Carruthers v MarshallCarruthers v Marshall and Marshall v Marshall

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read
CITATION: Carruthers v MarshallCarruthers v Marshall and Marshall v Marshall [2001] NSWSC 665 revised - 19/10/2001
CURRENT JURISDICTION: EQUITY DIVISION
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 5141/00; 2839/01
HEARING DATE(S): 30 July - 3 August 2001
JUDGMENT DATE:
3 August 2001

PARTIES :


LINDA HOPE CARRUTHERS v MARGARET LESLEY MARSHALL
KIM MARSHALL v MARGARET LESLEY MARSHLL
JUDGMENT OF: Master Macready at 1
COUNSEL : Mr L. Ellison for plaintiff
Mr C. Bevan for defendant
Mr Kim Marshall in person
SOLICITORS: Teece Hodgson & Ward
Turner Freeman for defendant
CATCHWORDS: Family Provision by a defacto partner and a son. Estate passes to wife from whom deceased had been separated for some years. Small estate. Orders made for provision with specific orders in respect of costs to cater for variations in the estate.
DECISION: Paragraph 71


- 1 -

    5141/00 - LINDA HOPE CARRUTHERS v MARGARET LESLEY MARSHALL

    2837/01 - KIM NEIL MARSHALL v MARGARET LESLEY MARSHALL

    JUDGMENT

1 MASTER: This is a hearing of two applications under the Family Provision Act in respect of the estate of the late Neil Marshall who died on 31 May 2000 in a plane accident near Whyalla in South Australia. The deceased was survived by his wife, the plaintiff Linda Carruthers, with whom the deceased had been living in a defacto relationship for some years prior to this death, and his son, Kim Marshall.

2   Proceedings have been brought by both Linda Carruthers and Kim Marshall and both matters have been heard together, with the evidence in one being evidence in the other.

3   The deceased's last will was made on 23 December 1992. Under the will the deceased left the whole of his estate to his wife, the defendant, and appointed her executrix. Before moving to the estate it is useful to look at some of the history of the family and the events surrounding this matter.

4   The deceased was born in the UK on 11 June 1943 and the plaintiff Linda Carruthers was born on 13 April 1952. On 23 September 1967 the deceased and the defendant married. They both worked and ultimately on 17 January 1980 their child, Kim Marshall, the plaintiff, was born. He started at school and had his ordinary schooling, although he in fact did not complete the HSC.

5   The plaintiff Linda Carruthers' early life is not of great importance but it was in 1986 that she purchased a property at Petersham for $119,500, her co-owners being Dianne Blackman and Margaret Penson. Apparently she and Ms Blackman in 1989 paid out Ms Penson's interest and the plaintiff and Ms Blackman continued to live at the premises.

6   Having lived elsewhere for some time the deceased and the defendant purchased a home at Herbert Street, Newtown as joint tenants in December 1990.

7   It was in 1992 that the plaintiff first met the deceased at work. Both were involved in the union movement and had positions which brought them into contact.

8   On 12 December 1992 the deceased's last will was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carruthers v MarshallCarruthers v Marshall and Marshall v Ma... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] NSWSC 665
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Carruthers v Marshall, the parties involved were Carruthers and Marshall, along with Marshall's wife. The dispute revolved around family provision claims under the Family Provision Act, with Carruthers, the de facto partner of the deceased, and Marshall, the deceased's son, both seeking a portion of the deceased's estate. The deceased had been separated from his wife for several years prior to his death, and the estate was relatively small. The court had to determine the appropriate amount of provision to be made to the de facto partner and the son from the deceased's estate, while also addressing the specific issue of how costs should be allocated given the potential variations in the estate's value.

The legal issues before the court included the interpretation and application of the Family Provision Act, particularly in determining whether Carruthers and Marshall were eligible for provision from the deceased's estate. The court had to assess the deceased's financial position, his obligations to his de facto partner and his son, and the needs of the applicants in relation to the size and nature of the estate. Additionally, the court needed to establish a method for calculating costs that could accommodate potential fluctuations in the estate's value.

In delivering the judgment, the court first considered the relevant provisions of the Family Provision Act and the principles established in previous case law. It examined the deceased's financial circumstances, including his income, assets, and liabilities. The court also evaluated the contributions made by Carruthers and Marshall to the deceased's lifestyle and the extent of their dependency on him. The court recognised the importance of ensuring that the estate was distributed fairly, taking into account the statutory criteria for making provision orders. After weighing all the evidence and arguments, the court determined that both Carruthers and Marshall were entitled to a portion of the estate and made specific orders regarding the provision to be paid to each. Furthermore, the court devised a method for allocating costs that would be adaptable to any changes in the estate's valuation, ensuring fairness and clarity in the financial arrangements.

The final orders included specific amounts to be paid to Carruthers and Marshall from the deceased's estate, as well as detailed instructions on how costs were to be calculated and allocated. The court's decision aimed to balance the needs of the applicants with the constraints of the estate, providing a clear and equitable outcome in line with the principles of the Family Provision Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.