Cartwright v Steve Little Plumbing & Drainage

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeals: Civil)

CARTWRIGHT & ANOR v STEVE LITTLE PLUMBING & DRAINAGE & ANOR

[2019] SASC 76

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Parker

20 May 2019

PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - PLEADINGS - STRIKING OUT - EMBARRASSING, TENDENCY TO CAUSE PREJUDICE, SCANDALOUS, UNNECESSARY ETC OR CAUSING DELAY IN PROCEEDINGS

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - ADMISSION OF FRESH EVIDENCE

COURTS AND JUDGES - JUDGES - DISQUALIFICATION FOR INTEREST OR BIAS - REASONABLE APPREHENSION OF BIAS GENERALLY

This is an appeal against a decision of a Magistrate to strike out the appellants’ further amended claim against the respondents, and to refuse the appellants’ application for leave to file a proposed second further amended claim.

The appellants’ pleadings in the Magistrates Court went through multiple iterations, each of which was alleged by the respondents to fail to provide necessary particulars and otherwise offend against the rules and practice as to pleadings. Given the appellants had been legally represented from the outset of the proceedings, the numerous opportunities already afforded to comply with the rules of pleading and the prejudice caused to the respondents by their ongoing failure to do so, the Magistrate held that it would not be appropriate to grant the appellants a further opportunity to replead their case.

In substance, the appellants’ six grounds of appeal raise two key issues for consideration. First, whether the Magistrate erred in not considering or otherwise acting upon discovered documents when finding that the further amended claim should be struck out and refusing leave to file a proposed second further amended claim. Second, whether the Magistrate erred in failing to apply r 98(3) of the Supreme Court (Civil) Rules 2006 (SA).

Held, per Parker J, dismissing the appeal:

1.  The fresh evidence which the appellants seek to admit does not meet the second requirement expressed by Denning LJ in Ladd v Marshall, in that it is irrelevant to the issues which fell for determination by the Magistrate (at [25]-[27]).

2.  A failure to plead sufficient particulars to give fair notice of a plaintiff’s case is not excused by an assertion that the particulars can be found in discovered documents, nor by asserting that the defendant already has knowledge of applicable particulars (at [39]-[40]).

3.  The extent to which a defence is inconsistent with discovered documents does not affect the assessment of whether a claim has offended the rules and practice as to pleadings (at [39], [41]).

4.  Error is not demonstrative of apprehended bias. Likewise, the making of findings which are ultimately adverse to a party is, in itself, insufficient to demonstrate apprehended bias (at [43]-[44]).

5.  The Magistrate did not err in relation to the application of r 98(3) (at [52]-[53]).

Magistrates Court (Civil) Rules 2013 (SA) rr 3, 24; Supreme Court (Civil) Rules 2006 (SA) r 98; Listening and Surveillance Devices Act 1972 (SA), referred to.
Ladd v Marshall [1954] 3 All ER 745; Orchard v Orchard (1972)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cartwright v Steve Little Plumbing & Drainage and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] SASC 76
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Cartwright v Steve Little Plumbing & Drainage involved an appeal against a decision of the Magistrates Court of South Australia. The appellants, the Cartwrights, sought damages from the respondents, Steve Little Plumbing & Drainage, for alleged negligence and breach of contract related to plumbing services provided for their residential property. The respondents sought to have the appellants' further amended claim struck out, arguing it was deficient and contained unnecessary and prejudicial material. The appeal focused on whether the Magistrate correctly decided to strike out the further amended claim and deny leave to file a second further amended claim. The court examined the principles for admitting fresh evidence and the adequacy of the appellants' pleadings. The appeal was dismissed, with the court finding the Magistrate correctly struck out the claim and denied leave to file a second further amended claim. The court held that the appellants' pleadings were insufficient and prejudicial, and the Magistrate's decision was consistent with the applicable rules and practice.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the following reasons, I dismiss the appeal.Background On 9 August 2017, the appellants lodged a claim in the Magistrates Court against the respondents for damages in the amount of $100,000. The claim was in respect of plumbing services provided by the respondents to the appellants — specifically, the installation of a subsurface wastewater system on the appellants’ residential property in Crafers. The respondents’ provision of these plumbing services was alleged to have been both negligent and in breach of contract. This original claim was brief with only very limited particulars. All parties to these proceedings were legally represented from the outset. On 10 August 2017, the appellants filed an amended claim. Leave to file this amended claim was not required under r 24(1)(c) of the Magistrates Court (Civil) Rules 2013 (SA). Subsequently, on 29 August 2017, the respondents filed a defence to the claim. Following a conciliation conference held at the Magistrates Court on 9 March 2018, the parties consented to an order granting the appellants leave to file a further amended claim within 21 days. A further amended claim was subsequently filed by the appellants on 9 April 2018. On 28 May 2018, the respondents filed an interlocutory application for the further amended claim to be struck out, and for the appellants to file a second further amended claim providing further and better particulars of paragraphs [7] to [9]. The respondents contended, in a supporting affidavit, that the consent orders for leave to file a further amended claim were made following an agreement between the parties that the further amended claim would only add further and better particulars of paragraphs [7] to [9] of the claim. It was alleged that the further amended claim both failed to provide the necessary particulars, and also contained additional material of an embarrassing nature including conclusions of law, and offended against the rules and practice of pleading. The interlocutory application was heard on 5 June 2018. At the hearing of the application, the appellants acknowledged that there were deficiencies in their pleadings and were granted leave to file an affidavit exhibiting a proposed second further amended claim. An affidavit exhibiting what would be the first of three iterations of the proposed second further amended claim was filed on 30 July 2018. At a hearing on 31 July 2018, the respondents submitted that this first iteration of the proposed second further amended claim remained an embarrassment and still failed to comply with the rules. The respondents’ interlocutory application was listed for argument on 9 August 2018. In advance of arguing the interlocutory application, on 7 August 2018, the appellants filed a further affidavit exhibiting a second iteration of the proposed second further amended claim. This second iteration of the proposed second further amended claim added, among other additions, allegations in respect of a misrepresentation said to be made by the respondents during negotiations in February 2014 to resolve the dispute.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

For the limited purpose of this appeal, the respondents indicated that they did not oppose the admission of the fresh evidence on the basis of its authenticity or by reason of a possible breach of the Listening and Surveillance Devices Act 1972 (SA).Consideration — fresh evidence The principles to be applied on appeal in a civil case on an application for admission of fresh evidence were expressed by Denning LJ in Ladd v Marshall as follows:[3]In order to justify the reception of fresh evidence or a new trial, three conditions must be fulfilled: first, it must be shown that the evidence could not have been obtained with reasonable diligence for use at the trial: second, the evidence must be such that, if given, it would probably have an important influence on the result of the case, although it need not be decisive: third, the evidence must be such as is presumably to be believed, or in other words, it must be apparently credible, although it need not be incontrovertible.These principles were approved by this Court in Orchard v Orchard and subsequent decisions.[4][3] [1954] 3 All ER 745 at 748 (Denning LJ).[4] (1972) 3 SASR 89. However, in respect of the third condition, this Court held that all that is meant by “apparently credible” is “that the evidence proffered is not so patently incredible that it can be said that on the face of it it is not worthy of any credence”: Ventura v Sustek (1976) 14 SASR 395 at 400 (Bray CJ). The respondents indicate that for the limited purposes of this appeal they do not take issue with the first and third requirements, but do object on the basis of the second requirement. In order to admit this fresh evidence I would nevertheless need to be satisfied of all three requirements. However, for the reasons that follow it is unnecessary to consider the first or third requirements in any further detail. I do not consider that this fresh evidence satisfies the second requirement for the admission of fresh evidence, as it is irrelevant to the issues which fell for determination by the Magistrate. Importantly, the issue before the Magistrate was that of the adequacy of pleadings. Her Honour clearly identified a large number of aspects in which the appellants’ pleadings were deficient. The introduction of evidence of a conversation in April 2016 could not have influenced the assessment of the inadequacies of the appellants’ pleadings in November 2018. I therefore decline to admit this fresh evidence.Grounds of appeal The appellants advance the following six grounds of appeal:a. the learned Magistrate erred in finding that the proposed Second Further Amended Claim (“SFAC”) failed to adequately plead the Plaintiffs’ case and failed to afford the Defendants fair noticeb. the learned Magistrate erred in failing to apply Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006, Rule 98(3) in relation to the pleaded representation of the Respondent in February 2014 that gave rise to the Plaintiffs’ claimsc. the learned Magistrate erred in failing to investigate conflicting material between the Defendants’ Defence as filed 29 August 2017 in that it directly contradicted discovered affidavit material of the Second Respondent.d. the learned Magistrate erred in failing to consider and act upon the Plaintiffs’ contention that the Respondents’ pleadings were in direct conflict with discovered affidavits of the Second Respondent and that this resulted in the court being misled in its view of the proceedingse. the learned Magistrate erred in dismissing the Plaintiffs’ claim on the grounds that the SFAC failed to afford the Defendants fair notice of the Plaintiffs’ case when the Defendants have, as pleaded and demonstrated by discovered materials, been privy to the basis and grounds of the Plaintiffs’ claims well before the institution of the proceedingsf. the learned Magistrate erred in determining that it would be prejudicial to the Defendants to grant the Plaintiffs’ application to file the SFAC particularly given the particulars sought by the Defendants over time were exhaustively disclosed in discovered documents and were already known to the Defendants

Decision

Reasons for decision

Following submissions on 9 August 2018, a further adjournment was granted to allow the appellants time to seek counsel’s advice and provide a third iteration of the proposed second further amended claim. An affidavit exhibiting the third (and now final) iteration of the proposed second further amended claim was filed on 20 September 2018. Further submissions were then made to the Magistrate on 27 September 2018.The Magistrate’s decision On 26 November 2018, the Magistrate made the orders against which the appellants now appeal. Her Honour noted that, in the course of submissions on 5 June 2018, the appellants had effectively conceded that the original further amended claim was, in many respects, not a compliant pleading. Her Honour therefore considered this position to be uncontroversial and, consistently with the principles in Allstate Life Insurance Co v Australia & New Zealand Banking Group Ltd, struck out the further amended claim.[1] Thereafter, her Honour considered only whether the third iteration of the proposed further amended claim was compliant with the rules and whether the appellants should be granted leave to file it.[1] (1994) 217 ALR 226. The Magistrate held that the third iteration of the proposed further amended claim failed to comply with the rules of pleading in a number of respects, which can be summarised as follows:·Sufficient material facts and particulars were not pleaded to support each element of the three causes of action pursued — negligence, misrepresentation and breach of contract;·The purported particulars were prolix, unnecessary and repetitious; and·Loss and damage were pleaded, but without particularisation as to how each loss was caused or whether it is common to all causes of action or relevant to a particular cause of action. Her Honour therefore accepted the respondents’ submission that the proposed further amended claim left the respondents without fair notice of the appellants’ claim. Her Honour held that the pleadings left the respondents in a position where they were forced to disentangle the narrative of facts and irrelevant material pleaded to guess which facts were material to each of the three causes of action, an issue which was compounded by the appellants failure to plead all elements of the causes of action relied upon. The Magistrate went on to find that the appellants’ continued reliance on defective pleadings had resulted in protracted proceedings contrary to r 3(1) of the Magistrates Court (Civil) Rules. Given the appellants had been legally represented from the outset of the proceedings, the numerous opportunities already afforded to comply with the rules of pleading and the prejudice caused to the respondents by their ongoing failure to do so, the Magistrate held that it would not be appropriate to grant the appellants a further opportunity to replead their case. Her Honour therefore refused the appellants’ oral application to file the third iteration of the proposed further amended claim.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In respect of the apprehended bias allegation raised for the first time during oral submissions, the respondents submit that this is beyond the scope of the current grounds of appeal and opposed any attempt to expand the grounds to what appeared to be a new ground.[6][6] The appellants have not sought to amend their notice of appeal to add an additional ground in respect of apprehended bias. Rather, they assert that their allegation of apprehended bias is encompassed in grounds (c) and (d).Consideration — grounds (a) and (c)-(f) The appellants’ submissions in respect of grounds (a) and (c) to (f) raise two key propositions for consideration. First, the third iteration of the proposed second further amended claim adequately pleaded the appellants’ case in spite of the deficiencies identifies by the Magistrate, in that the respondents were already privy to the background of their case from discovered documents and their own pre-existing firsthand knowledge. Second, the Magistrate failed to act on the contention that the respondents’ defence contradicted discovered documents. I consider both propositions to be plainly incorrect for the following reasons. As to the first proposition, a failure to plead sufficient particulars to give fair notice of a plaintiff’s case is not excused by an assertion that the particulars can be found in discovered documents,[7] nor by asserting that the defendant already has knowledge of the applicable particulars.[8] A defendant is entitled to rely upon the pleadings as to the case that will be advanced against them at trial, and to which the plaintiff will be confined.[7] See, eg, Boys v Geneva Finance Ltd (rec and mgr apptd) [2001] WASCA 376 at [15] (Anderson J), [1] (Wallwork J agreeing).[8] See, eg, Wunda Joinery Pty Ltd (in liq) v Wunda Projects Australia Pty Ltd [2007] SASC 301 at [8] (Judge Lunn); Palmos v Georgeson [1961] Qd R 186 at 193 (Stable J); Turner v Dalgety & Co Ltd (1952) 69 WN (NSW) 228 at 229 (Taylor J). As to the second proposition, whether or not discovered documents contradict the facts asserted in the respondents’ defence has no bearing on the discretion to strike out the further amended claim or the discretion to refuse permission to file the proposed second further amended claim. Where two parties are in substantial dispute as to the fundamental facts underlying litigation, there will very often be discovered documents which contradict a set of pleadings. The determination of facts in this context is a matter to be resolved at trial, not in the course of a pleadings argument. Whether the respondents’ defence was consistent with discovered documents was wholly irrelevant to the matters which fell for determination by the Magistrate at that time. Her Honour was under no further obligation to unilaterally “investigate” this issue. The extent to which a defence is inconsistent with discovered documents does not affect the assessment of whether a claim has offended the rules and practice as to pleadings. In any event, as the respondents observe, the discovered documents were not in evidence before the Magistrate.