Carol Anne Kiel v H C Curwen-Walker

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRAR  VI 687/94

B E T W E E N :

CAROL ANNE KIEL
Applicant

AND

H C CURWEN-WALKER
Respondent

BEFORE:     Judicial Registrar Millane

PLACE:        Melbourne

DATE:          27 October 1994

Reasons for Judgment

The Applicant brings this proceeding pursuant to Section 170 EA of the Industrial Relations Act 1988 (“the Act”). She alleges that her employment with the Respondent was terminated by him without valid reason and that such termination was harsh, unjust or unreasonable both in a substantive and procedural sense.

The relief sought under Section 170 EE of the Act before its amendment in June this year includes:-

1(a) An order declaring the termination of the employees employment to have contravened Division 3 of part VIA of the Industrial Relations Act 1988;

(b)       An order that the Respondent pay compensation.

  1. Such other order or orders as will put the employee in the same position (as nearly as can be done), as if the employment of the employee by the Respondent had not been terminated: see Section 170 EE of the Act.

The Respondent’s primary argument is that the Applicant resigned from her employment. Alternatively, he argues that at interview the Applicant misled him as to her capacity to perform the duties of a law clerk the job for which she was hired at a rate of pay commensurate to that position. As a result, the Respondent claims to have been entitled to rescind and terminate the contract of employment once he became aware of the Applicant’s lack of capacity. The misrepresentation permitted the contract to be terminated immediately without complying with any terms of the contract of employment even as to termination or, it was argued, without offering any warnings and period of time within which to improve the Applicant’s performance. Further the Applicant’s lack of capacity to meet the job requirements constitutes a valid reason under the Act for terminating the Applicant. Again this could be done without offering any warnings or training. Although, this was not stated explicitly in the Respondent’s submission I understood the second limb of the Respondent’s case to be that the evidence given by the Respondent as to a series of events which occurred during the currency of the Applicant’s short lived employment was evidence of her lack of capacity to meet the job requirements. This evidence was not relied upon to characterise the termination as one for reasons related to her conduct or performance where Section 170 DC(a), Article 7 of Schedule 10 and paragraph 8 of Schedule 11 to the Act sign post steps to be taken by an employer to incorporate procedural fairness in the termination process.

The following witnesses were called to give evidence:-

  1. by the Applicant -
               The Applicant
               Julian Alexander Tey, Solicitor
               Timothy John Robertson, Solicitor
               Vicki Elizabeth Berger, fellow employee
               Ernest John Kirk, builder

  2. by the Respondent:-
               The Respondent

History

The Respondent is a solicitor and sole practitioner who, as at April 1994 operated three law practices in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carol Anne Kiel v H C Curwen-Walker and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1994] IRCA 128
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Carol Anne Kiel v H C Curwen-Walker, heard by Judicial Registrar Millane, involves the Applicant, Carol Anne Kiel, who brought proceedings against her former employer, H C Curwen-Walker, alleging that her employment was terminated without valid reason and that the termination was harsh, unjust, or unreasonable under Section 170 of the Industrial Relations Act 1988. The Applicant sought a declaration that her termination contravened the Act, as well as compensation for lost remuneration and other losses resulting from the termination. The Respondent argued that the Applicant resigned from her employment and that she had misrepresented her skills and capacity during the interview process, justifying the termination. Alternatively, he claimed that her lack of capacity to perform the job constituted a valid reason for termination.

The court had to decide whether the Respondent had established a valid reason for the termination under the Act, whether the termination was a resignation or a constructive dismissal, and what compensation, if any, was appropriate. The court first considered the evidence regarding the alleged misrepresentation of skills by the Applicant. The court found that the evidence did not support the claim that the Applicant misrepresented her skills to the Respondent. The court also examined the Respondent's evidence regarding the Applicant's performance during her employment, concluding that the complaints did not demonstrate a lack of capacity to perform the job.

Turning to the issue of whether the termination was a resignation or a constructive dismissal, the court found that the Respondent's actions amounted to a constructive dismissal. The Respondent had pressured the Applicant to resign, offering her payment in lieu of notice and a positive reference, which the court found to be inconsistent with the Respondent's belief that the Applicant lacked the capacity to perform her job. The court ordered compensation for the Applicant, considering the reduction in her income and the period of unemployment before she found new employment. The court also ordered the Applicant to pay the expenses of two witnesses who testified on her behalf.