Carpetex Pty Ltd v Roadrunner Pty Ltd & Andrew & Martin & Others

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Appeal Against a Master's Decision)

CARPETEX PTY LTD v ROADRUNNER PTY LTD & ANDREW & MARTIN & OTHERS

Judgment of His Honour Judge Rice

6 May 2005

PROCEDURE

MASTER'S APPEAL - EQUITABLE REMEDIES

The plaintiff leased commercial premises to SA Nut Co Pty Ltd for a three year period - Nut Co's obligations pursuant to lease guaranteed by third defendants - Nut Co entered administration during the three year period - Administrator of Nut Co sold business to first defendant, Roadrunner, and the lease of the premises is assigned to Roadrunner - Roadrunner remained in occupation for the remainder of the lease and thereafter held over on a monthly basis for almost three years - plaintiff claimed that Roadrunner and second defendant (as guarantor of Roadrunner's obligations) failed to make good when it vacated premises - first and second defendants seek contribution from third defendants for the cost of making good because deterioration in premises occurred during both occupations - claims on basis of unjust enrichment and equitable contribution - Master struck out Contribution Notice on the basis that, on the pleaded facts, neither remedy was available.

Held - neither remedy available on the facts as pleaded.

District Court Act 1991 s 43(2)(a); District Court Rules rules 25.04 and 97, referred to.
Fancourt and Another v Mercantile Credits Limited (1983) 154 CLR 87; Kadeh v Gill & Ors (2000) 211 LSJS 88; Pavey & Matthews Proprietary Limited v Paul (1986-1987) 162 CLR 221; Angelopoulos v Sabatino (1995) 65 SASR 1; Albion Insurance Co Ltd v Government Insurance Office (NSW) (1969) 121 CLR 342; Burke v Lfot Pty Ltd (2002) 209 CLR 282; Cockburn and Others v GIO Finance Ltd (No 2) (2001) 51 NSWLR 624; Belan & Anor v Casey (2003) 57 NSWLR 670; Burton v Litton Business Systems Pty Ltd and Data Print (Aust) Pty Ltd (1977) 16 SASR 163 at 170, considered.

CARPETEX PTY LTD v ROADRUNNER PTY LTD & ANDREW & MARTIN & OTHERS
[2005] SADC 41

Introduction

  1. This is an appeal against the decision of a Master striking out the Amended Contribution Notice of the first and second defendants because it failed to disclose a reasonable cause of action against the third defendants.

  2. To understand the arguments on both sides, it is necessary to explain something of the background events and parties involved.  For ease of reference, I propose to refer to the parties in their original capacities.  Carpetex Pty Ltd (“the plaintiff”) was the lessor of premises at 124 Main Street, Beverley.  The plaintiff entered into a lease (“the lease”) with SA Nut Co Pty Ltd (“Nut Co”) whereby the premises were leased to Nut Co for a term of three years commencing on 1st October, 1995.  Pursuant to clause 16 of the lease, the third defendants guaranteed performance of all of the covenants in the lease by the lessee, Nut Co.

  3. In or about May, 1998, Nut Co entered into administration…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carpetex Pty Ltd v Roadrunner Pty Ltd & Andrew & Martin & Ot... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] SADC 41
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This is an appeal against the decision of a Master striking out the Amended Contribution Notice of the first and second defendants because it failed to disclose a reasonable cause of action against the third defendants. To understand the arguments on both sides, it is necessary to explain something of the background events and parties involved. The plaintiff was the lessor of premises at 124 Main Street, Beverley. The plaintiff entered into a lease with SA Nut Co Pty Ltd whereby the premises were leased to Nut Co for a term of three years commencing on 1st October, 1995. Pursuant to clause 16 of the lease, the third defendants guaranteed performance of all of the covenants in the lease by the lessee, Nut Co. In or about May, 1998, Nut Co entered into administration and changed its name to ACN 007 706 452 Pty Ltd. On 16th June, 1998, ACN 007 706 452 Pty Ltd (Administrator Appointed) sold its business to the first defendant, Roadrunner Pty Ltd. The lease of the premises was assigned to Roadrunner by a Deed of Assignment between ACN 007 706 452 Pty Ltd (Administrator Appointed) (as assignor) and Roadrunner (as assignee) and Carpetex (as lessor). Also on 16th June, 1998, the third defendant, Mr G.M. Andrew, entered into a Deed of Guarantee whereby he agreed to guarantee the obligations of Roadrunner to Carpetex pursuant to the lease. Roadrunner did not seek a renewal of the lease but held over pursuant to the lease on a monthly basis, vacating the premises on 30th June, 2001. The plaintiff claimed that the first defendant, Roadrunner, when it vacated the premises, failed to carry out its obligations, including the obligation to make good pursuant to the lease. The plaintiff also claimed that the second defendant, as a guarantor under the lease, failed to meet his obligations, including the obligation to make good pursuant to the lease. On 19th January, 2004, the first defendant (Roadrunner) and the second defendant (Mr Andrew) issued a Contribution Notice against the third defendants. This Notice was amended and finally an Amended Contribution Notice was filed. The proceedings as between Carpetex and the third defendants have settled, subject to the third defendants obtaining a release from the Contribution Notice. The first and second defendants have refused to provide such a release. In that situation the third defendants filed an application seeking orders that the Amended Contribution Notice filed against them by the first and second defendants be struck out on the basis that it disclosed no cause of action known to the law. Alternatively, the third defendants sought summary judgment in their favour in the contribution proceedings. On 17th November, 2004, the Master made the following orders:-“1.I strike out the Amended Contribution Notice.2.I award to the third defendants against the first and second defendants their costs of and incidental to the contribution claim including the cost of the application and argument.”This appeal is against those orders. The appeal is brought pursuant to s 43(2)(a) of the District Court Act 1991 and District Court Rule 97. DCR 97 provides that this appeal be by way of rehearing. No additional material has been filed. There is no need for the appellant to show error and the Court simply considers the matter afresh. The court considered the legal issues of unjust enrichment and equitable contribution. In relation to unjust enrichment, the court found that the parties had contractual obligations that determined their rights and obligations, which precluded a claim based on unjust enrichment. In relation to equitable contribution, the court found that the first and second defendants had separate liabilities in respect of their obligations to make good for the same premises, and there was no basis upon which the plaintiff could succeed against the first and second defendants for the period prior to the date of the assignment. The court found that it was proper that the learned Master ordered that the Amended Contribution Notice be struck out. The appeal was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established