Carson v Illawarra Retirement Trust t/as IRT Group

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Carson v Illawarra Retirement Trust t/as IRT Group [2024] QCAT 323

PARTIES:

GEOFFREY RAYMOND CARSON

(applicant)

v

ILLAWARRA RETIREMENT TRUST T/AS IRT GROUP

(Respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

OCL015-22

MATTER TYPE:

Other civil dispute matters

DELIVERED ON:

8 August 2024

HEARING DATE:

25 January 2024

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member Paratz AM

ORDERS:

The Tribunal Directs that:

1.     Illawarra Retirement Trust t/as IRT Group (‘the Trust’) is to file one (1) copy in the Tribunal, and give one (1) copy to Geoffrey Raymond Carson, of its Submissions as to the Final Orders to be made, and providing Draft Orders, which are consistent with the findings of the Tribunal made in these Reasons, that:

(a)     the Trust is in compliance with the Retirement Villages Act1999 (Qld) in purchasing bulk insurance cover which encompasses insurance in relation to the Retirement Village known as Parklands at Currimundi in Queensland;

(b)     the Trust must identify and separate any insurance costs which are directly related to the Corporate costs of the Trust, which form part of the bulk insurance cover, in formulating the insurance component of the General Services Charge for the Parklands Village;

(c)     the Trust is to implement a logical process that fairly apportions the insurance costs directly related to the Parklands Village for the purposes of establishing the General Services Charge payable by the residents of that Village;

(d)     the Trust is to establish a means of disclosing to the residents the basis of the insurance costs that are being attributed to the Parklands Village in its General Services Charge, whilst still maintaining the commercial confidence of the Trust as to its overall activities; and

(e)     the dates from when such Orders should take effect, by:

4:00pm on the date two (2) months after the date of these Reasons.

2.     Geoffrey Raymond Carson is to file one (1) copy in the Tribunal, and give one (1) copy to Illawarra Retirement Trust t/as IRT Group, of his Submissions in Response to the submissions of the Trust as to the Final Orders to be made, and providing alternate Draft Orders (if any), by:

4.00pm on the date three (3) months after the date of these Reasons.

3.     Illawarra Retirement Trust t/as IRT Group is to file one (1) copy in the Tribunal, and give one (1) copy to Geoffrey Raymond Carson, of its Submissions in Reply to the submissions of Mr Carson as to the Final Orders to be made, and providing Draft Orders (if any), by:

4.00pm on the date four (4) months after the date of these Reasons.

4.     Unless either party requests an Oral Hearing, the Final Orders to be made will be determined by the Tribunal On the Papers, having regard to the submissions made, after:

four (4) months after the date of these Reasons.

The Tribunal Orders:

1.   Until further or other Order, publication is prohibited of:

(a)     The materials contained in pages 157-733 attached to the affidavit of Louise Lever dated 29…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carson v Illawarra Retirement Trust t/as IRT Group and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QCAT 323
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Carson v Illawarra Retirement Trust t/as IRT Group, the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) was tasked with resolving a dispute concerning the calculation of the General Services Charge (GSC) for the Parklands Retirement Village at Currimundi, Queensland. The plaintiff, Geoffrey Raymond Carson, a resident of the Village, challenged the Trust's methodology for including insurance costs within the GSC, contending that the Trust had improperly included costs that were not directly attributable to the Village. Carson argued that the Trust, having purchased insurance in bulk, was not authorised to include certain costs in the GSC and that the Trust had failed to accurately apportion the insurance costs related to the Village.

The central legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the Trust was authorised under the Retirement Villages Act 1999 (Qld) to purchase insurance in bulk, and if the correct cost of insurance was included in the GSC for the Village. The Tribunal considered statutory provisions, the Trust's insurance policies, and expert evidence to determine the proper method of allocating insurance costs. After examining the evidence and submissions, the Tribunal found that while the Trust was authorised to purchase insurance in bulk, it was required to correctly identify and separate the costs directly related to the Village. The Tribunal also found that the Trust had not implemented a logical process to fairly apportion these costs, nor had it adequately disclosed the basis for the insurance costs attributed to the Village in its GSC.

In its reasons, the Tribunal directed that the Trust must separate any corporate costs from those directly related to the Village and implement a process for fair apportionment. Additionally, the Trust was required to establish a means of disclosing the basis of the insurance costs to residents while maintaining commercial confidence. The Tribunal ordered the Trust and Carson to submit written submissions on the final orders, with the Final Orders to be determined on the papers unless an oral hearing was requested. The Tribunal also temporarily prohibited the publication of certain materials pending further order.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal Directs that:

1. Illawarra Retirement Trust t/as IRT Group (‘the Trust’) is to file one (1) copy in the Tribunal, and give one (1) copy to Geoffrey Raymond Carson, of its Submissions as to the Final Orders to be made, and providing Draft Orders, which are consistent with the findings of the Tribunal made in these Reasons, that:

(a) the Trust is in compliance with the Retirement Villages Act 1999 (Qld) in purchasing bulk insurance cover which encompasses insurance in relation to the Retirement Village known as Parklands at Currimundi in Queensland;

(b) the Trust must identify and separate any insurance costs which are directly related to the Corporate costs of the Trust, which form part of the bulk insurance cover, in formulating the insurance component of the General Services Charge for the Parklands Village;

(c) the Trust is to implement a logical process that fairly apportions the insurance costs directly related to the Parklands Village for the purposes of establishing the General Services Charge payable by the residents of that Village;

(d) the Trust is to establish a means of disclosing to the residents the basis of the insurance costs that are being attributed to the Parklands Village in its General Services Charge, whilst still maintaining the commercial confidence of the Trust as to its overall activities; and

(e) the dates from when such Orders should take effect, by:

4:00pm on the date two (2) months after the date of these Reasons.

2. Geoffrey Raymond Carson is to file one (1) copy in the Tribunal, and give one (1) copy to Illawarra Retirement Trust t/as IRT Group, of his Submissions in Response to the submissions of the Trust as to the Final Orders to be made, and providing alternate Draft Orders (if any), by:

4.00pm on the date three (3) months after the date of these Reasons.

3. Illawarra Retirement Trust t/as IRT Group is to file one (1) copy in the Tribunal, and give one (1) copy to Geoffrey Raymond Carson, of its Submissions in Reply to the submissions of Mr Carson as to the Final Orders to be made, and providing Draft Orders (if any), by:

4.00pm on the date four (4) months after the date of these Reasons.

4. Unless either party requests an Oral Hearing, the Final Orders to be made will be determined by the Tribunal On the Papers, having regard to the submissions made, after:

four (4) months after the date of these Reasons.

The Tribunal Orders:

1. Until further or other Order, publication is prohibited of:

(a) The materials contained in pages 157-733 attached to the affidavit of Louise Lever dated 29 August 2022; and

(b) The materials referred to in Order 2 given on 13 May 2022, being publication of an Excel spreadsheet attached to the statement of evidence of Jason Gaudiosi in hardcopy or in any electronic form or held on a USB.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established