Caruana v Director of Public Prosecutions

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE

COMMERCIAL AND EQUITY DIVISION   S CI 2010 00734

IN THE MATTER of applications under section 20 of the Confiscation Act 1997 (Vic)

IN THE MATTER of an offender, SHARON LOUISE CARUANA

SHARON LOUISE CARUANA and ATTILA GAL Applicants
v
DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS FOR VICTORIA Respondent

---

JUDGE:

KYROU J

WHERE HELD:

Melbourne

DATE OF HEARING:

23 November, 8 and 9 December 2011

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

19 December 2011

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

Caruana v DPP

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2011] VSC 658

---

CONFISCATION – Exclusion application – Fraud offences – The offender’s partner, who was not involved in the offences, provided funds to the offender to hold for the partner – The offender’s bank account in which the partner’s funds were deposited became subject to a restraining order – Whether the partner has an interest in the funds – Whether the funds are held on trust – Principles for distinguishing an amount owed as a debt and an amount held on trust – Whether the offender has effective control of the funds – Meaning of ‘effective control’ – Whether the funds are tainted property or derived property – Whether the offender’s interest in the funds was lawfully acquired – Whether the funds are required to satisfy a compensation order – Applications dismissed – Confiscation Act 1997 (Vic) ss 3, 9, 20, 22, 23, 35, 132, sch 2.

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors
For the Firstnamed Applicant  Ms M Wilkening-Le Brun Le Brun Glezakos Lawyers
For the Secondnamed Applicant  Mr P G Adami Stynes Dixon Lawyers
For the Respondent  Ms R Sofroniou Office of Public Prosecutions

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Introduction and summary........................................................................................................... 1

Facts that are not in dispute......................................................................................................... 2

General comments on evidence and credit................................................................................ 4

Relevant statutory provisions...................................................................................................... 5

Facts that are in dispute................................................................................................................ 8

How much money did Mr Gal provide to Ms Caruana?....................................................... 8
What was the purpose of the payment of $60,000?............................................................... 9

Mr Gal’s application................................................................................................................... 13

Matters that Mr Gal must establish....................................................................................... 13
Does Mr Gal have an interest in the $60,000?...................................................................... 14

Principles for distinguishing an amount owed as a debt and an amount held on trust 14
Did Mr Gal transfer the $60,000 to Ms Caruana to hold on trust for him?.................. 16

Is the $60,000 tainted property?............................................................................................ 19
Is the $60,000 derived property?........................................................................................... 20
Was the $60,000 in the effective control of Ms Caruana?.................................................... 22
Outcome of Mr Gal’s application........................................................................................... 23

Ms Caruana’s application........................................................................................................... 23

Matters that Ms Caruana must establish.............................................................................. 23
Does Ms Caruana have an interest in the $60,000?............................................................. 23
Did Ms Caruana lawfully acquire the $60,000?................................................................... 24
Is the $60,000 tainted property or derived property?.......................................................... 25
Is the $60,000 required to satisfy the Compensation Order?............................................... 25
Outcome of Ms Caruana’s application.................................................................................. 25

Proposed order............................................................................................................................. 25

HIS HONOUR:

Introduction and summary

  1. This proceeding involves two applications under s 20 of the Confiscation Act 1997 (‘Act’) for exclusion orders in relation to a sum of $70,000 held in a Commonwealth…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Caruana v Director of Public Prosecutions and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] VSC 658
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Caruana v Director of Public Prosecutions involved an appeal against a confiscation order under the Confiscation Act 1997 (Vic). The offender, who had been convicted of fraud, sought to exclude certain funds from the confiscation order, claiming they belonged to his partner. The partner, who was not involved in the offences, had provided the funds to the offender to hold for her. The offender’s bank account, where the funds were deposited, was subject to a restraining order. The court had to determine whether the partner had an interest in the funds, whether the funds were held on trust, and whether the offender had effective control of the funds.

The legal issues centred around the principles for distinguishing an amount owed as a debt from an amount held on trust. The court also needed to consider whether the offender had effective control of the funds, and if the funds were tainted or derived property. Furthermore, it was necessary to ascertain whether the offender’s interest in the funds was lawfully acquired and whether the funds were required to satisfy a compensation order. The court was tasked with applying the relevant sections of the Confiscation Act 1997 (Vic), including ss 3, 9, 20, 22, 23, 35, 132, and sch 2, to these issues.

The court found that the partner did not have an interest in the funds, as they were provided to the offender to hold for her. The court concluded that the funds were not held on trust, as the partner did not retain any beneficial interest in the funds. The offender did not have effective control of the funds, as the restraining order prevented him from accessing them. The funds were considered tainted property, as they were derived from the offender’s criminal activities. The offender’s interest in the funds was not lawfully acquired, and the funds were not required to satisfy a compensation order. The applications to exclude the funds from the confiscation order were dismissed.

The court’s final orders affirmed the confiscation order, requiring the offender to forfeit the funds in his bank account, as they were tainted property derived from his criminal activities. The court’s reasoning was grounded in the statutory provisions of the Confiscation Act 1997 (Vic) and the principles of distinguishing between debts and trust holdings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established