Carver v Bankstown City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

Land and Environment Court


of New South Wales

          CITATION:
Carver & Anor v Bankstown City Council [1999] NSWLEC 130
          PARTIES
Applicants
Peter George Star Carver and Maxwell Thomas Parker
Respondent
Bankstown City Council
          NUMBER:
40153 of 1998
          CORAM:
Sheahan J
          KEY ISSUES:
Costs :- in Class 4 - indemnity costs - party-party costs - public interest litigation
          LEGISLATION CITED:
          DATES OF HEARING:
04/27/1999
          EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT DATE:

04/27/1999
          LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES:


Applicants
Mr A Hyam, Barrister
Solicitor
Mr Tony Giurissevich

Respondent
Mr Dennis Wilson, Barrister
Solicitors
Mr Adam Seton of Marsdens


    JUDGMENT:

IN THE LAND AND Matter No: 40153 of 1998


ENVIRONMENT COURT Coram: Sheahan J


OF NEW SOUTH WALES 27 April 1999

PETER GEORGE STAR CARVER and


MAXWELL THOMAS PARKER

Applicants

v

BANKSTOWN CITY COUNCIL

Respondent


JUDGMENT


1. This matter came before me again this morning, but I need not repeat all that I said on 22 February, when I recounted its history.

2. These proceedings stand in the name now of two councillors, out of an original three, who remain extremely unhappy with the course of action followed by their council in the aftermath of the destruction by fire on 1 July 1997 of the Bankstown Civic Centre.

3. The class 4 application was filed within a week of the key council resolution of 28 July 1998, but, on 12 August 1998, Lloyd J refused interlocutory relief on the basis of his crucial threshold finding that the evidence then assembled by the applicants did not satisfy him that they had a serious question to be tried.

4. It is fair to say that the two applicants who remained after his Honour's decision have done very little to prosecute these proceedings since they filed their points of claim on 28 October 1998.

5. The council filed its points of defence on 5 November 1998 and its major affidavit on 4 December 1998. The points of defence denied the points of claim in their entirety and Mr Wilson, Counsel for the Council, submits that the affidavit of Mr Dunn dated 4 December completely answered them.

6. The applicants thereafter shifted their attack on the council to an allegation of contempt in respect of the demolition of the remaining foundations of the Civic Centre some time very late in 1998 or early in 1999. (I cannot find in the evidence a firm date). The applicants, in any event, conceded, by early February, that the substantive proceedings had by then ceased to have any utility.

7. The proceedings were discontinued by the filing in Court this morning of the applicants’ notice of discontinuance, without the consent of the respondent, but bearing the date 15 February 1999, which I note to be one week prior to the earlier hearing before me, during which Mr Hyam, Counsel for the applicants, said that the proceedings would be discontinued " in due course ".

8. These proceedings having now been discontinued, and there being in them no order made by the Court in respect of which the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carver v Bankstown City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] NSWLEC 130
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Carver v Bankstown City Council, the applicants, Peter George Star Carver and Maxwell Thomas Parker, challenged the Bankstown City Council's actions following the destruction of the Bankstown Civic Centre by fire. The applicants were dissatisfied with the council's response to the fire and filed proceedings under Class 4 of the Local Government Act. The case was dismissed by Lloyd J, who found that the applicants did not have a serious question to be tried. Despite this, the applicants continued their legal challenge, alleging contempt due to the demolition of the Civic Centre's remaining foundations. However, the proceedings were eventually discontinued by the applicants.

The court was required to determine the costs of the proceedings and whether indemnity costs should be awarded. The court considered the principles of indemnity costs, which are awarded when proceedings are manifestly hopeless or demonstrably devoid of merit. The court found that the proceedings were futile from 31 January 1999, when the remaining foundations were demolished.

The court held that the applicants should pay the respondent's costs on a normal party and party basis from the commencement of the proceedings until 31 January 1999, and on an indemnity basis thereafter. The court reasoned that the applicants should be responsible for the costs incurred by the council due to the futile nature of the proceedings.

The final orders of the court were that the applicants should pay the respondent's costs on a normal party and party basis from the commencement of the proceedings until 31 January 1999, and on an indemnity basis thereafter.