Caratti v Mammoth Investments Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 66 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

TITLE OF COURT :   THE COURT OF APPEAL (WA)

CITATION:   CARATTI -v- MAMMOTH INVESTMENTS PTY LTD [No 2] [2018] WASCA 6

CORAM:   BUSS P

MURPHY JA

HEARD:   22 NOVEMBER 2017

DELIVERED          :   19 JANUARY 2018

FILE NO/S:   CACV 21 of 2014

BETWEEN:   ALLEN BRUCE CARATTI

Appellant

AND

MAMMOTH INVESTMENTS PTY LTD
First Respondent

NAVARAC PTY LTD
Second Respondent

ESPERANCE CATTLE CO PTY LTD
Third Respondent

GRANITE HILL PTY LTD
Fourth Respondent

FILE NO/S              :CACV 112 of 2014

BETWEEN             :MAMMOTH INVESTMENTS PTY LTD

Appellant

AND

GRANITE HILL PTY LTD
First Respondent

ALLEN BRUCE CARATTI
Second Respondent

ESPERANCE CATTLE CO PTY LTD
Third Respondent

FILE NO/S              :CACV 120 of 2014

BETWEEN             :GRANITE HILL PTY LTD

Appellant

AND

ESPERANCE CATTLE CO PTY LTD
First Respondent

NAVARAC PTY LTD
Second Respondent

MAMMOTH INVESTMENTS PTY LTD
Third Respondent

ALLEN BRUCE CARATTI
Fourth Respondent

ON APPEAL FROM:

Jurisdiction              :  SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Coram  :MARTIN CJ

Citation  :ESPERANCE CATTLE COMPANY PTY LTD -v- GRANITE HILL PTY LTD [2014] WASC 279

File No  :CIV 1594 of 2013

Catchwords:

Practice and procedure - Liberty to apply - Meaning and effect of liberty to apply - Proper construction of order - To reserve for further consideration primary judge's orders as to assessment of damages - Whether delay in making application - Whether interests of justice to allow applications to be heard on their merits - Whether orders of the primary judge for assessment of damages should be set aside - Conventional bases upon which an order for assessment of damages is made - Whether judge's erroneous findings in the primary decision affected findings of breach and causation and thereby the making of orders for damages to be assessed

Practice and procedure - Request for remitter to another judge on the basis of apprehended bias - Whether request for recusal should be made to primary judge - Whether any proper basis for recusal where primary judge is part heard

Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), s 137B, s 18, s 236 of sch 2 (Australian Consumer Law)

Result:

Remitter of certain matters to primary judge pursuant to liberty to apply

Category:    B

Representation:

CACV 21 of 2014

Counsel:

Appellant:     Dr J T Schoombee & Mr A P Rumsley

First Respondent           :     Mr D Ryan SC & Ms P M Tantiprasut

Second Respondent      :     Mr D Ryan SC & Ms P M Tantiprasut

Third Respondent          :     No appearance

Fourth Respondent        :     Mr J A Thomson SC

Solicitors:

Appellant:     Alan Rumsley Commercial Disputes Lawyer

First Respondent           :     Lemonis & Tantiprasut Lawyers

Second Respondent      :     Lemonis & Tantiprasut Lawyers

Third Respondent          :     No appearance

Fourth Respondent        :     Pacer Legal Pty Ltd

CACV 112 of 2014

Counsel:

Appellant:     Mr D Ryan SC & Ms P M Tantiprasut

First Respondent           :     Mr J A Thomson SC

Second Respondent      :     Dr J T Schoombee & Mr A P Rumsley

Third Respondent          :     No appearance

Solicitors:

Appellant:     Lemonis…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Caratti v Mammoth Investments Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] WASCA 6
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Court of Appeal of Western Australia, Allen Bruce Caratti has applied to the court for reconsideration of orders made in three appeals arising from a decision of Martin CJ in Esperance Cattle Company Pty Ltd v Granite Hill Pty Ltd. The appeals, which were heard together, concerned a sublease executed by Mammoth Investments Pty Ltd, a company associated with the Caratti family, to Granite Hill Pty Ltd, and the dispute over the validity of that sublease. Allen Caratti, who signed the sublease as a director of Mammoth when he was not, and forged the signature of another director, has now sought to rely on the liberty to apply, which was granted in the appeal decision, to argue that the orders made by the primary judge should be reconsidered.

The key issues before the court were whether the liberty to apply was properly engaged and, if so, what orders should be made. In particular, the court considered whether the delay in making the application, the interests of justice, and the effect of any errors in the primary decision on the orders made for assessment of damages should be taken into account. The court also considered whether there was any basis for the recusal of the primary judge.

The court found that the liberty to apply was properly engaged, but that the delay in making the application was a significant factor against allowing the applications to be heard on their merits. The court noted that the primary judge had made orders for assessment of damages, and that the delay in making the application meant that the interests of justice did not favour allowing the applications to be heard on their merits. The court also found that the errors in the primary decision did not affect the findings of breach and causation, and therefore did not affect the making of orders for damages to be assessed. Finally, the court found that there was no proper basis for the recusal of the primary judge.

The orders of the court were that Allen Caratti's applications be dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT: This matter involves an application in each of three related appeals. The relevant parties to the present dispute are Mr Allen Bruce Caratti (Allen Caratti), Mammoth Investments Pty Ltd (Mammoth), Navarac Pty Ltd (Navarac) and Granite Hill Pty Ltd (Granite Hill).[1] Mammoth and Navarac are companies associated with the Caratti family. [1] There was evidence that another party to the appeals, Esperance Cattle Co Pty Ltd, has been placed in liquidation, and it did not appear on the present application. Allen Caratti is the appellant in CACV 21 of 2014 (Allen Caratti's appeal), the second respondent in CACV 112 of 2014 (Mammoth's appeal), and the fourth respondent in CACV 120 of 2014 (Granite Hill's appeal). In Allen Caratti's appeal, Granite Hill filed a cross‑appeal, and its grounds were identical to Granite Hill's grounds in Granite Hill's appeal. In Mammoth's appeal, Allen Caratti filed a notice of contention. The three appeals arise out of the decision of Martin CJ in the primary proceedings CIV 1594 of 2013: Esperance Cattle Company Pty Ltd v Granite Hill Pty Ltd (primary decision).[2] The appeals were heard together by this Court, and reasons were delivered on 27 May 2016: Caratti v Mammoth Investments Pty Ltd (appeal decision).[3] Upon delivering its reasons, the Court made various orders, including that the parties have liberty to apply as to certain matters. [2] Esperance Cattle Company Pty Ltd v Granite Hill Pty Ltd [2014] WASC 279; (2014) 47 WAR 318. [3] Caratti v Mammoth Investments Pty Ltd [2016] WASCA 84; (2016) 50 WAR 84. On 10 May 2017, Allen Caratti filed an application in each of the three appeals, seeking to rely on the liberty to apply. Programming orders were made for affidavits and submissions. Allen Caratti's applications were heard by this court on 22 November 2017. The issues, in substance, are whether the liberty to apply is properly engaged, and if so, what orders, if any, should be made. At all material times, Navarac and Mammoth were companies controlled by the Caratti family. Navarac was the registered proprietor of certain property near Esperance, known as the Young River Station (property). Navarac leased the property to Mammoth. In or about mid‑November 2012, Mammoth purported to execute a sublease of the property to Granite Hill with effect from 28 February 2013. The document (Granite Hill Lease Document)[4] was executed by Granite Hill, and purportedly executed by Mammoth, in that Allen Caratti signed it as a purported director of Mammoth when he was not, and forged the signature of a director, his mother, Maddeleine.[4] In the primary proceedings there were two versions of the alleged sublease by Mammoth to Granite Hill. The judge referred to these two versions as the 'GH version of the Granite Hill sublease' and the 'ABC version' (see, eg, primary decision [121], [288] - [289], [397]). The primary judge found that the material instrument binding on Mammoth was the former instrument, although it did not create a proprietary interest in favour of Granite Hill. It was that instrument which was relevant to the appeal, and which the plurality in the appeal decision (at [519]) referred to as the 'Granite Hill Lease Document'. These reasons, consistently with the plurality's reasons in the appeal decision, maintain that terminology.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established