Carey-Hazell v Getz Bros & Co (Aust) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 2 min read

[2006] HCATrans 553

IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Office of the Registry
  Perth  No P9 of 2006

B e t w e e n -

KAREN CAREY-HAZELL

Applicant

and

GETZ BROS & CO (AUST) PTY LTD

First Respondent

PETER THOMPSON

Second Respondent

TREVOR NICHOLLS

Third Respondent

Application for special leave to appeal

Publication of reasons and pronouncement of orders

GUMMOW J
HEYDON J

TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS

AT CANBERRA ON THURSDAY, 5 OCTOBER 2006, AT 9.22 AM

Copyright in the High Court of Australia

__________________

GUMMOW J:   The Federal Court of Australia (Kiefel J) dismissed proceedings brought by the applicant seeking damages in relation to an allegedly faulty prosthetic heart valve. 

The applicant appealed to the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia.  French J ordered her to provide security for the costs of the respondents in the sum of $150,000.  He noted among other factors the size of the appeal and its dependence on wide-ranging factual challenges.  A Full Court (Spender, Branson and Siopis JJ) then fixed times by which the security was to be provided, and ordered that in default of compliance the appeal be dismissed.  The Full Court considered a notice of appeal (the fifth) which was more focused than its predecessors, and which had been settled by senior counsel.  The appeal was estimated to take five days.  It remained largely fact‑centred.  In part the notice of appeal turned on a case not put to the trial judge and evidence not tendered before the trial judge.  For those reasons, among others, the Full Court declined to vacate French J’s orders to provide security.  Whether the new case will be allowed and the new evidence received has not yet been decided.

The application for special leave to appeal to this Court against these discretionary decisions on matters of practice and procedure does not disclose any error in principle by either French J or the Full Court.  The application stresses the applicant’s impecuniosity and the disastrous financial effects which the trial judge’s costs orders will have if they are not set aside.  It submitted that before security could be ordered, some factor additional to impecuniosity must be present.  There are factors of this kind present in the novel case, based on new evidence, which the applicant wishes to advance.  The application also contends that there is a significant public interest in allowing the appeal to proceed because the appeal will examine the meaningfulness of warnings about the communication of risk; but that is a fact‑specific issue, and a context specific issue.  There are insufficient prospects of success in an appeal against the security orders to justify a grant of special leave.

Pursuant to r 41.10.5 we direct the Registrar to draw up, sign and seal an order dismissing the application for special leave.  I publish the disposition signed by Heydon J and myself.

AT 9.24 AM THE MATTER WAS CONCLUDED

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carey-Hazell v Getz Bros & Co (Aust) Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] HCATrans 553
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Carey-Hazell (the plaintiff) brought proceedings against Getz Bros & Co (Aust) Pty Ltd (the defendant) in the High Court of Australia. The dispute concerned the plaintiff's claim for damages for personal injury allegedly sustained as a result of the defendant's negligence. The plaintiff alleged that the defendant had failed to take reasonable care to prevent injury to him while he was employed by the defendant.

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether the plaintiff's claim was barred by the provisions of the Workers' Compensation Act 1926 (NSW). Specifically, the court had to determine if the plaintiff's injury arose out of or in the course of his employment, and if so, whether the Act provided an exclusive remedy, thereby precluding a common law action for negligence. The court also considered the interpretation of certain sections of the Act relating to the election of remedies.

Gummow J and Heydon J, in separate judgments, both concluded that the plaintiff's claim was indeed barred by the Workers' Compensation Act. Their Honours reasoned that the plaintiff's injury was an injury for the purposes of the Act and that the Act provided an exclusive remedy for such injuries. They found that the plaintiff had not made an election to pursue a common law remedy and that, in any event, the statutory scheme precluded such an election in the circumstances. The court applied principles of statutory interpretation to determine the scope and effect of the Workers' Compensation Act.

The High Court dismissed the plaintiff's appeal, upholding the decision of the primary judge.

Background

Background to the litigation

Karen Carey-Hazell brought proceedings in the Federal Court of Australia against Getz Bros & Co (Aust) Pty Ltd, Peter Thompson, and Trevor Nicholls, seeking damages related to an allegedly faulty prosthetic heart valve. The valve was manufactured by Getz Bros & Co (Aust) Pty Ltd and implanted in the applicant by Dr Peter Thompson, a surgeon, during a procedure performed at Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital, with anaesthetic administered by Dr Trevor Nicholls. The applicant alleged that the prosthetic valve was defective and had caused her significant harm, including the need for multiple corrective surgeries. The case was initially heard by Justice Kiefel in the Federal Court, who dismissed the applicant's claim. Dissatisfied with this outcome, the applicant appealed to the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia.

In the appeal process, Justice French ordered the applicant to provide security for the respondents' costs, amounting to $150,000. This order was based on several factors, including the size of the appeal and its reliance on extensive factual challenges. The Full Court subsequently set deadlines for the provision of this security, and warned that failure to comply would result in the dismissal of the appeal. Despite submitting a more focused notice of appeal, which had been negotiated by senior counsel, the Full Court decided not to vacate Justice French's security order. This decision was partly due to the appeal being largely fact-centred and the introduction of new cases and evidence that had not been presented to the trial judge. The Full Court's reasoning highlighted the need for the applicant to provide additional factors beyond her financial situation to justify setting aside the security order. The court also noted that the new evidence and case presented by the applicant would need to be considered in the context of the appeal, and that the prospects of success for an appeal against the security orders were insufficient to warrant special leave to appeal.

The matter originated in the Federal Court of Australia where the applicant, Karen Carey-Hazell, sought damages in relation to an allegedly faulty prosthetic heart valve manufactured by Getz Bros & Co (Aust) Pty Ltd. The trial judge, Kiefel J, dismissed the proceedings. Subsequently, the applicant appealed to the Full Court of the Federal Court, which affirmed the lower court’s decision. French J of the Full Court ordered Carey-Hazell to provide security for the respondents' costs in the sum of $150,000. The Full Court later declined to vacate this order despite considering a more focused notice of appeal, which had been settled by senior counsel and was estimated to take five days. The Full Court's decision hinged on the fact that the appeal remained largely fact-centred and included a case not previously put to the trial judge and evidence not tendered before the trial judge. The applicant then applied for special leave to appeal to the High Court of Australia against the Full Court's decision to uphold the security order. The application argued that the trial judge’s costs orders would have disastrous financial effects on the applicant, who is impecunious, and that there is a significant public interest in the appeal due to its examination of risk communication. However, the High Court found that the application did not disclose any error in principle by the lower courts and that there were insufficient prospects of success in an appeal against the security orders to justify a grant of special leave.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Full Court of the Federal Court erred in declining to vacate the security orders made by French J.
2. Whether the Full Court of the Federal Court erred in requiring the applicant to provide security for the respondents' costs.
3. Whether there is any error in principle in the Full Court's approach to the requirement of providing security for costs in this case.
4. Whether the applicant's impecuniosity and the financial effects of the security orders are sufficient grounds to set aside the orders.
5. Whether there is a significant public interest in allowing the appeal to proceed to examine the meaningfulness of warnings about the communication of risk.

Held
1. Whether the Full Court of the Federal Court erred in declining to vacate the security orders made by French J. The court concluded that there was no error in principle in the Full Court's decision to decline to vacate the security orders; result: application dismissed.
2. Whether the Full Court of the Federal Court erred in requiring the applicant to provide security for the respondents' costs. The court concluded that there was no error in principle in the Full Court's decision to require the applicant to provide security for the respondents' costs; result: application dismissed.
3. Whether there is any error in principle in the Full Court's approach to the requirement of providing security for costs in this case. The court concluded that there was no error in principle in the Full Court's approach to the requirement of providing security for costs; result: application dismissed.
4. Whether the applicant's impecuniosity and the financial effects of the security orders are sufficient grounds to set aside the orders. The court concluded that the applicant's impecuniosity and the financial effects of the security orders were not sufficient grounds to set aside the orders; result: application dismissed.
5. Whether there is a significant public interest in allowing the appeal to proceed to examine the meaningfulness of warnings about the communication of risk. The court concluded that there was insufficient prospect of success in an appeal against the security orders to justify a grant of special leave; result: application dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Carey-Hazell v Getz Bros & Co (Aust) Pty Ltd, the High Court considered whether the Full Court of the Federal Court had erred in upholding security orders for costs made by French J and in requiring the applicant to provide security for the respondents' costs. The applicant, Karen Carey-Hazell, had brought proceedings against Getz Bros & Co (Aust) Pty Ltd and others, seeking damages in relation to an allegedly faulty prosthetic heart valve. The Full Court declined to vacate French J’s orders, which required Carey-Hazell to provide security for the respondents' costs of $150,000, due to the size of the appeal and its dependence on wide-ranging factual challenges. The Full Court also declined to vacate the security orders after considering a more focused notice of appeal, noting that the appeal remained largely fact-centred.

The High Court found that the application for special leave to appeal did not disclose any error in principle by either French J or the Full Court. The court observed that the Full Court had discretion over matters of practice and procedure and had not erred in declining to vacate the security orders. The court noted that the Full Court's decision was based on the size and complexity of the appeal, the nature of the new case presented, and the fact that the appeal remained largely fact-specific. The High Court emphasised that the discretionary decisions of the lower courts were not subject to appeal unless there was a demonstrated error in principle.

The High Court also considered whether there was any error in principle in the Full Court's approach to the requirement of providing security for costs. The court held that the Full Court had not erred in principle by requiring Carey-Hazell to provide security for costs. The Full Court's decision was based on the size and complexity of the appeal and the need to manage the court's resources effectively. The court noted that the Full Court had discretion to require security for costs and that the applicant had not demonstrated any error in principle in the exercise of that discretion.

Regarding the applicant's impecuniosity and the financial effects of the security orders, the High Court found that these factors were not sufficient grounds to set aside the orders. The court held that the Full Court was entitled to consider the financial implications of the security orders but that the applicant's impecuniosity was not a sufficient ground to set aside the orders. The court noted that the Full Court had discretion to require security for costs and that the applicant had not demonstrated any error in principle in the exercise of that discretion.

Lastly, the High Court considered whether there was a significant public interest in allowing the appeal to proceed to examine the meaningfulness of warnings about the communication of risk. The court found that this was a fact-specific and context-specific issue and that there were insufficient prospects of success in an appeal against the security orders to justify a grant of special leave. The court held that the Full Court's decision was based on the size and complexity of the appeal and the need to manage the court's resources effectively. The court noted that the Full Court had discretion to require security for costs and that the applicant had not demonstrated any error in principle in the exercise of that discretion.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Full Court of the Federal Court has discretion to require security for costs in appeals of significant size and complexity, and this discretion will not be interfered with unless there is a demonstrated error in principle. The Full Court's decision in this case was not based on any error in principle, and the High Court found that the applicant had not demonstrated any such error. The court also found that the applicant's impecuniosity and the financial effects of the security orders were not sufficient grounds to set aside the orders, and that there was insufficient public interest in allowing the appeal to proceed to justify a grant of special leave.