Carlos Lopez-Avila and K & S Freighters Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

[2015] AATA 197 

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2013/4670

Re

Carlos Lopez-Avila

APPLICANT

And

K & S Freighters Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

John Handley, Senior Member

Date 31 March 2015
Place Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

....[sgd]....................................................................

John Handley, Senior Member

WORKERS’ COMPENSATION – applicant suffered left-wrist injury in March 2008 – pre-existing asymptomatic osteoarthritis aggravated – short period of incapacity and return to work on full duties in November 2008 – applicant met with manager in August 2012 concerning work performance  which was found to be unsatisfactory – proposal that performance improvement plan be devised – applicant left workplace with belief his employment had been terminated – has not returned to work – incapacity by depression and anxiety subsequently certified by doctors – not work-related – no incapacity from August 2012 by wrist injury – decision affirmed

Legislation

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 sections 5A and 14

REASONS FOR DECISION

John Handley, Senior Member

31 March 2015

  1. The applicant lodged two applications with the Tribunal seeking a review of decisions made by the respondent.

  2. The first application, 2013/1443, was a review of a decision to deny compensation (T37, pages 129-136) for a psychiatric injury which was alleged to be the consequence of abuse and discrimination in the workplace. The applicant gave evidence about a number of adverse comments made about him by supervisors, largely related to his poor command of the English language (the applicant was born in El Salvador), however the focus during the hearing was on an event (giving rise to the psychiatric disease) that took place in the workplace on 24 August 2012.

  3. On that day the applicant, who was employed as a truck mechanic, was called into a meeting with Mr Paul Whiteway, the operations manager of the respondent’s premises at Laverton. The meeting was called because a complaint had been made about the quality of the applicant’s workmanship and the time taken by him to complete some mechanical work. On the day prior to the meeting, a road test of a truck over which the applicant had completed mechanical work found it to have defective steering. An inspection of the truck revealed that a piece of timber, which had been used to support a gearbox whilst it was being replaced had not been removed and it was jammed adjacent to the steering axle.

  4. During the meeting with Mr Whiteway, the applicant was given a letter (T35, page 125) which recorded that his work performance had been found to be unsatisfactory, it was expected to improve immediately, but if it did not, disciplinary action, including termination of employment may occur.

  5. The applicant’s union representative, who was present with him during the meeting advised him to sign the letter which had been requested by Mr Whiteway.

  6. Toward the end of the meeting (at about 3 pm on a Friday afternoon) the applicant became upset. Mr Whiteway, who observed he was upset, suggested that he should go home and speak with…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carlos Lopez-Avila and K & S Freighters Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] AATA 197
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Carlos Lopez-Avila and K & S Freighters Pty Ltd involved a dispute regarding an injury sustained by the applicant while working as a truck mechanic. The applicant claimed that an incident on 19 March 2008, where he was struck in the left wrist by a bolt or socket, aggravated a pre-existing arthritic condition, leading to ongoing symptoms and limitations in his ability to perform his duties. The respondent, K & S Freighters Pty Ltd, disputed the applicant's claims and questioned the extent of his incapacity and the impact of the alleged aggravation of his condition. The matter was heard and determined by the relevant tribunal.

The primary legal issues that the tribunal had to address were whether the applicant's injury on 19 March 2008 had aggravated his pre-existing degenerative condition, and if so, to what extent this aggravation impacted his capacity to work. Additionally, the tribunal had to consider the evidence regarding the applicant's work history, his modifications to his work practices post-injury, and the nature and extent of any ongoing symptoms and limitations. The tribunal also needed to determine whether the applicant's employment was terminated due to performance issues or if it was a result of the events following the complaint on 24 August 2012.

The tribunal found that the applicant had indeed suffered an injury on 19 March 2008, which aggravated his pre-existing arthritic condition. The evidence from the medical experts supported the conclusion that the repetitive nature of the applicant's work likely aggravated or accelerated the degeneration of his left wrist. The tribunal accepted the unanimous opinion of the medical experts that the applicant was fit for work that did not expose him to heavy lifting or repetitive use of his left wrist and hand. The tribunal also found that the applicant's employment was not terminated due to performance issues but rather due to a misunderstanding following a complaint on 24 August 2012.

The tribunal ordered that the respondent, K & S Freighters Pty Ltd, provide appropriate compensation and support to the applicant, taking into account his ongoing symptoms and limitations, and the impact of the aggravation of his pre-existing condition. The tribunal also noted the importance of clear communication and understanding between the employer and the employee to prevent misunderstandings that could lead to distress and termination of employment.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

All of the above doctors were satisfied the applicant had degenerative changes present at 19 March 2008, that he was then asymptomatic, however the accident aggravated the pre-existing disease process. Mr Goldwasser reported that the work undertaken by the applicant, being repetitive in nature could have aggravated or accelerated the degeneration. Mr Doig and Dr Fraser reported the degenerative process was arthritic in nature. Dr Fraser noted widespread arthritic changes affecting both hands and the fingers and his right foot. As a consequence of the aggravation, the applicant demonstrated symptoms of pain, restriction of movement and loss of strength. All of the doctors were guarded in their opinions about the capacity of the applicant to return to his previous employment and were unanimous that he would be fit only for work which did not expose him to heavy lifting or repetitive use of his left wrist and hand. Conclusion and reasons for decision The circumstances which were endured by the applicant, as learnt by this review, were very unfortunate. Prior to 19 March 2008, the applicant had enjoyed a relatively long period of employment with the respondent as a truck mechanic. There had been some prior breaches of safety protocols, for which he had received warnings, but it appears that he enjoyed a good relationship with Mr Whiteway. It is not in dispute and I find as a fact that on 19 March 2008 the applicant suffered injury to his left wrist when he was struck either by a bolt or socket which was propelled at speed and by force. The applicant worked for about two weeks subsequently in pain, he then sought treatment, and for the next few months he progressed through a process initially of total incapacity and eventually a graduated return to work. By 24 November 2008 he was working full-time without restrictions. It was not apparent from the documents lodged before the hearing that although the applicant continued to perform his pre-injury duties, he modified his work when heavy lifting by using his right hand and his left forearm. Nonetheless, it appears that he was not prohibited from undertaking any work but there were occasions when some jobs were undertaken with the assistance of another person. The applicant worked until 24 August 2012. There were occasions when he worked in the presence of pain and there were occasions when his wrist was bandaged but he was not incapacitated. Although he took Panadol Osteo on occasions for relief of pain, he had not seen any doctors for treatment of his wrist between 10 June 2008 (Mr Goldwasser) and 18 September 2012 when he attended the Sunshine clinic. On 24 August 2012 the applicant was called into a meeting as a result of a complaint made against him arising out of work that he had undertaken on the previous day over one of the respondent’s trucks. The applicant was asked to sign a document which recorded that it was a final warning and his future performance would be monitored. Whether because the applicant did not understand the contents of the document or because Mr Whiteway suggested that he go home (when he became distressed) or a combination of both, the applicant believed that his employment had been terminated.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established