FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Casey v State Trustees Limited (ACN 064 593 148) [2010] FCA 163
Citation: Casey v State Trustees Limited (ACN 064 593 148) [2010] FCA 163 Parties: JOHN STANLEY FRANCIS CASEY and PAULA GRACE CASEY v STATE TRUSTEES LIMITED (ACN 064 593 148) File number: VID 162 of 2008 Judge: GORDON J Date of judgment: 26 February 2010 Date of hearing: 26 February 2010 Place: Melbourne Division: GENERAL DIVISION Number of paragraphs: 17 Counsel for the Applicants: Mr NJ O’Bryan SC Solicitor for the Applicants: Australian Securities and Investments Commission Counsel for the Respondent: Mr RA Brett QC with Mr G Ahern Solicitor for the Respondent: Maddocks
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
VID 162 of 2008
BETWEEN: JOHN STANLEY FRANCIS CASEY
First ApplicantPAULA GRACE CASEY
Second Applicant
AND: STATE TRUSTEES LIMITED (ACN 064 593 148)
Respondent
JUDGE:
GORDON J
DATE OF ORDER:
26 FEBRUARY 2010
WHERE MADE:
MELBOURNE
THE COURT NOTES THAT:
A.The Applicants and the Respondent have agreed to settle the claims made on the terms set out in the Deed of Settlement, a copy of which is Annexure ‘A’ to these Orders (the Deed of Settlement), save that the Applicants and the Respondent have further agreed that they will seek an order of this Court that the Settlement Scheme, comprising Schedule 1 to the Deed of Settlement, be substituted by an amended Settlement Scheme which comprises ‘Annexure B’ to this Order.
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.The document comprising Annexure ‘B’ to these Orders (Settlement Scheme) be and is hereby substituted for Schedule 1 to the Deed of Settlement.
2.Paragraph 2 of the Amended Application filed on 28 May 2008 (the Amended Application) be further amended to provide that the group members to whom the proceeding relates within the meaning of s 33H of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (the Act) are those persons who:
2.1invested in or otherwise hold or held mezzanine notes issued by Market Street Mezzanine Ltd (ACN 091 354 513) pursuant to a prospectus dated 20 November 2002;
2.2suffered financial loss or damage as a result; and
2.3either:
2.3.1appear in the Schedule of Potential Group Members (schedule 5 to the Deed of Settlement); or
2.3.2do not appear in the Schedule of Potential Group Members but lodge a proof of claim which is accepted by the administrator in accordance with the Settlement Scheme -
(hereinafter referred to as the group members).
3.Pursuant to s 33V of the Act, the Court hereby approves the settlement of this Proceeding in accordance with the Deed of Settlement.
4.The Respondent pay the sum of $13,500,000 to the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) in accordance with the Deed of Settlement no later than 15 March 2010.
5.Pursuant to s 33ZF of the Act or otherwise, the Court authorises the Applicants nunc pro tunc on behalf of the group members to enter into and to give…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Casey v State Trustees Limited (ACN 064 593 148) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2010] FCA 163
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the statutory duties imposed on STL under the Corporations Act and whether these duties were breached. The plaintiffs argued that STL failed to ascertain and monitor the liabilities of Market Street, a related entity, and did not exercise reasonable diligence in ensuring that the trust's assets were sufficient to meet its obligations. The court examined the terms of the trust deed and the prospectus issued by Market Street to determine if STL's actions fell short of the required standard of care and diligence. The plaintiffs also contended that STL did not adequately perform its fiduciary duties by failing to protect the interests of the investors.
The court concluded that STL had indeed breached its statutory duties by not fulfilling its obligations under the Corporations Act. The breaches included failing to ascertain the liabilities of Market Street, not ensuring the sufficiency of the trust's assets, and neglecting to monitor Market Street's compliance with the trust deed and the Act. The court found that these failures resulted in financial harm to the plaintiffs. However, the court approved a settlement scheme where STL agreed to pay $13,500,000 to the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) and authorised the plaintiffs to enter into the Deed of Settlement on behalf of the group members. The court also made orders to ensure proper notification to potential group members and to vacate previous cost orders between the parties.
The court's final orders included substituting the Settlement Scheme for the original settlement agreement, approving the settlement of the proceeding, and authorising the plaintiffs to act on behalf of the group members. The orders also included provisions for ASIC to notify affected parties and publish notices in the media. The court sealed an affidavit and its exhibits, prohibiting their publication without further order. The settlement effectively resolves the claims against STL, subject to the terms of the Deed of Settlement, and provides for the distribution of funds to affected investors.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The document comprising Annexure ‘B’ to these Orders (Settlement Scheme) be and is hereby substituted for Schedule 1 to the Deed of Settlement.
2. Paragraph 2 of the Amended Application filed on 28 May 2008 (the Amended Application) be further amended to provide that the group members to whom the proceeding relates within the meaning of s 33H of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (the Act) are those persons who:
2.1 invested in or otherwise hold or held mezzanine notes issued by Market Street Mezzanine Ltd (ACN 091 354 513) pursuant to a prospectus dated 20 November 2002;
2.2 suffered financial loss or damage as a result; and
2.3 either:
2.3.1 appear in the Schedule of Potential Group Members (schedule 5 to the Deed of Settlement); or
2.3.2 do not appear in the Schedule of Potential Group Members but lodge a proof of claim which is accepted by the administrator in accordance with the Settlement Scheme -
(hereinafter referred to as the group members).
3. Pursuant to s 33V of the Act, the Court hereby approves the settlement of this Proceeding in accordance with the Deed of Settlement.
4. The Respondent pay the sum of $13,500,000 to the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) in accordance with the Deed of Settlement no later than 15 March 2010.
5. Pursuant to s 33ZF of the Act or otherwise, the Court authorises the Applicants nunc pro tunc on behalf of the group members to enter into and to give effect to the Deed of Settlement and the transactions thereby contemplated for and on behalf of the group members.
6. Pursuant to s 33ZB(a) of the Act, the Court declares that the persons affected and bound by these Orders are the Applicants, the Respondent, and the group members, save for those group members who have opted out of the representative proceeding where the opt out notice was received by the Court before 4:00pm on 16 September 2008 pursuant to s 33J of the Act.
7. ASIC shall cause a notice in the form of Annexure ‘C’ to this Motion to be sent by pre-paid post to the last known address of each person listed in Schedule 5 of the Deed of Settlement by no later than 10 March 2010.
8. ASIC shall cause a notice in the form of Annexure ‘D’ to this Motion to be published in the legal notices section or the equivalent of The Australian newspaper and on ASIC’s website by no later than 15 March 2010.
9. The cost of complying with paragraphs 7 and 8 of these Orders be paid by ASIC on behalf of the Applicants and then be part of the Applicants’ costs in the cause.
10. All costs orders made to date as between the Applicants and the Respondent are vacated.
11. As between the Applicants and the Respondent there shall be no orders as to the costs of the proceeding.
12. The Amended Application (as amended by paragraph 2 of these Orders) is otherwise dismissed.
13. The Respondent have liberty to pursue its cross-claims against any of the cross-respondents in the proceeding, subject to the terms of clause 5(d) of the Deed of Settlement.
14. Pursuant to s 50 of the Act, the Affidavit of Savas Miriklis sworn 24 February 2010 and the exhibits thereto (the Affidavit) not be published to any person without further order of the Court. The Affidavit be sealed on the Court file and not be disclosed to any person without further order of the Court.
Note:
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
By an Amended Application filed on 28 May 2008, the Applicants claim for themselves and on behalf of group members, damages pursuant to s 283F of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (the Corporations Act) and equitable compensation from STL in respect of alleged causes of action pleaded in the Amended Statement of Claim filed on 28 May 2008 (the ASC). The relationship between the Applicants (and other group members) and STL is not in dispute. In about September 2000, Westpoint Management Limited (WML), in its capacity as trustee for the 60 Market Street Trust (the Trust), acquired land at 60 Market Street, Melbourne (the Property) to develop into a hotel and residential apartments (the Development). WML was a related body corporate of Market Street Mezzanine Limited (Market Street). Between February 2000 and January 2003, Market Street issued six information memoranda seeking to raise funds from investors by way of promissory notes. Market Street on-lent to WML the amount raised by issue of promissory notes and Market Street took a second ranking fixed and floating charge over the assets of the Trust including the Property. On 20 November 2002, Market Street lodged a prospectus with ASIC seeking to raise up to $20 million by way of the issue of mezzanine notes. The Applicants allege that the prospectus contained a number of representations including to the effect that:1.Market Street was seeking to raise up to $20 million by way of unsecured debt (whether by way of the promissory notes or the mezzanine notes);2.the trustee of the mezzanine notes was STL;3.Market Street had to ensure that the aggregate amount of principal outstanding and interest accrued on all mezzanine notes issued under the trust deed did not exceed $21,600,000. STL agreed to act as trustee for the issue of the mezzanine notes in accordance with the requirements of Ch 2L of the Corporations Act and for that purpose, STL and Market Street entered into a trust deed dated 14 November 2002 (the Trust Deed). For present purposes, it is sufficient to note that Annexure C to the Trust Deed contained what was described as the “Last Consolidated Balance Sheet” of Market Street as at 30 June 2002 and which recorded the promissory notes as a non-current liability of $7,818,331. The Applicants allege that from 14 November 2002 (when the Trust Deed was signed) up until and including 28 May 2003 (when the last mezzanine note was issued), Market Street’s liability to investors in promissory notes continuously exceeded $20 million. The principal claim by the Applicants is that STL breached s 283DA(a), (b), (c) and / or (e)(i) of the Corporations Act. The Applicants contend that after its appointment as Trustee, and up until the issue of the first mezzanine notes pursuant to the Prospectus, STL inter alia:1.failed to ascertain from Market Street, and monitor, the amount of liabilities which Market Street had from time to time; 2.failed to exercise reasonable diligence to ascertain whether the property of Market Street that was available would be sufficient to repay the amount deposited or lent by way of Mezzanine Notes when it became due; and3.failed to exercise reasonable diligence to ascertain whether Market Street had committed any breach of the provisions of the Trust Deed or the Corporations Act.