Carmichael Rail Network Pty Ltd v BBC Chartering Carriers GmbH & Co KG

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

GAGELER CJ,
GORDON, STEWARD, GLEESON AND JAGOT JJ

CARMICHAEL RAIL NETWORK PTY LTD
AS TRUSTEE FOR THE CARMICHAEL
RAIL NETWORK TRUST  APPELLANT

AND

BBC CHARTERING CARRIERS GMBH & CO KG
& ANOR  RESPONDENTS

Carmichael Rail Network Pty Ltd v BBC Chartering Carriers GmbH &
Co KG

[2024] HCA 4

Date of Hearing: 17 October 2023
Date of Judgment: 14 February 2024

B32/2023

ORDER

1.Appeal dismissed.

2.The appellant pay the respondents' costs of the appeal.

On appeal from the Federal Court of Australia

Representation

E G H Cox SC with D J Reynolds for the appellant (instructed by Mills Oakley)

G J Nell SC with J K Kennedy for the first respondent (instructed by Aus Ship Lawyers)

J A Hogan-Doran SC for the second respondent (instructed by HWL Ebsworth Lawyers)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. GAGELER CJ, GORDON, STEWARD, GLEESON AND JAGOT JJ. This appeal concerns the proper construction of Art 3(8) of the "Australian Hague Rules", incorporated into Australian law by s 8 of the Carriage of Goods by Sea Act 1991 (Cth)[1] ("the COGSA"). By s 10(1) of that Act, the Australian Hague Rules apply to a contract of carriage of goods by sea, relevantly, from a port in Australia to another port in Australia. Article 3(8) provides that any "clause, covenant, or agreement in a contract of carriage relieving the carrier or the ship from liability for loss or damage to ... goods ... or lessening such liability otherwise than as provided in these Rules, shall be null and void and of no effect".

    [1]Schedule 1 to the COGSA contains the amended Hague Rules (unmodified text), generally referred to as the Hague‑Visby Rules. Schedule 1A sets out the modifications of the text in Sch 1. The Australian Hague Rules (as referred to in these reasons for judgment) are the amended Hague Rules in Sch 1 as modified by the text in Sch 1A.

  2. The appellant ("Carmichael", the shipper) contracted with the second respondent ("OneSteel") for the manufacture and supply of head‑hardened steel rails. OneSteel manufactured the rails and, pursuant to a booking note between the first respondent ("BBC", the carrier) and an agent for Carmichael, it was arranged for the rails to be shipped by sea from the Port of Whyalla in South Australia to the Port of Mackay in Queensland. BBC prepared a stowage plan for the rails on the ship. OneSteel's subcontractor loaded the rails onto the ship. A mate's receipt for the goods loaded on the ship was issued and the ship departed from the Port of Whyalla. On the same day, BBC issued a bill of lading for the rails to Carmichael's agent. When the ship arrived in the Port of Mackay the goods on board were unloaded. It was discovered that a collapse of the stowed goods had damaged the rails to the extent they became unusable. The rails were…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carmichael Rail Network Pty Ltd v BBC Chartering Carriers Gm... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] HCA 4
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Carmichael Rail Network Pty Ltd (Carmichael) appealed to the High Court of Australia against a decision of the Full Federal Court concerning an arbitration clause in a bill of lading. The dispute arose from a contract for the carriage of goods by sea, where Carmichael sought to restrain arbitration proceedings commenced by BBC Chartering Carriers GmbH & Co KG (BBC) in London under English law. BBC, in turn, sought a stay of Carmichael's proceedings in the Federal Court in favour of the London arbitration.

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether the arbitration clause in the bill of lading was rendered inoperative by Article 3(8) of the Australian Hague Rules, as contained in Schedule 1A of the *Carriage of Goods by Sea Act 1991* (Cth). Article 3(8) voids any clause that relieves or lessens a carrier's liability for loss or damage to goods otherwise than as provided by the Australian Hague Rules. Carmichael argued that the arbitration clause, by requiring disputes to be resolved in London under English law, would lessen the carrier's liability. The court also considered the effect of an undertaking given by BBC to apply the Australian Hague Rules in the arbitration and a declaration made by the Federal Court to a similar effect.

The High Court rejected Carmichael's submissions regarding the construction of Article 3(8). The court reasoned that the undertaking by BBC and the Federal Court's declaration were relevant facts to be considered at the time of determining whether Article 3(8) was engaged. The undertaking meant that BBC agreed to admit in the arbitration that the Australian Hague Rules, as applied and interpreted under Australian law, would govern the proceedings. The court found that Carmichael's arguments distinguishing between the application and interpretation of the rules under Australian law involved impermissible speculation. Furthermore, the court held that the mere fact that arbitration in London might involve greater expense or a different practical burden for Carmichael did not, in itself, mean that BBC's liability was relieved or lessened in a manner proscribed by Article 3(8). The court affirmed that the relative costs of dispute resolution fall outside the scope of Article 3(8) and that Carmichael had failed to prove any likely greater cost that would engage the provision.

Consequently, the High Court dismissed Carmichael's appeal, upholding the Full Federal Court's decision to restrain the Federal Court proceedings and allow the London arbitration to proceed, based on the undertaking and declaration. The appellant was ordered to pay the respondents' costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal dismissed.

2. The appellant pay the respondents' costs of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

GAGELER CJ, GORDON, STEWARD, GLEESON AND JAGOT JJ
Even if the expense to and "practical burden" on Carmichael might be greater by reason of the arbitration in London than it would be if, instead, Carmichael's proceeding in the Federal Court of Australia were permitted to proceed, there are no meaningful criteria by which it can be said that such greater cost in fact relieves or lessens BBC's liability otherwise than in accordance with the Australian Hague Rules. For example, what percentage cost increase will suffice before it can be said that liability is lessened or relieved? While Carmichael may choose to conduct two sets of proceedings, one against BBC in the arbitration and one against OneSteel in Australia, it may be inferred that Carmichael's choice will be informed by the returns it considers it could receive. The mere fact that this choice is available also does not mean that BBC's potential liability to Carmichael is relieved or lessened. The Full Court was correct to conclude that "[w]here the relative costs of dispute resolution fall are simply not within the scope of Art 3(8)".[71] Carmichael would have also failed on this ground for lack of proof of any greater cost being likely to be incurred by the parties complying with their contractual bargain in cl 4 of the bill of lading to arbitrate any disputes in London.[71]Carmichael Rail Network Pty Ltd v BBC Chartering Carriers GmbH & Company KG (The BBC Nile) (2022) 295 FCR 81 at 92 [45].Conclusion and orders The Full Court did not err in dismissing Carmichael's application to restrain the conduct of the arbitration and granting BBC's application that Carmichael's proceeding in the Federal Court of Australia be stayed, on the basis of the undertaking that BBC gave and the declaration the Full Court made by consent between Carmichael and BBC. The orders which should be made are:(1) The appeal be dismissed.(2)The appellant pay the respondents' costs of the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GAGELER CJ, GORDON, STEWARD, GLEESON AND JAGOT JJ

It follows that Carmichael's submissions on the construction of Art 3(8) of the Australian Hague Rules must be rejected, including its submissions that once a shipper shows that a clause, if enforced, may potentially lessen the carrier's liability, then the clause is to be held void unless the carrier demonstrates that the risk will not eventuate.The undertaking and declaration Carmichael submitted that the undertaking and declaration did not assist BBC's case as: (a) BBC has no assets in Australia against which the undertaking may be enforced; and (b) the undertaking and declaration concern the application in the arbitration of the Australian Hague Rules as applied under Australian law and not the application in the arbitration of the Australian Hague Rules as interpreted under Australian law. Carmichael's first contention, that BBC has no assets in Australia against which the undertaking may be enforced, involves speculation that BBC, having given its undertaking to the Full Court, will, and will be permitted in the arbitration to, act contrary to its undertaking in the arbitration in some way. As explained above, that speculation is impermissible. Carmichael's second contention, distinguishing between the Australian Hague Rules as applied and as interpreted under Australian law, also involves speculation. Senior counsel for BBC accepted, in the hearing of the appeal, that the undertaking meant that BBC undertook to admit in the arbitration that the Australian Hague Rules as applied and as interpreted under Australian law applied. To avoid any suggestion that BBC had not submitted to the jurisdiction of the Federal Court, the Full Court also made the declaration with the consent of BBC. Given this, Carmichael accepted in the hearing of the appeal that if its construction of the undertaking as excluding the Australian interpretation of Australian law was incorrect, the only risk to it was of "rogue" arbitrators acting contrary to the agreement of the parties and, thereby, contrary to s 46 of the UK Arbitration Act (discussed below). This exemplifies the "insular distrust" rightly eschewed in Sky Reefer. The terms of the undertaking and declaration, to the effect that the Australian Hague Rules as applied under Australian law apply in the arbitration, bear only one possible meaning. The words "as applied" necessarily carry with them the meaning "as interpreted". The Australian Hague Rules cannot be applied under Australian law unless they are interpreted in accordance with Australian law. The undertaking and declaration are facts relevant to the operation of Art 3(8). To the extent Carmichael submitted they could not be considered because they had come into existence only after BBC had relied on cl 4 of the bill of lading to commence the arbitration in London, the submission cannot be accepted. Lord Diplock's statement in The Hollandia that "the time at which to ascertain whether a choice of forum clause will have an effect that is proscribed by article III, paragraph 8 should be when ... the carrier seeks to bring the clause into operation and to rely upon it"[62] does not mean that, in this case, the Full Court was (or this Court is) confined to the facts as they existed at the time BBC commenced the arbitration in reliance on cl 4 of the bill of lading (that is, before the giving of the undertaking and the making of the declaration). The facts are those admitted, agreed, or found (or those which are ex facie apparent) at the time the court is deciding if Art 3(8) is engaged or not. [62]The Hollandia [1983] 1 AC 565 at 575.