Caruso v Patchett and Insurance Australia Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

MAGISTRATES COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

Caruso v Patchett & Insurance Australia Ltd

Citation:

[2015] ACTMC 10

Hearing Date(s): 18 August 2015
DecisionDate:

8 September 2015

Before:

Magistrate Morrison

Decision:

See [45]

Category:

Interlocutory Application

Catchwords:

CIVIL LAW – appeal against decision of a Registrar refusing an application to amend statement of claim and entering summary judgment for the second defendant – error in statement of claim – principles applying to amendment after limitation period – whether mistake in the name or identity of a party – whether mistake genuine – whether mistake misleading or likely to cause reasonable doubt about identity  - whether leave appropriate - error attributable to solicitor and party personally blameless – appeal by way of rehearing – Registrar’s orders set aside - leave to amend granted and application for summary judgment dismissed.

Legislation Cited:

Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT) r 502-503; 6256

Cases Cited:

Alinta 2000 Ltd v Petkov [2012] WASCA 258

Al Tawwab [1991] 1 Lloyd’s Rep 201

Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University [2009] 239 CLR 175

Bridge Shipping Pty Ltd v Grand Shipping SA(1991) 173 CLR 231
Davies v Elsby Brothers Ltd [1961] 1 WLR 170
Mass (Australia) Pty Limited (CAN 108 657 012) v R & B Crane & Rigging Pty Ltd (CAN 101 925 482) [2008] ACTSC 23

Mitchell v Harris Engineering Co Ltd [1967] 2 QB 703

Parties:

Angela Caruso (plaintiff)
Scott Patchett (first defendant)
Insurance Australia Ltd (second defendant)

Representation:

Counsel
Mr R Crowe SC (plaintiff)
Mr P Woulfe (defendants)

Solicitors
Maliganis Edwards Johnson (plaintiff)

HWL Ebsworth (defendants)

File Numbers:

CS 651 of 2014

MAGISTRATE MORRISON:

  1. The proceedings before me involve an appeal from a decision of the Registrar of this Court.

  1. Appeals from decisions of the Registrar take place by way of rehearing – see rule 6256(4) of the Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT).

  1. The broad background to the proceedings is that the plaintiff was injured in a motor vehicle accident on 12 October 2010. The plaintiff’s vehicle was stationary when struck from behind by another vehicle and pushed forward into a third vehicle.  She lodged a claim with the second defendant which was the insurer of both other vehicles. She commenced proceedings in this Court for damages for negligence on 3 June 2014. Her statement of claim names the driver of the vehicle in front of her as first defendant.  The plaintiff says the relevant limitation period runs from 6 May 2012 when the insurer made its last payment for treatment expenses for the plaintiff.  On 10 June 2015 the second defendant applied for summary judgment against the plaintiff. The plaintiff filed what was in effect a cross application for leave to amend her claim to name the correct defendant that being the driver of the vehicle which struck her from behind. Both applications were heard at the same time and on 25 June the Registrar delivered her decision.

  1. The effect of the Registrar’s decision was to refuse…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Caruso v Patchett and Insurance Australia Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] ACTMC 10
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Caruso, the plaintiff, filed an appeal against the decision of a Registrar who refused an application to amend the statement of claim and subsequently entered a summary judgment in favour of Patchett and Insurance Australia Ltd, the defendants. Caruso sought to amend the statement of claim to correct an error in the name of the defendant. Caruso had initially named Patchett as the defendant but discovered that the correct defendant was Insurance Australia Ltd. Caruso argued that the error was a genuine mistake, not misleading, and did not cause reasonable doubt about the identity of the defendant. Caruso also argued that the error was attributable to the solicitor and that Caruso was personally blameless.

The court had to determine whether the error in the statement of claim could be amended after the limitation period had expired, and if so, whether the mistake in the name or identity of the party was genuine, not misleading, and not likely to cause reasonable doubt about the identity of the party. The court also had to consider whether leave to amend was appropriate, given that the error was attributable to the solicitor and Caruso was personally blameless. The court had to decide whether the Registrar's decision to refuse the application to amend the statement of claim and enter summary judgment for the second defendant was correct.

The court found that the error in the statement of claim was a genuine mistake, not misleading, and not likely to cause reasonable doubt about the identity of the party. The court found that the mistake was attributable to the solicitor and that Caruso was personally blameless. The court held that the principles applying to amendment after the limitation period were not absolute and that the court should exercise its discretion to grant leave to amend if the circumstances warranted it. The court found that the circumstances in this case warranted the grant of leave to amend, and the Registrar's orders were set aside. The court granted leave to amend and dismissed the application for summary judgment.

Orders

Orders of the court

See [45]

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established