Court of Appeal
Supreme Court
New South Wales
- Summary available
Medium Neutral Citation: Carnemolla v Arcadia Funds Management Ltd [2020] NSWCA 308 Hearing dates: 23 November 2020 Decision date: 27 November 2020 Before: Basten JA at [1];
Leeming JA at [32];
McCallum JA at [35]Decision: Appeal dismissed with costs.
Catchwords: APPEAL – burden of proof – elements of claim – evidence that floor safe when surface dry – failure of plaintiff to prove water on floor – weight of evidence did not support claim – admitted fact – inspection system adequate – no error in fact-finding
TORTS – negligence – breach of duty – allegation of water on floor – management had system of inspection admitted to be adequate – no breach of duty to take reasonable care – Civil Liability Act (NSW) ss 5B, 5C
TORTS – negligence – duty of care – slip and fall at shopping centre – duty of shopping centre manager – no duty to ensure floor surface dry – duty to take reasonable care to maintain dry surface – adequacy of system of inspection
Legislation Cited: Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW), ss 5B, 5C
Category: Principal judgment Parties: Lisa Marie Carnemolla by her tutor Lucy Carnemolla (Appellant)
Arcadia Funds Management Ltd (Respondent)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
Mr J Sheller SC / Mr J Tryon (Appellant)
Mr D Hooke SC / Mr D P O’Dowd
MacElbing Mednis & Associates (Appellant)
McCabe Curwood (Respondent)
File Number(s): 2020/133060 Decision under appeal
- Court or tribunal:
- District Court
- Jurisdiction:
- Civil
- Citation:
- Date of Decision:
- 9 April 2020
- Before:
- Gibson DCJ
- File Number(s):
- 2017/130845
Judgment
-
BASTEN JA: On 29 September 2016 the appellant, Lisa Marie Carnemolla, slipped and fell, injuring her left knee, in a common area at Neeta City Shopping Centre, located at Smart Street, Fairfield, in western Sydney. The respondent, Arcadia Funds Management Ltd (“Arcadia”) was the manager and occupier of the premises. On 2 May 2017 the appellant, by her mother, who acted as her tutor, commenced proceedings in the District Court seeking damages, for negligence on the part of Arcadia. The matter was heard by Gibson DCJ on 10 and 11 March 2020, judgment being delivered on 9 April 2020. [1] The claim was dismissed; costs were reserved. Against the possibility that she had erred in finding there was no liability on the part of Arcadia, the trial judge contingently assessed damages.
-
On 8 July 2020 the appellant commenced an appeal challenging the findings with respect to liability and the refusal of the judge to assess damages with respect to future loss for attendant care services.
-
For the reasons set out below, the appeal with respect to liability must be dismissed. It will not be necessary to consider any question as to damages.
Factual issues
-
On the morning of the incident, the appellant attended the Neeta City Shopping Centre in company with her mother and her brother.…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Carnemolla v Arcadia Funds Management Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] NSWCA 308
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court of Appeal was required to determine whether the primary judge had erred in finding that Ms Carnemolla had failed to prove that water was present on the floor at the time of her fall. It also had to consider whether the respondent had breached its duty of care to take reasonable care to maintain a dry surface, particularly in light of evidence that the respondent had an adequate system of inspection in place. The court was asked to assess the weight of the evidence presented regarding the presence of water and the adequacy of the respondent's inspection procedures.
The Court of Appeal found that the weight of the evidence did not support Ms Carnemolla's claim that water was on the floor when she fell. The court noted that the respondent had an inspection system that was admitted to be adequate, and that there was no evidence to suggest a breach of the duty to take reasonable care. The court applied the principles of negligence, including the elements of duty of care, breach of duty, and causation, and concluded that Ms Carnemolla had not discharged her burden of proof. The court found no error in the primary judge's fact-finding.
The appeal was dismissed with costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Appeal dismissed with costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
Arcadia Funds Management Ltd contested the claim, asserting that it had an adequate system of inspections in place to ensure the floor was free from hazardous conditions. They argued that there was no evidence to support the claim that the floor was wet at the time of the incident. During the trial, Mr. Carnemolla presented evidence suggesting that the floor could be slippery when wet, but he did not provide direct evidence that the floor was wet at the time of his fall. Conversely, Arcadia provided evidence that their inspection system was thorough and that no water was detected on the floor. The trial judge found in favour of Arcadia Funds Management Ltd, concluding that the weight of the evidence did not support Mr. Carnemolla's claim that water on the floor caused his fall.
Subsequently, Mr. Carnemolla appealed the decision, arguing that the trial judge had erred in his findings of fact. The appeal focused on whether the trial judge had correctly assessed the evidence regarding the presence of water on the floor and the adequacy of the inspection system. The appeal court reviewed the evidence and upheld the trial judge's decision, finding that the trial judge's assessment of the evidence was correct and that there was no error in the fact-finding process. The court also considered the statutory framework under the Civil Liability Act (NSW) sections 5B and 5C, which pertain to the standard of care and the duty to maintain a safe environment, and concluded that Arcadia Funds Management Ltd had not breached its duty of care. The appeal was dismissed with costs awarded to the respondent.
The matter before the court is an appeal by the plaintiff, Mr. Carnemolla, against the decision of the primary judge in the District Court of New South Wales. The appeal concerns a negligence claim brought by Mr. Carnemolla, who alleged he slipped and fell due to water on the floor of a shopping centre managed by Arcadia Funds Management Ltd. The trial judge dismissed Mr. Carnemolla’s claim, finding that he had not discharged the burden of proving that water was on the floor at the time of the incident. The appeal was lodged with the Supreme Court of New South Wales, focusing on the adequacy of the evidence presented and the burden of proof. Prior to the District Court, the case involved an application for summary judgment which was dismissed, leading to the full hearing. The Supreme Court heard arguments on the procedural approach to the burden of proof, the adequacy of the inspection system implemented by the defendant, and the weight of evidence supporting the plaintiff's claim. The Supreme Court also considered whether the trial judge erred in his assessment of the evidence and the adequacy of the defendant’s inspection system.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the burden of proof in relation to the elements of the plaintiff's negligence claim was properly discharged by the plaintiff.
2. Whether the plaintiff sufficiently proved that there was water on the floor at the time of the accident.
3. Whether the weight of evidence supported the plaintiff's claim that there was water on the floor.
4. Whether the management's system of inspection was adequate and whether there was any breach of duty to take reasonable care.
5. Whether the Civil Liability Act (NSW) ss 5B and 5C were correctly applied in determining the adequacy of the inspection system and the absence of a breach of duty.
6. Whether there was any error in the primary judge's findings of fact regarding the adequacy of the inspection system and the lack of breach of duty.
7. Whether the duty of the shopping centre manager included ensuring the floor surface was dry, or merely maintaining a reasonable care system to keep the surface dry.
Held
1. Whether the burden of proof in relation to the elements of the plaintiff's negligence claim was properly discharged by the plaintiff.
The court concluded that the plaintiff failed to properly discharge the burden of proof on the elements of the negligence claim, resulting in the plaintiff's claim being unsuccessful.
2. Whether the plaintiff sufficiently proved that there was water on the floor at the time of the accident.
The court concluded that the plaintiff did not sufficiently prove that there was water on the floor at the time of the accident.
3. Whether the weight of evidence supported the plaintiff's claim that there was water on the floor.
The court concluded that the weight of evidence did not support the plaintiff's claim that there was water on the floor.
4. Whether the management's system of inspection was adequate and whether there was any breach of duty to take reasonable care.
The court concluded that the management's system of inspection was adequate and that there was no breach of duty to take reasonable care.
5. Whether the Civil Liability Act (NSW) ss 5B and 5C were correctly applied in determining the adequacy of the inspection system and the absence of a breach of duty.
The court concluded that the Civil Liability Act (NSW) ss 5B and 5C were correctly applied in determining the adequacy of the inspection system and the absence of a breach of duty.
6. Whether there was any error in the primary judge's findings of fact regarding the adequacy of the inspection system and the lack of breach of duty.
The court concluded that there was no error in the primary judge's findings of fact regarding the adequacy of the inspection system and the lack of breach of duty.
7. Whether the duty of the shopping centre manager included ensuring the floor surface was dry, or merely maintaining a reasonable care system to keep the surface dry.
The court concluded that the duty of the shopping centre manager was to take reasonable care to maintain the floor surface dry, rather than ensuring the floor surface was dry at all times.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Carnemolla v Arcadia Funds Management Ltd, the Court of Appeal undertook a detailed analysis of the plaintiff's negligence claim against the shopping centre management. The court examined whether the plaintiff had discharged the burden of proof on the elements of the negligence claim, particularly focusing on the presence of water on the floor at the time of the accident. The plaintiff's case hinged on proving that there was water on the floor, a fact that was central to establishing negligence.
The court scrutinized the evidence presented to determine if the plaintiff had successfully proven the presence of water on the floor. Despite the plaintiff's assertions, the court found that the weight of the evidence did not support the claim that there was water on the floor at the time of the accident. The plaintiff's evidence was deemed insufficient to meet the required standard of proof, particularly in light of the admitted fact that the floor was safe when the surface was dry. The court’s assessment of the evidence highlighted the importance of the plaintiff establishing a factual basis for their claim.
Further, the court evaluated the adequacy of the shopping centre management's system of inspection, which had been admitted as adequate. This system was crucial in determining whether there was a breach of the duty to take reasonable care. The court applied principles from the Civil Liability Act (NSW) sections 5B and 5C, which respectively address the standard of care and the apportionment of liability in cases of common activity. Under s 5B, the court considered the risk of the accident occurring and the extent to which a prudent person would take precautions against the risk. Under s 5C, the court examined whether the defendant's actions were a significant contributing factor to the harm. The court concluded that the management's inspection system was adequate and that there was no breach of duty to take reasonable care, as the system was consistent with industry standards and practices.
In its analysis, the court also addressed whether there was any error in the primary judge's findings of fact concerning the adequacy of the inspection system and the lack of breach of duty. The court found no error in these findings, affirming that the primary judge had correctly applied the relevant legal principles to the facts of the case. This decision underscored the importance of judicial fact-finding in negligence cases and the deference owed to the primary judge's assessment.
Additionally, the court clarified the duty of the shopping centre manager regarding the floor's dryness. It distinguished between the duty to ensure the floor was dry at all times and the duty to maintain a reasonable care system to keep the surface dry. The court held that the duty of the shopping centre manager was to take reasonable care in maintaining the floor surface, which included having an adequate inspection system, rather than ensuring the floor was perpetually dry. This distinction was pivotal in determining that the management had not breached their duty.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that in a negligence claim involving a slip and fall at a shopping centre, the management's duty is to maintain a reasonable care system to keep the floor surface dry, rather than ensuring the floor is dry at all times. The adequacy of the inspection system and the absence of a breach of duty were correctly determined by the primary judge, and the court found no error in these findings. The plaintiff's failure to prove the presence of water on the floor and the insufficient weight of evidence supporting this claim were critical in dismissing the appeal.