Carrick v Health Insurance Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Carrick v Health Insurance Commission [2007] FCA 984

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – Health Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) – statutory scheme for examination of conduct of medical practitioner to ascertain whether practitioner engaged in inappropriate practice – Commission’s decision to make investigative referral challenged – Director’s decision to make adjudicative referral to a Professional Services Review Committee challenged – final report of Committee challenged – sampling methodology used by Committee challenged – Held: application dismissed

Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) s 5
Health Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) ss 81, 82, 85, 86, 87, 89B, 91, 93, 95, 103, 106K, 106H

Applicant VEAL of 2002 v Minister for Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2005) 225 CLR 88 distinguished
Daniel v Kelly (2003) 200 ALR 379 distinguished
Freeman v Health Insurance Commission [2004] FCA 453 referred to
Kelly v Daniel (2004) 134 FCR 64 cited
Mathews v Health Insurance Commission (2006) 90 ALD 49 approved
Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Limited (1986) 162 CLR 24 cited
Oreb v Willcock (2005) 146 FCR 237 cited
Phan v Kelly [2007] FCA 269 approved
Pradhan v Holmes (2001) 125 FCR 280 cited
Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority (1998) 1944 CLR 355 cited

JANE CARRICK v HEALTH INSURANCE COMMISSION, ALAN JOHN HOLMES IN HIS CAPACITY AS DIRECTOR, PROFESSIONAL SERVICES REVIEW, RICHARD KING, GRAHAM NEWSTEAD, GLENDA PEEL AND RICHARD GORDON CONSTITUTING THE PROFESSIONAL SERVICES REVIEW COMMITTEE NO 352 AND THE DETERMINING AUTHORITY ESTABLISHED BY SECTION 106Q OF THE HEALTH INSURANCE ACT 1973 (CTH)

NSD 322 OF 2005

BRANSON J
3 JULY 2007
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 322 OF 2005

BETWEEN:

JANE CARRICK
Applicant

AND:

HEALTH INSURANCE COMMISSION
First Respondent

ALAN JOHN HOLMES IN HIS CAPACITY AS DIRECTOR, PROFESSIONAL SERVICES REVIEW
Second Respondent

RICHARD KING, GRAHAM NEWSTEAD, GLENDA PEEL AND RICHARD GORDON CONSTITUTING THE PROFESSIONAL SERVICES REVIEW COMMITTEE NO 352
Third Respondent

THE DETERMINING AUTHORITY ESTABLISHED BY SECTION 106Q OF THE HEALTH INSURANCE ACT 1973 (CTH)
Fourth Respondent

JUDGE:

BRANSON J

DATE OF ORDER:

3 JULY 2007

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application be dismissed except as to ‘the constitutional grounds’ as defined in the order made by Sackville J on 7 September 2006.

2.The applicant pay the respondents’ costs of the proceeding except as to ‘the constitutional grounds’ as defined in the order made by Sackville J on 7 September 2006.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 322 OF 2005

BETWEEN:

JANE CARRICK
Applicant

AND:

HEALTH INSURANCE COMMISSION
First Respondent

ALAN JOHN HOLMES IN HIS CAPACITY AS DIRECTOR, PROFESSIONAL SERVICES REVIEW
Second Respondent

RICHARD KING, GRAHAM NEWSTEAD, GLENDA PEEL AND RICHARD GORDON CONSTITUTING THE PROFESSIONAL SERVICES REVIEW COMMITTEE NO 352
Third Respondent

THE DETERMINING AUTHORITY ESTABLISHED BY SECTION 106Q OF THE HEALTH INSURANCE ACT 1973 (CTH)
Fourth Respondent

JUDGE:

BRANSON J

DATE:

3 JULY 2007

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carrick v Health Insurance Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] FCA 984
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Carrick v Health Insurance Commission, Dr Carrick sought judicial review of a decision by the Commission not to investigate her conduct, instead referring her matter to the Director of Health Insurance for investigation. The Federal Court was tasked with determining whether the Commission’s decision not to investigate was legally sound. Dr Carrick argued that she had taken corrective actions based on prior communications with the Commission and had demonstrated a willingness to cooperate, which should have led to a decision not to investigate.

The central legal issue was whether the Commission properly exercised its discretion in deciding not to investigate Dr Carrick's conduct. Dr Carrick contended that the Commission’s prior communications and her actions in response to those communications should have precluded an investigation. The Court examined whether the Commission's decision-making process was flawed, considering the prior counselling and review of Dr Carrick's conduct. The Court also assessed whether the Commission appropriately acknowledged the discretionary nature of its decision to investigate.

The Court concluded that the Commission had indeed recognised its discretion to decide whether to investigate. Despite Dr Carrick's argument that she had been led to believe she had passed a stage of review, the Court found that the Commission's correspondence did not commit it to a particular course of action. Furthermore, the Court found that Dr Carrick's case was distinguishable from previous cases cited by her, which had hinged on a mistaken belief by the Commission that it was obligated to investigate. Consequently, the Court dismissed Dr Carrick’s application, except in relation to specific constitutional grounds previously defined.

The Court ordered that Dr Carrick’s application be dismissed, except as to the constitutional grounds defined in a previous order by Sackville J. Additionally, the Court ordered Dr Carrick to pay the respondents' costs of the proceeding, except in relation to those constitutional grounds. This decision underscored the importance of the Commission correctly exercising its discretion and clarified the scope of judicial review in such matters.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed except as to ‘the constitutional grounds’ as defined in the order made by Sackville J on 7 September 2006.

2. The applicant pay the respondents’ costs of the proceeding except as to ‘the constitutional grounds’ as defined in the order made by Sackville J on 7 September 2006.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

BRANSON J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BRANSON J

She submitted in her outline opening statement that if the delegate of the Commission had taken the above communications into account he would have been aware that:‘a.The applicant had in fact, reduced her workload in some areas and thereby had better practice statistics since and because of her counselling session;b.In one (of three) areas of concern, the applicant had in fact completely satisfied the Commission’s Case Management’s [sic] Committee that her use of Item 30378 (gastroscopy) and her prescribing of pharmaceuticals was no longer an issue (see, the letter dated 19 October 2001 ‑ in the applicant’s affidavit of 11 May 2005 at page 16);c.The applicant, at all these times, plainly demonstrated an active willingness, not only to co-operate with the Commission’s investigations, but to reduce her workload to “acceptable” levels ‑ she was simply not told that which she needed in order to satisfy the Commission further;d.The applicant was positively led to believe that she had passed through to the next stage of Commission review, as it were, in relation to the referral period which she plainly considered was once under review by the Commission (which was 1 July 2000 to 30 June 2001). For example, in the letters from the Commission dated:(1)24 April 2001 (page 15 of the applicant’s affidavit);(2)19 October 2001 (page 16);the applicant is informed that her practice profile will be reviewed later. She was entitled to consider that the Commission was not sufficiently concerned about the period 1 July 2000 to 30 June 2001 as to then refer her to the Director under the Act; and,e.The applicant was positively mislead [sic] by the Commission’s Medical Advisor in the conduct of the counselling session on 14 December 2000 …’. (emphasis omitted)Consideration Dr Carrick placed particular reliance on the judgments of this Court, at first instance and on appeal, regarding an investigative referral decision made concerning a Dr Daniel (Daniel v Kelly (2003) 200 ALR 379 (Ryan J); Kelly v Daniel (2004) 134 FCR 64 (Full Court)). In Daniel v Kelly Ryan J at [13] rejected the submission that, in the circumstances of that case, the investigative referral was a result of the operation of the Act with the consequence that no occasion arose for the exercise of a discretion by the Commission. His Honour went on at [25] to describe as ‘plainly relevant to any decision to investigate Dr Daniel’ the fact that the relevant conduct of Dr Daniel had already been the subject of counselling and review resulting in a decision to take no action at that time. On appeal the Full Court at [81] agreed that the Commission had a discretion under s 86 to make an investigative referral and that the Commission had proceeded on the erroneous assumption that it was required to make an investigate referral. I reject Dr Carrick’s submission that this case is on ‘all fours’ with Daniel v Kelly. It is not suggested in this case that the Commission proceeded on the assumption that it was required to make an investigative referral. The correspondence considered in [24] and [28] below makes plain that the Commission appreciated that an investigative referral was discretionary.