Carlisle Homes Pty Ltd v Tick Homes Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Carlisle Homes Pty Ltd v Tick Homes Pty Ltd [2018] FCA 973

File number: VID 717 of 2018
Judge: MURPHY J
Date of judgment: 26 June 2018
Catchwords: COPYRIGHT – application for an interlocutory injunction restraining reproduction and sale of house plans and building houses in accordance with the plans – allegation of copying house plans in infringement of copyright in the plans – prima facie case established – damages an adequate remedy – balance of convenience against grant of interlocutory injunction – application dismissed
Legislation: Copyright Act 1968 (Cth)
Cases cited:

Apotex Pty Ltd v Cipla Ltd [2017] FCA 1627

Australian Broadcasting Corporation v O’Neill (2006) 227 CLR 57

Beecham Group Ltd v Bristol Laboratories Pty Ltd (1968) 118 CLR 618

Clarendon Homes (Aust) Pty Ltd v Henley Arch Pty Ltd (1999) 46 IPR 309

Eagle Homes Pty Ltd v Austec Homes Pty Ltd (1999) 87 FCR 415

Henley Arch Pty Ltd v Lucky Homes Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 1217

InterPharma Pty v Hospira, Inc (No 3) [2017] FCA 1536

SW Hart & Co Pty Ltd v Edwards Hot Water Systems (1985) 159 CLR 466

Tamawood Ltd v Henley Arch Pty Ltd (2004) 61 IPR 378; [2004] FCAFC 78

Date of hearing: 21 June 2018
Registry: Victoria
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Copyright and Industrial Designs
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 53
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr T D Cordiner QC and Mr A Christophersen
Solicitor for the Applicant: K&L Gates
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr P H Wallis
Solicitor for the Respondents: Aitken Partners

ORDERS

VID 717 of 2018
BETWEEN:

CARLISLE HOMES PTY LTD (ACN 106 263 209)

Applicant

AND:

TICK HOMES PTY LTD (ACN 620 818 180)

First Respondent

RESIMAX GROUP PTY LTD (ACN 164 428 942)

Second Respondent

ARCHTEK PTY LTD (ACN 610 883 997) (and another named in the Schedule)

Third Respondent

JUDGE:

MURPHY J

DATE OF ORDER:

26 JUNE 2018

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application for injunctive relief be dismissed.

2.The proceeding be granted a hearing date as soon as practicable.

3.The Applicant pay the Respondents’ costs of the application.

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

MURPHY J:

  1. In this proceeding the applicant, Carlisle Homes Pty Ltd, alleges that the respondents, Tick Homes Pty Ltd, Resimax Group Pty Ltd, Archtek Pty Ltd and Aziz Kheir have infringed Carlisle Homes’ copyright under the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) (Copyright Act) in relation to nine of its residential home plans, doing so by reproducing and offering for sale reproductions of those plans and/or by homes built in accordance with the reproductions (or substantial parts of them).  Pending the hearing and determination of the substantive proceeding Carlisle Homes seeks an interlocutory injunction to restrain the respondents from reproducing or substantially reproducing any of reproductions of the plans and from offering for sale, selling or constructing any houses in accordance or substantially in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carlisle Homes Pty Ltd v Tick Homes Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 973
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Carlisle Homes Pty Ltd v Tick Homes Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, Carlisle Homes, a substantial home building company, sought an interlocutory injunction against the defendants, Tick Homes, Resimax, and Archtek, to prevent them from reproducing and selling house plans that Carlisle Homes alleged were copied in infringement of their copyright. The Federal Court was tasked with determining whether a prima facie case of copyright infringement had been established and whether the balance of convenience favoured the grant of an interlocutory injunction.

The court found that Carlisle Homes had established a prima facie case of copyright infringement as there was a high degree of objective similarity between the Tick Homes plans and the Carlisle Homes plans, and the former employee of Carlisle Homes had access to the plans in question. However, the court determined that damages would be an adequate remedy for Carlisle Homes, and the balance of convenience did not favour the grant of an interlocutory injunction. The court considered the potential harm to Tick Homes if an injunction were granted, including the impact on their business operations and the availability of alternative remedies.

The court dismissed the application for injunctive relief and ordered a speedy hearing of the substantive proceeding. The court also ordered that Carlisle Homes pay the respondents' costs of the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for injunctive relief be dismissed.

2. The proceeding be granted a hearing date as soon as practicable.

3. The Applicant pay the Respondents’ costs of the application.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons I explain, I have refused the injunctive relief sought and ordered a speedy hearing of the substantive proceeding. THE SALIENT FACTS The evidence in the application is by affidavit and there was no cross-examination. Carlisle Homes relies on affidavits by its Managing Director, John Doulgeridis, its Senior Designer, Shane Rogers, and its solicitor, Savannah Hardingham. The respondents rely on an affidavit by the fourth respondent, Mr Kheir who is a director of each of Tick Homes, Resimax and Archtek. Much of their evidence is uncontentious. The parties Carlisle Homes is a substantial home building company which commenced operation in 2004 and which it is appropriate to describe as a high volume builder. It has constructed over 8,000 homes since 2004 and since 2014 it has constructed over 1,000 homes per year. Mr Kheir states that he founded the Resimax Group in 2008. Resimax is primarily involved in developments of detached volume housing and also in apartment developments. It currently controls more than 5,000 residential lots and homes to be developed, and it is also a high volume developer and builder. Together with Dean Mallia, an experienced draftsperson in the high volume housing industry, Mr Kheir set up Archtek in 2016, primarily to provide drafting services to Resimax. In 2017 he set up Tick Homes to provide affordable homes for first home buyers by offering relatively inexpensive house and land packages to be built on land developments in which Resimax is involved. The creation of the Carlisle Homes Plans Mr Rogers is an experienced house designer and draftsperson and since October 2011 he has been employed by Carlisle Homes, to create house plans for that company. Mr Doulgeridis works closely with Mr Rogers when he is designing plans and Carlisle Homes markets and promotes the plans and the houses built by reference to the plans as original designs. Carlisle Homes’ original house plans include the following nine house designs created by Mr Rogers in the course of his employment: (a)the Bayview 19, completed in about September 2014; (b)the Edgewood 23, completed in about September 2014; (c)the Glenbrook 25, completed in about June 2016; (d)the Portland 25, completed in about July 2015; (e)the Rutherford 32, completed in about June 2016; (f)the Peninsula 33, completed in about July 2016; (g)the Lennox 23, completed in about November 2012; (h)the Brooklyn 16, completed in about June 2015; and (i)the Newbury 23, completed in about June 2015; (collectively the Carlisle Homes Plans). The creation of the Tick Homes Plans In early 2017 Mr Kheir began assembling the management team to lead the development of Tick Homes within Resimax. Amongst others, in May 2017 he engaged Darren Mehl to be Resimax’s Chief Operating Officer and to have responsibility for Tick Homes, and in July 2017 he engaged James Farrar as Tick Homes’ Building Manager. Mr Mehl had worked for Carlisle Homes until he was made redundant in April 2017. Mr Kheir states that shortly after employing Mr Mehl he instructed him to prepare a design brief to Mr Mallia for the construction of a suite of home plans to suit Resimax’s upcoming developments. The design brief was for homes to be built on relatively small blocks of land for buyers with budgetary constraints, which required precision in determining room sizes and home size. He says that Mr Mehl prepared the design brief in July 2017. The design brief is in evidence and in my view it is at a high level.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The issues of resemblance to, and actual use of, the copyright work are discrete because, in the absence of a causal connection, objective similarity does not give rise to a finding of reproduction. They overlap, however, because the necessary causal connection between the alleged infringing work and the copyright work is often established by arguing that an inference of use of the copyright work should be drawn on the basis of a high degree of similarity between the two works, coupled with opportunity to use the copyright work (access) and with failure by the alleged infringer to adequately explain that party’s assertion of independent origination (authorship) of the work said to infringe. The elements of sufficient objective similarity and causal link are aspects of “reproduction” and it can be artificial to consider them separately, and where access to and use of a copyright work is found to have occurred a finding of copying can add significance to “objective similarity”: Eagle Homes Pty Ltd v Austec Homes Pty Ltd (1999) 87 FCR 415 at [84]-[85], [98] per Lindgren J (with whom Finkelstein J agreed at [111]); Clarendon Homes (Aust) Pty Ltd v Henley Arch Pty Ltd (1999) 46 IPR 309 at [27] per Heerey, Sundberg and Finkelstein JJ. CONSIDERATIONIs there a prima facie case of breach of copyright? Carlisle Homes contends that the Tick Homes Plans were created by Mr Mallia referring to and copying the Carlisle Homes Plans without Carlisle Homes’ authority. It argues that the evidence of copying is overwhelming, including that: (a)each of the Tick Homes Plans appears to be a close copy of the corresponding Carlisle Homes Plan; (b)each of the Tick Homes Plans appears to reproduce unique and distinctive features of the corresponding Carlisle Homes Plans; (c)the design documents produced by the respondents in response to Carlisle Homes’ request do not demonstrate the evolution of the designs and do not show that they were created without copying; (d)Mr Mehl was previously employed by Carlisle Homes as General Manager of Carlisle Homes’ “Easy Living” business from April 2015 until April 2017, and he had access to the Carlisle Homes Plans; and (e)Tick Homes has closely emulated multiple aspects of Carlisle Homes’ marketing materials in ways that demonstrate an awareness of and reference to them. Mr Cordiner, Senior Counsel for Carlisle Homes, took the Court to numerous similarities between many of the Tick Homes Plans and the corresponding Carlisle Homes Plan. While the level of objective similarity varies between the different plans, I accept that many of the Tick Homes Plans show a high level of objective similarity to the corresponding Carlisle Homes Plan. Mr Wallis, counsel for the respondents, reluctantly accepted that Carlisle Homes made out a prima facie case of breach of copyright, at least in relation to those plans with stronger similarity, but argues that Carlisle Homes’ case is weak. The respondents argue, amongst other things, that: (a)Mr Mehl and Mr Mallia’s evidence denying that they had any reference to the Carlisle Homes Plans in designing the Tick Homes Plans should be accepted; (b)Mr Mallia’s explanation as to the absence of early sketches, early CAD drafts and emails which show the development of the draft plans without reference to the Carlisle Homes Plans should be accepted; (c)there is little substance in the suggestion that Mr Mehl had access to the Carlisle Homes Plans as the former General Manager of Carlisle Homes' “Easy Living” business, and therefore the opportunity to copy them, when those plans were published on the Carlisle Homes’ website for all and sundry to see; (d)the similarities between the Tick Homes Plans and the Carlisle Homes Plans reflect house features which most consumers would wish to see (such as open plan kitchen/dining/living areas, an alfresco dining area, a main bedroom with ensuite bathroom and walk-in robe, subsidiary bedrooms and an additional family bathroom near those bedrooms) coupled with the restrictions on room and overall size associated with smaller than standard blocks of land; (e)Mr Rogers’ evidence that the Carlisle Homes Plans contain numerous features which are, on their own and/or in combination, unique and important distinctive features has no basis in the evidence or is, at least, overstated; and (f)Carlisle Homes Plans is a volume builder and its “Easy Living” housing range is relatively low cost project housing. Carlisle Homes’ marketing material shows that it did not market the Carlisle Homes Plans on the basis that its homes had unique or distinctive features, instead it largely did so on the basis that its homes are good value for money, quality constructions and will be speedily completed. The respondents submit that the notion that the type of project housing which the Carlisle Homes Plans embody is somehow unique or contains unique features does not withstand examination.