Carthew v Cairns Regional Council

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

CITATION:

Carthew v Cairns Regional Council [2025] QCAT 319

PARTIES:

TIMOTHY CARTHEW

(applicant)

v

CAIRNS REGIONAL COUNCIL

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

GAR293-24

MATTER TYPE:

General administrative review matters

DELIVERED ON:

10 August 2025

HEARING DATE:

23 May 2025

HEARD AT:

Cairns

DECISION OF:

Member Pearce

ORDERS:

The decision of the Cairns Regional Council made on 29 November 2023 in respect of a destruction order for the dog “Ruby” is confirmed.

CATCHWORDS:

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW – DOG

DESTRUCTION ORDERS – where dog attacked members of the public – where dog seized – whether discretion to issue destruction order in respect of the dog should be exercised – where dog had been declared a dangerous dog – effective management of regulated dogs – whether a dog constitutes, or is likely to constitute, a threat to the safety of persons by attacking them or causing fear to the extent that the threat may only be satisfactorily dealt with by the destruction of the dog

Animal Management (Cats and Dogs) Act 2008 (Qld)

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009

(Qld)

Cutbush v Scenic Rim Regional Council (No 2) [2019] QCATA 167

Nguyen v Gold Coast City Council Animal Management [2017] QCATA 121

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

No appearance

Respondent:

M. Dunstan, Preston Law representing Cairns Regional Council

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. In these proceedings Timothy Carthew (“the Applicant”) seeks a review of the decision of the Cairns Regional Council (“the Council”) made on 23 November 2023 to issue a Destruction Order in respect of Mr Carthew’s dog “Ruby” (“the Dog”).

Background Facts

  1. The Applicant is the owner of the dog, Ruby. The dog is a Pitbull cross and is a female.

  2. On 9 November 2023, the victim was attended upon by Queensland Ambulance Service (“QAS”) for serious face, leg and arm injuries sustained from an alleged dog attack that occurred at a homeless camp located at the old drive-in theatre site located at 710-714 Des Chalmers Drive, Woree.

  3. The ambulance officer reported in his statement that the victim had been breaking up a fight between the dog and the male dog named Boof, caused by the male dog getting within close proximity to the dog’s puppies. While breaking up the fight, the victim fell in between the dog and boof, putting herself between the dog and the puppies, causing the dog to react and attack the victim.

  4. The QAS officers attended to significant dog bite injuries to the victim’s face resulting in significant disfiguration to the victim’s nose, causing the exposure of the nasal bone. The victim also sustained deep bite wounds to the right tricep and left thigh, as well as a puncture wound to the left shoulder.

  5. The victim was taken to Cairns Base Hospital where she underwent multiple surgeries to treat the dog bite injuries, including rhinoplasty and skin grafts to treat the injuries to the nose.

  6. On 10 November 2023, the respondent returned to the location of the dog attack and seized the dog as well…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carthew v Cairns Regional Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] QCAT 319
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Carthew v Cairns Regional Council, the applicant contested the respondent's decision to issue a Regulated Dog Declaration and Destruction Order in relation to a dog named Ruby. The respondent, Cairns Regional Council, had determined that Ruby, having attacked members of the public, constituted a threat to public safety. The applicant sought a review of this decision by the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT). The central issue was whether the Council had correctly exercised its discretion under the Animal Management Act 2008 (Qld) to issue a destruction order for the dog.

The Tribunal examined the statutory framework under which the Council made its decision. It noted that the Animal Management Act aimed to provide effective management of regulated dogs and ensure they do not pose a threat to public safety. A regulated dog, as defined in the Act, includes a declared dangerous dog, which is a dog that has seriously attacked or caused fear to a person or animal, or is likely to do so based on its behaviour. The Tribunal also considered the relevant provisions that allow an authorised person to make a destruction order if the dog poses a serious threat.

The Tribunal concluded that the Council had correctly exercised its discretion in making the Regulated Dog Declaration and Destruction Order. The Council's decision was supported by the evidence that Ruby had attacked members of the public, fitting the criteria for a declared dangerous dog under the Act. The Tribunal found that the Council's decision to issue the destruction order was consistent with the purpose of the Act to protect the community and ensure regulated dogs are managed effectively. Therefore, the Tribunal confirmed the Council's decision.

The Tribunal confirmed the decision of the Cairns Regional Council made on 29 November 2023 in respect of the destruction order for the dog Ruby.

Orders

Orders of the court

The decision of the Cairns Regional Council made on 29 November 2023 in respect of a destruction order for the dog “Ruby” is confirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

After conducting an internal review of the matter, the respondent decided, on 8 April 2024, to confirm the original decisions made on 29 November 2023 to issue the applicant with a concurrent Regulated Dog Declaration and Destruction Order in relation to the dog and advised the applicant accordingly.Tribunal’s Jurisdiction to review the Decision The Tribunal’s review jurisdiction is conferred on the Tribunal by an enabling Act to review a decision made or taken to have been made.[1] [1]Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) (“QCAT Act”) s 17. A person who is given a review notice for a decision may apply to the Tribunal, as provided under the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) (“QCAT Act”), for an external review of the decision.[2] A review notice is given by the Chief Executive to the Applicant by way of a notice of the review decision following an internal review.[3] The decision dated 25 May 2024 given to the Applicant is a review notice for the purpose of these proceedings. Accordingly, the Animal Management Act is the “enabling Act” for these proceedings.[2]The Animal Management Act s 188.[3]Ibid s 187. The Tribunal has jurisdiction to hear and determine these proceedings provided the Applicant has applied to the Tribunal to exercise its review jurisdiction for a reviewable decision.[4] The Applicant has filed such an Application to review a decision and accordingly the Tribunal has jurisdiction and can proceed to hear and determine the review.[4]QCAT Act s 18. The Tribunal is to review the decision by way of a fresh hearing on the merits and is to produce the correct and preferable decision.[5] [5]Ibid s 20. In conducting the review jurisdiction in respect of a reviewable decision, the tribunal may:(a)confirm or amend the decision; or(b)set aside the decision and substituted its own decision; or(c)set aside the decision and return the matter for reconsideration to the decision-maker for the decision, with the directions the tribunal considers appropriate.The Animal Management Act and the Making of Declarations The purpose of the Animal Management Act is to provide effective management of regulated dogs and promote responsible ownership.[6] That is achieved by imposing obligations on particular persons to exercise effective control of dogs in particular circumstances and ensure dogs do not attack or cause fear.[6]The Animal Management Act s 3. Chapter 4 of the Animal Management Act contains provisions under the heading “Regulated dogs”. The purpose of Chapter 4 is to:[7] (a)protect the community from damage or injury, or risk of damage or injury, from regulated dogs; and(b)ensure regulated dogs are—(i) not a risk to community health or safety; and(ii) controlled and kept in a way consistent with community expectations and rights of individuals.[7]Ibid s 59. A regulated dog is:[8] (a)a declared dangerous dog; or(b)a declared menacing dog.[8] Ibid s 60. A declared dangerous dog is a dog declared under s 94 of the Animal Management Act to be a dangerous dog.[9] [9] Ibid s 61.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In conducting the review jurisdiction in respect of a reviewable decision, the tribunal may:(a)confirm or amend the decision; or(b)set aside the decision and substituted its own decision; or(c)set aside the decision and return the matter for reconsideration to the decision-maker for the decision, with the directions the tribunal considers appropriate.The Animal Management Act and the Making of Declarations The purpose of the Animal Management Act is to provide effective management of regulated dogs and promote responsible ownership.[6] That is achieved by imposing obligations on particular persons to exercise effective control of dogs in particular circumstances and ensure dogs do not attack or cause fear.[6]The Animal Management Act s 3. Chapter 4 of the Animal Management Act contains provisions under the heading “Regulated dogs”. The purpose of Chapter 4 is to:[7] (a)protect the community from damage or injury, or risk of damage or injury, from regulated dogs; and(b)ensure regulated dogs are—(i) not a risk to community health or safety; and(ii) controlled and kept in a way consistent with community expectations and rights of individuals.[7]Ibid s 59. A regulated dog is:[8] (a)a declared dangerous dog; or(b)a declared menacing dog.[8] Ibid s 60. A declared dangerous dog is a dog declared under s 94 of the Animal Management Act to be a dangerous dog.[9] [9] Ibid s 61. Any local government may declare a particular dog to be a declared dangerous dog.[10] However, such a declaration can only be made if the dog:[11] (a)has seriously attacked, or acted in a way that caused fear to, a person or another animal; or(b)may, in the opinion of an authorised person having regard to the way the dog has behaved towards a person or another animal, seriously attack, or act in a way that causes fear to the person or animal.[10] Ibid s 89.[11] Ibid s 89(2). A declaration made under this section is a regulated dog declaration.[12] The term “seriously attack” means:[13] (a)in relation to a person—attack the person in a way that causes the death of, or grievous bodily harm or bodily harm to the person; or(b)in relation to an animal—attack the animal in a way that causes the death of the animal or maims or wounds the animal.[12] Ibid s 89(5).[13]Ibid s 89(6). If a dog is a regulated dog, then an authorised person may immediately destroy the dog if:[14] (a)the authorised person reasonably believes the dog is dangerous and the authorised person cannot control the dog; or(b)the owner of the dog has asked the authorised person to destroy the dog.[14] Ibid s 127. Where the dog is a “regulated dog” and s 127 of the Animal Management Act does not authorise the destruction of the dog then:(a)if the dog has seriously attacked a person or an animal, the authorised person must make a destruction order in relation to the dog; or(b)if the dog has not seriously attacked a person or an animal, the authorised person may make a destruction order in relation to the dog.