Carlin & Anor v Mladenovic & Anor No. Scgrg-98-1537

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

CARLIN & ANOR v MLADENOVIC & ANOR
[2000] SASC 142

Land and Valuation Division

  1. DEBELLE J.     This is an application under the Encroachments Act, 1944.

  2. The plaintiffs reside at 8A Grayson Street, Kilkenny.  Their neighbours at 8 Grayson Street are the defendants.  There is a Besser block wall between the two properties.  The wall is not erected on the true boundary but 1.65 metres inside the true boundary and on the plaintiffs’ land.  The wall is in excess of 2.5 metres high.

  1. A house property is erected on each of the two allotments.  On the northern side of the defendant’s house a lean-to addition has been constructed.  It houses bathroom, toilet and laundry facilities.  It protrudes 0.9 metres into the plaintiffs’ allotment.  The position is depicted on the plan below.

It will be noticed that the encroachment is over the front one-third of the defendants’ land.  The plaintiffs have issued proceedings under the Encroachments Act seeking removal of the encroaching building.

  1. The Besser block wall had been constructed in 1977 by the plaintiffs to screen the adjoining property and to provide support for extensive roofing over a carport area and a workshop area towards the rear of their allotment.  The wall was constructed some nine years before the defendants purchased their land.

  2. The plaintiffs have known of this encroachment for some 37 years at the date of the hearing.  Yet they did not take any steps to remedy the situation until 1994.  In addition, they had owned the defendants’ allotment for three years between 1969 and 1972 and did not then remedy the situation.  That is apparent from the history of the dealings in the two allotments.

  3. On 28 September 1961 the plaintiffs purchased their house and property at 8A Grayson Street.  They have resided in the house ever since.

  4. The house and land at 8 Grayson Street, now owned by the defendants, was in 1961 owned by a Mrs Rice.  She lived in the house with her husband.

  5. A wooden paling fence was erected between the two properties.  When the plaintiffs purchased their land, they believed that the fence marked the true boundary.  About four to five months after the plaintiffs had purchased their land, they became aware that the fence did not mark the true boundary and that part of the Rices’ house encroached upon their land.  The Rices’ house was then configured in the same way as the house now owned by the defendants.  The encroachment was a lean-to addition.

  6. The plaintiffs decided not to take any step to remedy the encroachment because the Rices were an elderly couple and Mr Rice was ill.

  7. The plaintiffs spoke to the Rices about purchasing their property.  They secured some kind of informal right of first refusal.  The terms of the agreement are of no consequence because the plaintiffs purchased the property in about August 1969.  For some reason which was not explained, the transfer of the land was not registered until 8 March 1972.

  8. The plaintiffs intended to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carlin & Anor v Mladenovic & Anor No. Scgrg-98-1537 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] SASC 142
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Carlin & Anor v Mladenovic & Anor involves a dispute over land boundaries and encroachments. The plaintiffs, Carlin and another, reside at 8A Grayson Street, Kilkenny, while the defendants, Mladenovic and another, reside at 8 Grayson Street. The primary issue is the existence of a Besser block wall, which is located 1.65 metres inside the true boundary on the plaintiffs' land, and a lean-to addition to the defendants' house that encroaches by 0.9 metres onto the plaintiffs' property. The plaintiffs have brought an action under the Encroachments Act, 1944, seeking the removal of the encroaching building. The court had to determine whether the encroachment should be removed, and if so, what form the remedy should take.

The court found that the encroachment had been in place for over 33 years, during which the plaintiffs had taken no action to address it. The Besser block wall had been constructed by the plaintiffs in 1977, nine years before the defendants purchased the property. The plaintiffs had owned the land now occupied by the defendants for three years prior to this and did not remove the encroachment then either. The court considered the significant cost and disruption that would result from removing the lean-to addition and the fact that the encroachment had not affected the plaintiffs' use and enjoyment of their land. Additionally, the defendants were unaware of the encroachment when they purchased the property, and it would be inequitable to require them to pay compensation given the plaintiffs' long-standing acquiescence.

The court concluded that while the status quo should not be maintained indefinitely, it would be appropriate to redefine the boundaries to allow for a reasonable accommodation of both parties' interests. The court ordered that the boundaries be adjusted to follow the southern side of the Besser block wall to a point midway along the common boundary, with the remainder of the boundary being the true boundary. The court also exercised its discretion under the Encroachments Act not to require the defendants to pay compensation to the plaintiffs. The court will hear further submissions on the terms of the orders necessary to implement these decisions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

DEBELLE J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: DEBELLE J