Carlyle v Queensland Law Society

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND

ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

CITATION:

Carlyle v Queensland Law Society [2023] QCAT 161
PARTIES:
ALEXANDRA CARLYLE

(applicant)

v

QUEENSLAND LAW SOCIETY

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

GAR606-21

MATTER TYPE:

General administrative review matters

DELIVERED ON:

18 January 2023

HEARING DATE:

2 December 2022

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Hon. Duncan McMeekin KC, Judicial Member

ORDERS:

1.     The application is dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS – QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL – where a solicitor acting as agent for a company selling a business misappropriated monies paid by the purchaser – whether the purchaser can claim against the fidelity fund – whether the purchaser suffered pecuniary loss – whether default was shown to have caused loss

Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld), s 359, s 375, s 392

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 20

Black v S Freedman & Co (1910) 12 CLR 105

Legal Services Board v Gillespie-Jones (2013) 249 CLR 493; [2013] HCA 35

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

P J Woods and E J Jensen ib Linda Phelps & Company

Respondent: P Somers ib Queensland Law Society

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. This review concerns the right of the applicant to make a claim on the Legal Practitioners Fidelity Fund Guarantee Fund established under s 359 of the Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld) (“LPA”).

    The Background

  2. A solicitor, Juliette Wright, principal of Phoenix Lawyers Pty Ltd, misappropriated certain monies that were paid to her by the applicant. The applicant intended that the monies be paid by Ms Wright to Ms Wright’s client, Brabus PA Franchising Pty Ltd (“Brabus”). The monies were owed, or at least believed by the applicant to be owed, pursuant to a series of contracts entered into by the applicant with Brabus for the acquisition of a franchise business and its stock in trade. The purchase price was arrived at by striking an agreement on the value of the business and then setting a notional sum for the value of stock in trade which was adjusted after a stock take. The business and stock were duly transferred to the applicant or related entities upon payment to Ms Wright of the agreed amounts. The contracts were settled on 1 August 2016. Ms Wright paid part of the monies received to Brabus but misappropriated the balance – a sum of $115,450.00.

  3. It is uncontroversial that Ms Wright was at all times acting as agent for Brabus. She was in fact employed by Brabus. She had applied for a practising certificate to run her own practise, Phoenix Lawyers, and her certificate issued on 1 July 2016. She received the monies in question here a few weeks later.

  4. The peculiar twist in the facts here is that neither Brabus nor the applicant were aware of any misappropriation for some years.

  5. In 2019 the applicant sold the business back to Brabus. In 2020 the misappropriation came to light. Thus, for some years the applicant, and for that matter Brabus, were unaware that monies had been taken…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carlyle v Queensland Law Society and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QCAT 161
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Carlyle v Queensland Law Society, the applicant sought a review of a decision made by the Queensland Law Society to disallow a claim for $115,450 under the Legal Practitioners Fidelity Fund Guarantee Fund. The applicant, who had transferred monies to solicitor Juliette Wright for the settlement of a franchise sale, alleged that Wright had misappropriated a portion of the funds. Wright was employed by the franchisee and had acted as their agent in the transaction. The applicant was unaware of the misappropriation until several years later, when Wright listed the business for sale at an inflated price and pocketed the difference. Wright was subsequently charged with dishonesty and sentenced to imprisonment. The applicant made a claim for the misappropriated funds under the fidelity fund, but the Society disallowed the claim. The applicant sought a review of this decision under section 392 of the Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld).

The court was required to determine whether the applicant was eligible for compensation under the fidelity fund. Specifically, the court needed to consider whether the applicant had suffered a pecuniary loss due to a default to which Part 3.6 of the Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld) applied. The court also needed to consider whether the funds paid to Wright were considered "investment money" within the meaning of section 373(2) of the Act, and whether the applicant could recover the funds from some other source. The court considered submissions from both parties on these issues.

The court found that the applicant could not show that they had suffered a pecuniary loss due to a default to which Part 3.6 of the Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld) applied. The court held that the applicant had not demonstrated that they had suffered a loss as a result of Wright's actions, as they had not suffered any financial loss until they sold the business back to the franchisee. The court also rejected the argument that the funds paid to Wright were considered "investment money" within the meaning of section 373(2) of the Act. The court found that the applicant's claim was accordingly dismissed.

The court dismissed the applicant's claim for compensation under the fidelity fund. The court held that the applicant had not demonstrated that they had suffered a pecuniary loss due to a default to which Part 3.6 of the Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld) applied. The court found that the applicant had not suffered any financial loss until they sold the business back to the franchisee, and therefore could not claim compensation under the fidelity fund. The court also rejected the argument that the funds paid to Wright were considered "investment money" within the meaning of section 373(2) of the Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

This review concerns the right of the applicant to make a claim on the Legal Practitioners Fidelity Fund Guarantee Fund established under s 359 of the Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld) (“LPA”).The Background A solicitor, Juliette Wright, principal of Phoenix Lawyers Pty Ltd, misappropriated certain monies that were paid to her by the applicant. The applicant intended that the monies be paid by Ms Wright to Ms Wright’s client, Brabus PA Franchising Pty Ltd (“Brabus”). The monies were owed, or at least believed by the applicant to be owed, pursuant to a series of contracts entered into by the applicant with Brabus for the acquisition of a franchise business and its stock in trade. The purchase price was arrived at by striking an agreement on the value of the business and then setting a notional sum for the value of stock in trade which was adjusted after a stock take. The business and stock were duly transferred to the applicant or related entities upon payment to Ms Wright of the agreed amounts. The contracts were settled on 1 August 2016. Ms Wright paid part of the monies received to Brabus but misappropriated the balance – a sum of $115,450.00. It is uncontroversial that Ms Wright was at all times acting as agent for Brabus. She was in fact employed by Brabus. She had applied for a practising certificate to run her own practise, Phoenix Lawyers, and her certificate issued on 1 July 2016. She received the monies in question here a few weeks later. The peculiar twist in the facts here is that neither Brabus nor the applicant were aware of any misappropriation for some years. In 2019 the applicant sold the business back to Brabus. In 2020 the misappropriation came to light. Thus, for some years the applicant, and for that matter Brabus, were unaware that monies had been taken by Ms Wright. Unbeknown to the applicant, Ms Wright listed the business for sale at a sum more than the amount that Brabus had instructed and expected to receive. While it is not clear how this came about, Brabus was unaware that the business was marketed by Ms Wright at the greater sum and then sold for that greater sum. After receiving the sale proceeds from the applicant Ms Wright pocketed the difference between the price her client expected and the price the applicant paid –the sum of $115,450,00. After this misappropriation, along with others, came to light, the solicitor was charged with numerous offences of dishonesty but for present purposes the relevant charge she faced was as follows:“That on diverse dates between the 30th day of May 2016 and the 30th day of July 2016 ... [the solicitor] dishonestly induced [the applicant] to deliver $396,504.09 banking credits to [the solicitor] ...” Ms Wright pleaded guilty to the charges and was eventually sentenced to imprisonment in relation to these charges. The applicants made a claim for the sum of $115,450.00 on the fidelity fund. The relevant statutory committee of the Queensland Law Society disallowed the applicant’s claim. The applicant seeks a review of that decision under s 392 LPA.Principles governing review

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I did not understand the Society to maintain its submissions re s 392(2) LPA (i.e. that the amount sought to be recovered was reasonably available from some other source) nor did I understand the Society to persist with its submissions that the monies paid to Ms Wright were “investment money” within the meaning of s 373(2) LPA and so beyond the purview of Part 3.6.Conclusion In my opinion the applicant cannot show that she satisfies the requirement of s 374(1) – she is not a person who has suffered pecuniary loss because of a default to which part 3.6 of the LPA applies. The application is dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.