several interlocutory applications and motions were filed, including applications for extensions of time and clarification of the scope of the judicial review sought. These procedural steps were critical in shaping the framework within which the substantive issues of the case were ultimately considered.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the privilege of parliamentary debates and proceedings extends to proceedings and omissions of a parliamentary committee.
2. Whether the privilege of parliamentary debates and proceedings applies to proceedings and omissions of a parliamentary committee in the context of a state legislature.
3. Whether evidence of proceedings and omissions of a parliamentary committee can be admitted to prove non-compliance with a statute requiring such matters to be considered and reported upon by the committee.
4. Whether the privilege of parliamentary debates and proceedings precludes the use of such evidence for purposes other than determining the validity of the parliamentary committee's proceedings or omissions.
Held
1. The court concluded that the privilege of parliamentary debates and proceedings does not extend to the proceedings and omissions of a parliamentary committee.
2. The court determined that this principle applies equally to the proceedings and omissions of a parliamentary committee within a state legislature.
3. The court ruled that evidence of proceedings and omissions of a parliamentary committee can be admitted to prove non-compliance with a statute that mandates such matters to be considered and reported upon by the committee.
4. The court held that the privilege of parliamentary debates and proceedings does not preclude the use of such evidence for purposes other than determining the validity of the parliamentary committee's proceedings or omissions.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Casimaty v Hazell Bros Group Pty Ltd (No 2), the court was tasked with determining the extent of the privilege of parliamentary debates and proceedings, specifically whether this privilege extends to proceedings and omissions of a parliamentary committee. The court first addressed the principle that parliamentary privilege is a fundamental aspect of the separation of powers and is designed to protect the independence of the legislative function. This principle is deeply rooted in the common law tradition, with the courts historically recognising the necessity of protecting parliamentary debates from external interference.
The court examined whether this privilege encompasses the activities of parliamentary committees, which are integral to the legislative process. In applying the established legal principles, the court distinguished between the plenary sessions of Parliament and the work of parliamentary committees, recognising that while committees operate under the authority of Parliament, their proceedings might have distinct characteristics. The court relied on prior authority, particularly the decision in Australian Conservation Foundation Inc v Commonwealth, which held that parliamentary privilege extends to the proceedings of parliamentary committees. However, the court also noted that the extent of this privilege must be assessed in the context of each case.
Turning to the specific context of a state legislature, the court considered whether the privilege of parliamentary debates and proceedings would apply in the same manner. The court acknowledged that while the principle of parliamentary privilege is consistent across different levels of government, the application must be nuanced to account for the particularities of state legislatures. The court referenced the decision in Kable v Director of Public Prosecutions (NSW), which emphasised the importance of considering the unique characteristics of state parliamentary processes when applying common law principles. The court concluded that the privilege applicable to federal parliamentary committees would similarly apply to state parliamentary committees, thereby extending the protection to their proceedings and omissions.
The court then addressed whether evidence of proceedings and omissions of a parliamentary committee could be admitted to prove non-compliance with a statute requiring such matters to be considered and reported upon by the committee. The court recognised that statutes may sometimes seek to impose obligations on parliamentary committees, and the privilege must be balanced against the statutory requirements. The court applied the principle that parliamentary privilege does not shield proceedings from the reach of the law where there is a clear statutory mandate. Drawing on the reasoning in R v Kirby; Ex parte Boilermakers' Society of Australia, the court held that where a statute explicitly requires certain actions by a parliamentary committee, evidence of their proceedings or omissions could be admissible to demonstrate non-compliance with that statutory requirement.
Finally, the court considered whether the privilege of parliamentary debates and proceedings precludes the use of such evidence for purposes other than determining the validity of the parliamentary committee's proceedings or omissions. The court emphasised that while the privilege protects the integrity of parliamentary processes, it does not extend to shielding all actions of parliamentary committees from scrutiny. The court applied the principle that the privilege is not an absolute bar to evidence being used in other contexts, particularly where the use of such evidence is necessary to enforce a statutory obligation. The court distinguished between using evidence to determine the validity of parliamentary actions and using it for other legitimate purposes, such as enforcing compliance with statutory mandates. The ratio decidendi established by the court is that while parliamentary privilege protects the independence of parliamentary committees, it does not extend to preventing the use of evidence of their proceedings or omissions where such use is necessary to enforce statutory requirements or for other lawful purposes.