Carpenteri v Registrar of Firearms

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Appeal to a Single Judge)

CARPENTERI v REGISTRAR OF FIREARMS

[2021] SASC 27

Judgment of the Honourable Chief Justice Kourakis  

17 March 2021

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS - SOUTH AUSTRALIAN CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

FIRE, EXPLOSIVES AND FIREARMS - FIREARMS - LICENSING AND REGISTRATION - APPLICATION FOR LICENCE OR PERMIT - FIT AND PROPER PERSON

STATUTES - ACTS OF PARLIAMENT - INTERPRETATION

This is an appeal against a decision of the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (the Tribunal), on internal review, affirming a decision of the Tribunal to cancel the appellant’s firearms licence. The appellant’s firearms licence was suspended by the delegate of the Registrar of Firearms (the Delegate) after the appellant was found in possession of 20kg of harvested cannabis plant material. The appellant pleaded guilty to, and was convicted of, one count of trafficking in a controlled drug. The sentencing Judge accepted the appellant’s explanation that his involvement was ancillary and his intentions were to assist the co-accused, who was suffering from cancer, to produce cannabis oil for the purposes of pain relief. The sentencing Judge nonetheless convicted the appellant of trafficking because he was aware that the co-accused intended to sell any surplus.

A short time after the appellant’s conviction, the Delegate cancelled his firearms licence under s 20 of the Firearms Act 2015 (SA) (Firearms Act) on the basis that the appellant was no longer a fit and proper person to hold a firearms licence. The appellant appealed the Delegate’s decision to the Tribunal. A Senior Member of the Tribunal affirmed the Delegate’s decision on internal review.

The appellant appeals to this Court on two grounds: (1) that the decision was legally unreasonable in that it was made on an incorrect factual basis which failed to take into account the special circumstances accepted by the sentencing Judge; and (2) the reasons given by the Senior Member were inadequate and did not disclose the factual basis on which the decision was made.

Held per Kourakis CJ dismissing the appeal.

1. The jurisdiction exercised by the Registrar of Firearms under the Firearms Act is not dependent on, or in any way constrained by, findings made for the purposes of sentencing.

2.   It would be an error of law to confine the Tribunal, in the exercise of its administrative jurisdiction, to facts found in the criminal jurisdiction where the exercise of the Tribunal’s jurisdiction is not so tied.

3.   The Senior Member’s reasons disclose an adequate reasoning process based on a sound factual basis, which included the factual basis found by the sentencing Judge, in finding that the appellant’s conduct reflected poorly on his judgment and character such that he is unfit to hold a firearms licence.

Firearms Act 2015 (SA) ss 7, 14, 15, 17, 20. ; South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (SA) ss 34, 37, 39, 71.; Firearms Regulations 2017 (SA) sch 2, cl 1(b)., referred to.
That’s Entertainment WA Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Police (2013)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carpenteri v Registrar of Firearms and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] SASC 27
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Carpenteri v Registrar of Firearms, the applicant, Mr Carpenteri, sought a review of a decision by the Registrar to cancel his firearms licence. The decision was made after Mr Carpenteri was convicted of trafficking in a controlled drug, specifically cannabis oil. The South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (SACAAT) upheld the Registrar's decision, leading Mr Carpenteri to appeal to the Supreme Court of South Australia. The appeal centred on the grounds that the Tribunal's decision was based on incorrect facts and that the Registrar's decision was otherwise unlawful. The court had to determine whether the Registrar's decision to cancel the firearms licence was made in accordance with the law and whether the Tribunal had correctly exercised its jurisdiction in reviewing that decision.

The primary legal issue was whether the Registrar's decision to cancel Mr Carpenteri's firearms licence was made in accordance with the applicable statutory framework and whether the Tribunal had correctly exercised its jurisdiction in reviewing that decision. The court had to consider whether the Registrar's decision was based on a proper interpretation of the relevant statutory provisions, specifically the Firearms Act. Furthermore, the court had to assess whether the Tribunal correctly exercised its jurisdiction under the Administrative Laws Act, particularly in relation to the factual basis upon which the Registrar's decision was made.

The court held that the Registrar's jurisdiction under the Firearms Act was not constrained by findings made for the purposes of sentencing, and thus the Tribunal was not bound by the facts found in the criminal jurisdiction. The court found that the Senior Member of the Tribunal had provided adequate reasoning based on a sound factual basis, which included the facts found by the sentencing judge. The court rejected Mr Carpenteri's contention that the Tribunal should have inferred that he was fit to hold a firearms licence from the sentencing judge's decision not to impose a penalty of imprisonment. The court also dismissed the argument that the Tribunal had placed undue weight on Mr Carpenteri's association with his co-accused, Mr Surace, in reaching its decision. The court concluded that the Tribunal's decision was based on a sound factual basis and that Mr Carpenteri's criminal history, including his drug-related offence, reflected poorly on his judgment and character, making him unfit to hold a firearms licence.

The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal, affirming the Registrar's decision to cancel Mr Carpenteri's firearms licence. The court held that the Registrar's jurisdiction under the Firearms Act was not dependent on findings made for the purposes of sentencing, and that the Tribunal had correctly exercised its jurisdiction in reviewing the decision. The court found that the Tribunal's reasons were adequate and based on a sound factual basis, which included the facts found by the sentencing judge. The court rejected Mr Carpenteri's contentions regarding the factual basis and the Tribunal's reasoning, upholding the Registrar's decision to cancel his firearms licence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Held per Kourakis CJ dismissing the appeal.

1. The jurisdiction exercised by the Registrar of Firearms under the Firearms Act is not dependent on, or in any way constrained by, findings made for the purposes of sentencing.

2. It would be an error of law to confine the Tribunal, in the exercise of its administrative jurisdiction, to facts found in the criminal jurisdiction where the exercise of the Tribunal’s jurisdiction is not so tied.

3. The Senior Member’s reasons disclose an adequate reasoning process based on a sound factual basis, which included the factual basis found by the sentencing Judge, in finding that the appellant’s conduct reflected poorly on his judgment and character such that he is unfit to hold a firearms licence.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Judge accepted that Mr Carpenteri did not intend to take a direct part in any subsequent sale of cannabis oil by Mr Surace, but explained that Mr Carpenteri was nonetheless guilty of trafficking because he was aware that Mr Surace did intend to sell any surplus. The Judge was satisfied that Mr Carpenteri’s involvement was for altruistic purposes and that is was most unlikely that he would offend again. The Judge recorded a conviction without imposing any other penalty, and placed Mr Carpenteri on a bond in the sum of $1,000 to be of good behaviour for a period of three years.The Tribunal decision The Senior Member had before her the Police Apprehension Report and the Judge’s sentencing remarks. Mr Carpenteri filed an affidavit in the Tribunal in support of his application to review the decision of the Delegate. However, Mr Carpenteri did not attend the hearing and was therefore not available for cross‑examination. No adjournment was sought. As a result, those parts of his affidavit which attempted to elaborate on the circumstances of his offending were not received. The Senior Member noted the submission put on Mr Carpenteri’s behalf that the Tribunal should read into the Judge’s decision not to impose a penalty of imprisonment, which would have attracted, by force of statute, conditions prohibiting Mr Carpenteri from possessing firearms an opinion that Mr Carpenteri was fit to continue to hold a firearms licence. That submission is misconceived and the Senior Member correctly rejected it. The simple bond to which Mr Carpenteri was sentenced shows only that the Judge did not consider a period of imprisonment was warranted. No conclusion can be reached on whether the Judge had any view about Mr Carpenteri’s fitness to hold a firearms licence more generally. Moreover, it was not part of the Judge’s sentencing function to form any opinion on that question. That responsibility fell to be determined administratively pursuant to the Firearms Act. The Senior Member’s reasons for affirming the decision of the Delegate were:[12]The Tribunal is entitled to take Mr Carpenteri’s criminal history into account in reviewing the Delegate’s decision. It is notable that he has in 3 separate ways transgressed against the law relating to weaponry in SA – firstly in 2011 in possessing an unregistered air rifle, and secondly and thirdly in 2016 in possessing prohibited weapons. That is not a history of responsible behaviour in regards to weaponry. It detracts significantly from the submission put on behalf of Mr Carpenteri about his ‘previous responsible storage and use of firearms’ (applicant’s outline of argument dated 9 July 2019 at paragraph 20).[13]In relation to a criminal history of drug offending, there are previous decisions of both the District Court and the Tribunal upholding the cancellation of firearms licences when the licence holder had drug convictions. There does not need to be any nexus between the firearms and the drug offending. Mr Carpenteri was convicted of ‘traffic (type unknown) in a controlled drug – basic’. The Registrar submits that is a more serious charge than possession. I accept that submission. I reject the applicant’s contention that the weight of the charge is diminished by the fact that out of 20kg of cannabis detected, only 1.6kg was ‘usable’, or by Mr Carpenteri’s involvement with the cannabis being characterised by the sentencing judge as ‘ancillary’ or ‘altruistic’. It was and remains a serious charge regardless of Mr Carpenteri’s motive. Becoming involved with drug offending reflects poorly on both Mr Carpenteri’s character and his decision-making ability, even if his involvement was ‘ancillary’.[14]Mr Carpenteri contends that in reaching the decision to cancel Mr Carpenteri’s firearms licence the Delegate placed undue weight on his association with his co‑accused Mr Surace. The Tribunal is satisfied that there are sufficient reasons to affirm the decision to cancel Mr Carpenteri’s firearms licence without needing to examine minutely Mr Surace’s history or Mr Carpenteri’s association with him.(Citations omitted)Ground 1 – Incorrect factual basis

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established