Carlyle v Queensland Law Society

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Carlyle v Queensland Law Society [2022] QCAT 208

PARTIES:

ALEXANDRA CARLYLE

(applicant)

v

QUEENSLAND LAW SOCIETY

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

GAR606-21

MATTER TYPE:

General administrative review matters

DELIVERED ON:

21 July 2022

HEARING DATE:

On the papers

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Justice Mellifont, President

ORDERS:

1.   Leave is granted to the Queensland Law Society to be represented by in-house practitioner, briefing external Counsel.

2.   Leave is granted to the Applicant to be represented by solicitors and/or counsel.

3.   Directions 6 to 9 of the directions issued 8 February 2022 are vacated.

4.   The Applicant is to file and serve her written submissions by: 4 pm on 19 August 2022.

5.   The Respondent is to file and serve its written submissions by: 4 pm on 2 September 2022.

6.   The Applicant is to file and serve any reply to the respondent’s submissions by: 4 pm 16 September 2022.

7.   The matter is listed for a short directions hearing on 27 September 2022.

8.   The matter is to be listed for a tribunal hearing at a time and date to be fixed upon consultation with parties and the registry, not before 27 September 2022.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE OR TERRITORY COURTS – PARTIES AND REPRESENTATION – LEGAL REPRESENTATION – where the Queensland Law Society applied to be legally represented by a barrister – where the application was opposed on various grounds – where the party seeking leave is a State agency – whether there are complex questions of fact and law involved – whether it is in the interests of justice for leave to be granted 

Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld), s 359, s 381(1), s 382(1), s 383

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 20, s 29(1)(a), s 29(2)(3)(a), s 43, s 43(3)(a), s 43(3)(d)

Litherland v Sunshine Coast Regional Council [2019] QCAT 75
Chaudhary v Medical Board of Queensland [2012] QCAT 172

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

This matter was heard and determined on the papers pursuant to s 32 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld)

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. On 20 May 2022, I made a decision granting leave for the Queensland Law Society to be represented to by Counsel, instructed by in-house Counsel. 

  2. That decision was made to consequent upon an application for leave to be represented made by the Queensland Law Society (‘the Society’), who is the respondent in the principal proceedings, to be represented by:

    a)Ms Hunt, Senior In-House Legal Counsel; and

    b)Mr Somers, Barrister-at-Law, from the private bar. 

  3. The decision was made after having considered all relevant circumstances, the written application by the Society, and the submissions in response by the Applicant. 

  4. A request for reasons for that decision has since been received by the Tribunal.

  5. These are my reasons for that decision.

THE NATURE OF THE SUBSTANTIVE PROCEEDINGS

  1. The Applicant seeks a review by the Tribunal of a decision of the Committee of Management, a statutory committee and delegate of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carlyle v Queensland Law Society and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QCAT 208
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Carlyle v Queensland Law Society, the Applicant sought to review a decision by the Society to disallow her claim for compensation from the Fidelity Fund. The Applicant alleged that she was a victim of fraud when her settlement funds for the purchase of a business were misappropriated by the law firm, Phoenix Lawyers Pty Ltd, and its principal, Ms Juliette Wright. The Applicant argued that the Society's decision was inconsistent with current law, that the committee had considered irrelevant material, omitted relevant information, and included factual inaccuracies. The Society argued that the Applicant had not suffered a pecuniary loss, that the monies were not trust money or property, and that any loss was resolved by a settlement with the Vendor.

The Tribunal considered the legal issues raised by the Applicant's claim, including the definition of "default" under the Legal Profession Uniform Law Application Act 2014 (Qld), the interpretation of relevant sections of the Act, and the applicable legal principles governing the review of administrative decisions. The Tribunal examined the evidence and submissions presented by both parties and assessed the merits of the Applicant's claim in light of the relevant law. The Tribunal considered whether the decision was based on an error of law, whether relevant considerations were taken into account and irrelevant considerations were excluded, and whether the decision was irrational or unjust.

After careful consideration of the evidence and submissions, the Tribunal found that the Society's decision was the correct and preferable decision. The Tribunal held that the Applicant had not suffered a pecuniary loss, as the settlement had been reached with the Vendor, and that the monies were not trust money or property. The Tribunal also found that the decision-maker had considered all relevant material and that the decision was not based on irrelevant matters or factual inaccuracies. The Tribunal dismissed the Applicant's review application and affirmed the Society's decision.

The Tribunal did not make any orders for costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal’s function on the review application is to produce the correct and preferable decision.[1][1]Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) (‘QCAT Act’) s 20.GROUNDS UPON WHICH THE APPLICANT SAY SHE SHOULD PREVAIL IN QCAT AGAINST THE SOCIETY’S DECISION TO DISALLOW HER CLAIM The Applicant set out the grounds upon which she says she should prevail in QCAT against the Society’s decision to disallow her claim in her Form 23, Application to review a decision filed in QCAT and Annexure A thereto. I will not here repeat the details, or set out the material in the various annexures to the application, but rather provide a snapshot summary: a)The Applicant made a claim against the Fidelity Fund on the basis that the settlement funds of $365,000 for purchase of the business, Price Attack, Robina, was paid into the bank account of the registered practice Phoenix Lawyers Pty Ltd, upon the written direction of the Principal, Ms Juliette Wright, acting for the Vendor Brabus;b)The Queensland Police Service Financial Cyber Crime group notified the claimant[2] (who I take to be the Applicant) that the actual purchase price was $281,054.09, and as a result the Applicant was a victim of fraud as the remaining $115,450 of the funds was misappropriated by Phoenix Lawyers Pty Ltd, which Ms Wright used for her own purposes;[2]The term used by the Society to describe Ms Carlyle.c)The Applicant claimed this amount of $115,450 as compensation from the Fidelity Fund; d)The Applicant submits that the decision by the Society is unsustainable. In that respect, the Applicant submits that:(i) The decision is not consistent with current law; (ii) The committee considered irrelevant material not pertinent to the claim;(iii) Relevant material pertinent to the claim was omitted; (iv) Factual inaccuracies were included in an agenda paper; and (v) The claim relates to a default of a law practice. The Society’s reasons for decision are contained within an Information Notice attached to the decision. The Society’s response to the Applicant’s QCAT application is that the application to QCAT should be dismissed as the Society’s decision was the correct and preferable decision because: a)The Applicant did not suffer a pecuniary loss as a result of the default of Juliette Wright and/or Phoenix Lawyers and as such the application did not meet the requirements of section 374 of the Act; b)Further, there was no default as defined in section 356 of the Act in respect of the monies the Applicant paid to the Solicitors to complete a contract for the purchase of a business, because those monies were not trust money or trust property; c)Further, any loss the Applicant may have suffered has been resolved by a settlement the Applicant reached with Barbus; d)The Society’s decision was consistent with the current law; e)The decision-maker considered all relevant material, and the decision was not based on irrelevant matters or factual inaccuracies. The Response provides further details as to why the Society submits their decision was the correct and preferable decision.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.