Cardinia Pty Ltd & Anor v Yu Feng Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT

OF QUEENSLAND  No. 10143 of 1998

Brisbane

[Cardinia Pty Ltd & Anor v Yu Feng Pty Ltd]

BETWEEN:

CARDINIA PTY LTD (ACN 050 405 242)

First Plaintiff

AND:

ARTHUR WILLIAM IAN KENNEDY and
PATRICIA MARGARET KENNEDY

Second Plaintiffs

AND:

YU FENG PTY LTD (ACN 056 974 844)

Defendant

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - HELMAN J.

Judgment delivered 21 May 1999

1  The plaintiffs in action no. 10143 of 1998 apply for orders for disclosure under O. 35 of the Rules of Supreme Court.  The summons, which was filed on 4 March 1999 and came before me on 4 May 1999, seeks relief in two other actions, nos. 10688 and 11486 of 1998.  The former of those other actions, in which the plaintiffs were M A Ryan & Associates Pty Ltd and C.M. and M.A. Ryan, has been settled.  I heard argument on the application in action no. 10143 of 1998 on the understanding that my decision on that application would apply mutatis mutandis to the application in action no. 11486 of 1998.

  1. The first plaintiff in action no. 10143 of 1998 is the tenant of a shop E8, Stafford Sandwich and Carvery, in the food court of the defendant’s shopping centre called Stafford City Shopping Centre at 400 Stafford Road, Stafford, Brisbane. The first plaintiff has occupied the shop since about 11 December 1997 under a lease executed in November 1997. The other plaintiffs in the action, Mr and Mrs Kennedy, are directors and shareholders of the first plaintiff, and guarantors of the performance of its obligations under the lease. The lease provided for an initial rental of $58,000.00 per annum - $4,833.33 per month. The plaintiffs allege in paragraph 25 of their statement of claim, which was delivered on 10 December 1998, that $2,679.17 is a fair monthly rental and claim relief under the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) for misleading and deceptive conduct and other alleged contraventions of that Act, and other relief. The defendant in paragraph 6 of its defence and counter-claim, which was delivered on 24 December 1998, denies the allegation in paragraph 25 of the statement of claim. It is the issue as to the fair monthly rental that has given rise to this application.

  2. In paragraph 1 of the summons the plaintiffs, relying on O. 35 r. 13, seek an order that the defendant produce for inspection reports of rental figures of 183 ‘eat in food tenancies’ referred to in an affidavit filed on behalf of the defendant in connexion with an application for interlocutory relief on 24 November 1998.  The affidavit was sworn by Mr Peter Jeffries, a registered valuer and director of Byvan Management (Qld) Pty Ltd, the company that manages the shopping centre.  On the subject of shops on premises like that occupied by the first plaintiff, which has an area of forty-four square metres, Mr Jeffries swore that he had access to ‘reported rental figures of 183 eat in food tenancies which in area are…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cardinia Pty Ltd & Anor v Yu Feng Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] QSC 102
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Cardinia Pty Ltd and its directors, Arthur William Ian Kennedy and Patricia Margaret Kennedy, sought orders for disclosure against Yu Feng Pty Ltd in relation to a rental dispute concerning a shop in Stafford City Shopping Centre. The plaintiffs sought disclosure of reports on rental figures of similar tenancies, as well as further and better disclosure of documents relating to leases and rental payments of other food outlets in the shopping centre. Yu Feng Pty Ltd resisted the application, arguing that the documents were not directly relevant to the issues in the case and were protected by confidentiality provisions under the Retail Shop Leases Act 1994.

The Court considered whether the sought-after documents fell within the scope of the disclosure rules. The Court found that the reports on rental figures of similar tenancies were directly relevant to the issue of fair monthly rental, despite the defendant's argument that they concerned market rental instead. The Court also found that the documents relating to leases and rental payments of other food outlets were directly relevant to the issue of fair monthly rental. However, the Court accepted that some documents, such as those relating to settled actions or very remote transactions, were not directly relevant.

The Court concluded that there was an objective likelihood that the duty to disclose had not been complied with and ordered the defendant to produce the relevant documents. The Court also ordered that the disclosure be made under conditions to protect the confidentiality of information relating to other tenants, in line with the Retail Shop Leases Act. The Court invited further submissions on the form of the orders and costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Cardinia Pty Ltd, the first plaintiff, is the tenant of a shop at Stafford City Shopping Centre in Brisbane, having occupied the shop since approximately 11 December 1997 under a lease executed in November 1997. The lease provides for an initial rental of $58,000.00 per annum, which equates to $4,833.33 per month. The plaintiffs claim that $2,679.17 is a fair monthly rental and seek relief under the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) for alleged misleading and deceptive conduct and other contraventions of that Act. The defendant, Yu Feng Pty Ltd, denies the plaintiffs' allegation regarding the fair monthly rental. This dispute has led to an application for orders for disclosure under O. 35 of the Rules of the Supreme Court of Queensland.

The plaintiffs have sought reports of rental figures from 183 "eat in food tenancies" that are under 50m² in area, which are comparable to the shop in question. Initially, the plaintiffs sought reports on all 183 tenancies, but the application was later narrowed to 35 tenancies in shopping centres owned by the defendant, following the disclosure that only 35 of the 183 tenancies were in centres owned by the defendant. Despite written notices from the plaintiffs' solicitors to the defendant's solicitors requesting the production of these reports, the defendant has not complied with these requests.

The matter came before the Supreme Court of Queensland as an application for orders for disclosure under O. 35 of the Rules of the Supreme Court of Queensland. The summons was filed on 4 March 1999 and heard on 4 May 1999. The application was made in the context of action no. 10143 of 1998, with the understanding that the decision would apply mutatis mutandis to action no. 11486 of 1998. The first plaintiff, Cardinia Pty Ltd, and the second plaintiffs, Mr. and Mrs. Kennedy, are the applicants, while Yu Feng Pty Ltd is the defendant.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the defendant is required to produce reports of rental figures for 35 comparable tenancies under O. 35 r. 13 of the Supreme Court Rules (Qld).
2. Whether the defendant is required to make further and better disclosure under O. 35 r. 4 of the Supreme Court Rules (Qld) concerning documents relating to the rental agreements, contributions, rebates, discounts, and other inducements for food outlets in the shopping centre, as well as documents evidencing the actual rentals paid by tenants.

Held
1. The court held that the defendant is required to produce reports of rental figures for 35 comparable tenancies under O. 35 r. 13 of the Supreme Court Rules (Qld).
2. The court held that the defendant is required to make further and better disclosure under O. 35 r. 4 of the Supreme Court Rules (Qld) concerning documents relating to the rental agreements, contributions, rebates, discounts, and other inducements for food outlets in the shopping centre, as well as documents evidencing the actual rentals paid by tenants.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In relation to the first issue, the court found that Order 35 Rule 13 of the Supreme Court Rules (Qld) allows for the production of documents referred to in pleadings or affidavits to ensure fairness in litigation. The court considered that the plaintiffs' request for reports of rental figures for 35 comparable tenancies was justified as it aimed to assess the market rental, which in turn could influence the determination of a fair monthly rental. The court rejected the defendant's argument that the reports were irrelevant or inadmissible, as the relevance and admissibility were matters to be addressed at trial. The court concluded that the plaintiffs were entitled to the relief sought under paragraph 1 of the summons.

For the second issue, the court emphasised that Order 35 Rule 4 requires the disclosure of documents directly relevant to an allegation in issue. The court found that the documents sought by the plaintiffs concerning rental agreements, contributions, rebates, discounts, and actual rentals were directly relevant to the allegation of fair monthly rental. The court noted that the defendant had not provided a valid reason to withhold these documents and ordered their disclosure, subject to certain conditions to protect the interests of other tenants. The court also considered that some documents were too remote in time or related to settlements of other actions, and thus were not directly relevant to the allegation in issue.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that under the Supreme Court Rules (Qld), a party is entitled to the production of documents referred to in pleadings or affidavits under Order 35 Rule 13 and to the disclosure of documents directly relevant to an allegation in issue under Order 35 Rule 4, unless there is a valid reason to withhold such disclosure. The court's decision in this case follows established legal principles and authorities concerning disclosure and production of documents in litigation, and it did not depart from prior authority.