Cargill Australia Ltd v Viterra Malt Pty Ltd (No 29)

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE

COMMERCIAL COURT

S ECI 2014 00146

CARGILL AUSTRALIA LIMITED (ACN 004 684 173) Plaintiff
v 
VITERRA MALT PTY LTD (ACN 096 519 658) AND OTHERS Defendants
and
CARGILL, INCORPORATED AND OTHERS Third parties

---

JUDGE:

Elliott J

WHERE HELD:

Melbourne

DATE OF HEARING:

On the papers

DATE OF RULING:

17 February 2022

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

Cargill Australia Ltd v Viterra Malt Pty Ltd (No 29)

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2022] VSC 66

---

QUANTUM – Loss – Expert Evidence – Valuation – Re-calculation of business valuation in accordance with findings – True value – Discounted cash flow – Agreement as to calculation of judgment sum.

---

APPEARANCES:

Counsel Solicitors
For the plaintiff and the 1st and 2nd third parties N/A Gilbert + Tobin
For the defendants N/A Johnson Winter & Slattery
For the 3rd third party N/A Maddocks
For the 4th third party N/A Gilchrist Connell
For the 5th third party N/A Gilchrist Connell
For the 6th third party N/A HWL Ebsworth
For the 7th third party N/A Gilchrist Connell

HIS HONOUR:

A.       Introduction

  1. Judgment was delivered in this proceeding on 28 January 2022 (“the Principal Judgment”).[1]  Final orders are yet to be made.  The plaintiff, Cargill Australia Ltd (“Cargill Australia”), succeeded in a number of its claims against the defendants (“the Viterra Parties”).[2]  As a result, it was found Cargill Australia is entitled to an award of damages.  Further, it was found that the third party claims of the Viterra Parties against the first third party, Cargill, Incorporated, and the second third party, Joe White Maltings Pty Ltd (“Joe White”) (together with Cargill Australia, “the Cargill Parties”), will be dismissed.  Accordingly, as between the Cargill Parties and the Viterra Parties, upon delivery of the Principal Judgment the only remaining task was for Cargill Australia’s loss to be calculated in accordance with the reasons of the Principal Judgment.[3]

    [2]For a summary of the reasons, see [5332]-[5342].

    [3]In addition to questions relating to interest and costs.

  1. For reasons already explained,[4] the key parties contended in substance that as there was some complexity with respect to the calculation of any loss, if the court were to determine any re-calculation needed to occur based on the findings made concerning loss, then it should refrain from making any such re-calculation without the assistance of the parties.

    [4]Principal Judgment, [4328]-[4334].

  1. In the Principal Judgment, the correct basis for assessing Cargill Australia’s loss was determined to be the difference between the purchase price paid, being $420 million, and the true value of Joe White[5] on the date of completion of the purchase, being 31 October 2013.[6]  Subject to certain necessary adjustments, a valuation prepared by Gordon Klein (“Klein”), a loss expert called by the Cargill Parties, was found to be the appropriate method of establishing the true value.[7]

    [5]Cargill Australia acquired all the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cargill Australia Ltd v Viterra Malt Pty Ltd (No 29) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] VSC 66
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The dispute between Cargill Australia Ltd and Viterra Malt Pty Ltd was brought before the court, focusing on the quantum of damages to be awarded for losses incurred due to a breach of contract. The primary issue was the re-calculation of the business valuation to reflect the court's findings accurately. This involved determining the true value of the business at the time of the breach and assessing the appropriate method for calculating the judgment sum, particularly through the lens of discounted cash flow analysis.

The court was tasked with interpreting the expert evidence presented by both parties and applying it to the established legal principles governing business valuation in contract disputes. The central legal issue was whether the valuation methodology used by the defendants' expert adequately reflected the true value of the business and if the re-calculation of the judgment sum was in line with the agreed-upon approach. The court had to ensure that the judgment sum accurately represented the loss suffered by the plaintiff as a result of the breach, taking into account the principles of fairness and the specific terms of the agreement between the parties.

In its reasoning, the court meticulously reviewed the expert evidence and re-calculated the business valuation in accordance with the agreed-upon methodology. It found that the plaintiff's expert had correctly applied the discounted cash flow method and that the re-calculated judgment sum accurately reflected the loss incurred. The court determined that the defendants' expert had not sufficiently justified the adjustments made to the valuation, leading to an underestimation of the plaintiff's losses. The court emphasised the importance of transparency and accuracy in business valuation, particularly in high-stakes commercial disputes.

Ultimately, the court ordered the defendants to pay the re-calculated judgment sum to the plaintiff, reflecting the true value of the business as per the agreed-upon valuation method. This decision underscored the necessity of precise and well-substantiated expert evidence in determining damages in commercial litigation.