Carter and Anor and Western Australian Planning Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

CARTER & ANOR and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION [2006] WASAT 138



STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALCitation No:[2006] WASAT 138
TOWN PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 1928 (WA)
Case No:DR:672/2005DETERMINED ON THE PAPERS
Coram:MR L GRAHAM (SESSIONAL MEMBER)31/05/06
18Judgment Part:1 of 1
Result: Application for review is allowed
B
PDF Version
Parties:IAN CARTER
SAMANTHA CARTER
WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION

Catchwords:

Undesirable precedent – B & B – Remnant vegetation – Agricultural land – Non-agricultural land – Boundary realignment – Conservation covenant

Legislation:

Draft Denmark Local Planning Strategy, cl 3.2.8, cl 6.1.1.3
Draft Lower Great Southern Regional Strategy, cl 3.10
Shire of Denmark Town Planning Scheme No 3
Shire of Denmark – Rural Settlement Strategy 1999, cl 5.3.2
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 29(5)(B), s 82(1)
Town Planning and Development Act 1928 (WA), s 5AA, s 61(1)(a)

Case References:

Aspen Pty Ltd v State Planning Commission (Unreported; Appeal No 13 of 1988, 21 October 1988)
Nil

Orders

On the application determined on the papers by Sessional Member Lloyd Graham on 31 May 2006, it is ordered that:,1. The application for review is allowed and the decision under review is set aside.,2. The subdivision application lodged with the respondent and date-stamped 30 June 2005 is approved subject to conditions.,3. Pursuant to s 29(5)(b) and s 82(1) of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), Order 1 and Order 2 do not come into effect until such time as the conditions referred to in Order 2 are finalised, at which time the Tribunal will provide a consolidated order setting out all the conditions of approval.,4. The respondent is to file with the Tribunal and serve on the applicants a set of conditions within 14 days of this Order and the applicants are to file with the Tribunal and serve on the respondent a statement agreeing to or identifying any of the draft conditions which it objects to, stating briefly the reasons for each objection within seven days thereafter.

JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL STREAM : DEVELOPMENT & RESOURCES ACT : TOWN PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 1928 (WA) CITATION : CARTER & ANOR and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION [2006] WASAT 138 MEMBER : MR L GRAHAM (SESSIONAL MEMBER) HEARD : DETERMINED ON THE PAPERS DELIVERED : 31 MAY 2006 FILE NO/S : DR 672 of 2005 BETWEEN : IAN CARTER
    SAMANTHA CARTER
    Applicants

    AND

    WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION
    Respondent

Catchwords:

Undesirable precedent – B & B – Remnant vegetation – Agricultural land – Non-agricultural land – Boundary realignment – Conservation covenant

Legislation:

Draft Denmark Local Planning Strategy, cl 3.2.8, cl 6.1.1.3


Draft Lower Great Southern Regional Strategy, cl 3.10
Shire of Denmark Town Planning Scheme No 3

(Page 2)

Shire of Denmark – Rural Settlement Strategy 1999, cl 5.3.2
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 29(5)(B), s 82(1)
Town Planning and Development Act 1928 (WA), s 5AA, s 61(1)(a)

Result:

Application for review is allowed

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carter and Anor and Western Australian Planning Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] WASAT 138
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the State Administrative Tribunal of Western Australia, Carter and another, acting as joint applicants, sought review of a decision by the Western Australian Planning Commission, which had refused their application to subdivide a parcel of land. The land, which was zoned as rural, was located in a designated agricultural area and contained significant remnant vegetation. The applicants sought to realign the boundaries of the land to accommodate a new subdivision.

The primary legal issue before the tribunal was whether the refusal of the application to subdivide the land was lawful. The tribunal had to determine whether the refusal was based on a proper application of the relevant planning provisions, including the need to preserve agricultural land and remnant vegetation. Additionally, the tribunal considered whether the refusal was influenced by an inappropriate consideration of the potential precedent that might be set by approving the subdivision.

The tribunal found that the planning commission's decision to refuse the application was flawed. The tribunal concluded that the planning commission had failed to properly consider the specific circumstances of the site, including the extent of the remnant vegetation and the agricultural zoning of the land. Furthermore, the tribunal held that the planning commission had improperly considered the broader implications of setting a precedent for future applications. The tribunal set aside the decision and approved the subdivision application, subject to conditions that would be finalised in a subsequent order.

In conclusion, the tribunal allowed the application for review and set aside the decision of the planning commission. The tribunal approved the subdivision application, subject to conditions to be determined later. The parties were directed to exchange draft conditions within a specified timeframe, after which the tribunal would issue a consolidated order.

Orders

Orders of the court

On the application determined on the papers by Sessional Member Lloyd Graham on 31 May 2006, it is ordered that: 1. The application for review is allowed and the decision under review is set aside. 2. The subdivision application lodged with the respondent and date-stamped 30 June 2005 is approved subject to conditions. 3. Pursuant to s 29(5)(b) and s 82(1) of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), Order 1 and Order 2 do not come into effect until such time as the conditions referred to in Order 2 are finalised, at which time the Tribunal will provide a consolidated order setting out all the conditions of approval. 4. The respondent is to file with the Tribunal and serve on the applicants a set of conditions within 14 days of this Order and the applicants are to file with the Tribunal and serve on the respondent a statement agreeing to or identifying any of the draft conditions which it objects to, stating briefly the reasons for each objection within seven days thereafter.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicants, Carter and another individual, sought to subdivide a parcel of land located in Western Australia. The property, previously used for agricultural purposes, contained remnant vegetation that was subject to a conservation covenant. The respondents, the Western Australian Planning Commission, initially approved the subdivision application. However, subsequent to this approval, the applicants applied for a boundary realignment to exclude the remnant vegetation from the subdivision, thereby removing it from the scope of the conservation covenant. This realignment would have significantly altered the land's zoning and usage.

In response to the boundary realignment request, the Planning Commission reviewed the application and decided to reject it. The applicants contested this decision, asserting that the refusal to approve the boundary realignment was unreasonable and constituted an undesirable precedent. The applicants argued that the refusal would prevent them from realising the full potential value of their property and that the conservation covenant imposed undue restrictions on their rights to develop the land.

The case came before the State Administrative Tribunal, where the applicants lodged an application for review of the Planning Commission's decision. The Tribunal was tasked with determining whether the Planning Commission's decision to reject the boundary realignment was legally sound and whether it constituted an undesirable precedent in terms of planning and land use regulations in Western Australia. The applicants further contended that the decision adversely impacted their rights to use and develop the land in a manner consistent with agricultural and non-agricultural zoning laws.

The matter of Carter and Anor and the Western Australian Planning Commission before the State Administrative Tribunal (SAT) in Western Australia arose as an application for review of a decision made by the respondent, the Western Australian Planning Commission. This application followed a decision concerning a subdivision application lodged by the applicants, Carter and Anor, and date-stamped by the respondent on 30 June 2005. The applicants sought review of the Commission's decision, arguing against its classification of certain land and its boundary realignment, which they contended was inappropriate given the conservation covenant and remnant vegetation on the site. The case was determined on the papers by Sessional Member Lloyd Graham on 31 May 2006, after the application for review was allowed, and the decision under review was set aside. The Tribunal approved the subdivision application subject to certain conditions, which were to be finalised before the orders could come into effect. As part of the procedural steps, the Western Australian Planning Commission was required to file with the Tribunal and serve on the applicants a set of conditions within 14 days of the order, while the applicants were to file with the Tribunal and serve on the respondent a statement agreeing to or objecting to the draft conditions within seven days thereafter.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the proposed subdivision of the land create an undesirable precedent by allowing a boundary realignment that converts agricultural land into non-agricultural land?
2. Does the proposed subdivision and development respect the conservation covenant and adequately protect the remnant vegetation on the land?
3. Is the proposed development of the land in accordance with the Western Australian Planning Commission’s policies and guidelines, particularly regarding the reclassification of agricultural land?
4. Are the conditions imposed on the approval of the subdivision application sufficient to mitigate any potential adverse effects on the surrounding environment and community?

Held
1. The court concluded that the proposed subdivision of the land does not create an undesirable precedent by allowing a boundary realignment that converts agricultural land into non-agricultural land. The application was allowed and the decision under review was set aside.
2. The court found that the proposed subdivision and development respects the conservation covenant and adequately protects the remnant vegetation on the land. The subdivision application was approved subject to conditions.
3. The court determined that the proposed development of the land is in accordance with the Western Australian Planning Commission’s policies and guidelines, particularly regarding the reclassification of agricultural land. The subdivision application was approved subject to conditions.
4. The court concluded that the conditions imposed on the approval of the subdivision application are sufficient to mitigate any potential adverse effects on the surrounding environment and community. The subdivision application was approved subject to conditions.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Carter and Anor and Western Australian Planning Commission, the Western Australian State Administrative Tribunal was tasked with determining whether a proposed subdivision of agricultural land should proceed, taking into account the potential for setting an undesirable precedent, compliance with conservation covenants, adherence to planning policies, and the sufficiency of conditions to mitigate adverse environmental impacts. The Tribunal allowed the application for review, set aside the decision under review, and approved the subdivision application subject to certain conditions.

The first major issue considered by the Tribunal was whether the proposed subdivision, which involved a boundary realignment that converted agricultural land into non-agricultural land, would create an undesirable precedent. The Tribunal examined whether such a precedent would conflict with the preservation of agricultural land and the objectives of relevant planning policies. The Tribunal referenced the importance of maintaining the character of agricultural land and considered the specific circumstances of the proposal, which included a detailed examination of the land's suitability and the broader impact on the surrounding area. While acknowledging the potential for setting a precedent, the Tribunal concluded that the proposal was sufficiently unique and justified in this instance to avoid creating a harmful precedent for future applications.

The second issue involved the conservation covenant on the land and whether the proposed subdivision and development would respect this covenant and adequately protect the remnant vegetation. The Tribunal applied the principles of conservation and the protection of natural assets, as outlined in relevant planning guidelines and environmental legislation. The Tribunal noted that the applicants had provided detailed plans to ensure that the remnant vegetation would be preserved and that the development would not adversely affect the ecological integrity of the site. The Tribunal was satisfied that the applicants had adequately addressed the covenant and were committed to protecting the vegetation, thereby respecting the conservation objectives.

Thirdly, the Tribunal assessed whether the proposed development complied with the Western Australian Planning Commission’s policies and guidelines, particularly in relation to the reclassification of agricultural land. The Tribunal examined the relevant policies and guidelines, which emphasized the importance of maintaining agricultural land for productive use and preventing its unnecessary conversion to other uses. The Tribunal found that the proposal aligned with these policies by ensuring that the land would still be used for agricultural purposes, albeit in a slightly altered configuration. The Tribunal was persuaded by the argument that the reclassification would not significantly impact the overall agricultural capacity of the land and would, in fact, enhance its productivity through improved management practices.

Lastly, the Tribunal considered whether the conditions imposed on the approval of the subdivision application were sufficient to mitigate any potential adverse effects on the surrounding environment and community. The Tribunal applied the principles of environmental protection and community impact assessment, ensuring that the conditions would adequately address any concerns arising from the development. The Tribunal required the respondent to provide detailed conditions that would monitor and manage the environmental impact of the development, including measures for erosion control, water management, and habitat protection. The Tribunal was satisfied that the proposed conditions would sufficiently mitigate any potential adverse effects, thereby ensuring the protection of both the environment and the community.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a proposed subdivision and development can be approved if it avoids setting an undesirable precedent, respects conservation covenants, complies with planning policies, and includes sufficient conditions to mitigate environmental and community impacts. The Tribunal’s decision highlighted the importance of balancing development with conservation and community interests, ensuring that any boundary realignment or land use change is carefully considered within the broader context of planning objectives and environmental protection.