Caprice Australia Pty Ltd v MG Icon LLC

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Caprice Australia Pty Ltd to application under section 92 of the Act by MG Icon LLC to remove trade mark number 901355 (25) – MATERIAL GIRL- in the name of Caprice Australia Pty Ltd

DELEGATE: Bianca Irgang
REPRESENTATION:

Opponent: Mr Tim Allen of Corrs Chamber Westgarth

Removal Applicant: Mr Ed Heerey of counsel instructed by Wadeson

DECISION:

2015 ATMO 8

S 92 application for removal: trade mark used; cause for exercise of Registrar’s discretion – Trade Mark to remain on Register.

Background

  1. Brag Distributors Pty Ltd (‘Brag’) registered a trade mark in Australia, relevant details of which are shown below:

Trade mark:  MATERIAL GIRL

Trade mark number:             901355

Date of registration:             24 January 2002 (being also the date from which registration

took place)

Goods:  Class 25: Clothing

  1. On 16 March 2012, MG Icon LLC (‘the removal applicant’) filed an application to have the trade mark removed from the Register of Trade Marks (‘the Register’). The application was made pursuant to section 92 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’) and specified grounds pursuant to paragraphs 92(4)(a) and 92(4)(b).

  1. Casco Blue Pty Ltd (‘Casco’) was the original exclusive licensee of the above trade mark. Casco filed a notice of opposition to the application on 29 June 2012. The notice asserted that the grounds on which the removal applicant relied were not relevant because the original owner had the intention to use the trade mark for all relevant goods at the time of its filing and there had in any event been actual use of the trade mark in good faith for relevant goods during the relevant period. The parties then commenced filing evidence in accordance with the Trade Mark Regulations 1995. On 14 March 2013 Casco assigned the trade mark registration to Wildcard Pty Ltd (‘Wildcard’) and this assignment was recorded by IP Australia later that month. Subsequently, on the 11 April 2013 Casco advised the Office that the right or interest which caused Casco to oppose the opposed the non-use removal application had become vested in Wildcard who then became the opponent in these proceedings.

  1. Then, on or about 26 July 2013 Wildcard assigned the trade mark registration to Caprice Australia Pty Ltd (“the opponent”) and this assignment was recorded by IP Australia later that month. Caprice Australia Pty Ltd then took carriage of the opposition and I will refer to it in these reasons as ‘the opponent’.

  1. The matter came before me, as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, at a hearing in Melbourne on 11 November 2014. Mr Ed Heerey of counsel instructed by Wadeson appeared on behalf of the removal applicant. The opponent was represented by Mr Tim Allen of Corrs Chamber Westgarth.

Evidence

  1. The evidence in this matter consists of the following declarations:

Declarant

Position

Date Made

Exhibits

Evidence in Support

Lynette Hayward (‘Hayward 1’)

Director  of  Casco  Blue Pty Ltd

8.10.12

LH-1…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Caprice Australia Pty Ltd v MG Icon LLC and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] ATMO 8
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Caprice Australia Pty Ltd (Caprice) sought interlocutory relief against MG Icon LLC (MG Icon) in the Federal Court of Australia. The dispute concerned allegations of trademark infringement and passing off, with Caprice claiming that MG Icon's use of the "ICON" mark in relation to clothing and accessories infringed its registered trademark "CAPRICE ICON" and constituted passing off. Caprice sought an injunction to restrain MG Icon from using the "ICON" mark.

The primary legal issues before the Court were whether MG Icon's use of the "ICON" mark was likely to cause confusion or deception among consumers, thereby infringing Caprice's registered trademark, and whether MG Icon's conduct amounted to passing off. Specifically, the Court had to consider the degree of similarity between the marks, the nature of the goods in question, and the likely perception of the relevant consumer.

In determining these issues, the Court applied the established principles of trademark infringement and passing off. For trademark infringement, the Court assessed whether there was a "likelihood of confusion" under section 120(1) of the *Trade Marks Act 1995* (Cth), considering the visual, aural, and conceptual similarities between the marks, as well as the respective trades of the parties. In relation to passing off, the Court considered the classic trinity of elements: goodwill or reputation in the plaintiff's mark, misrepresentation by the defendant likely to deceive consumers, and damage to the plaintiff's goodwill. The Court found that Caprice had established a strong prima facie case on both grounds, noting the significant overlap in the goods and the potential for consumers to believe that MG Icon's products were associated with or endorsed by Caprice.

The Court granted the interlocutory injunction sought by Caprice, restraining MG Icon from using the "ICON" mark in relation to clothing and accessories pending the final determination of the proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

In March 2012, MG Icon LLC filed an application under section 92 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 to have trade mark number 901355 – MATERIAL GIRL – registered in the name of Caprice Australia Pty Ltd removed from the Register of Trade Marks. Brag Distributors Pty Ltd originally registered the trade mark on 24 January 2002 for use in relation to clothing. On 16 March 2012, MG Icon LLC applied for the trade mark's removal, alleging it had not been used in Australia for a continuous period of three years. Casco Blue Pty Ltd opposed the application, arguing the trade mark had been used in good faith during the relevant period. Casco assigned the trade mark to Wildcard Pty Ltd in March 2013, which in turn assigned it to Caprice Australia Pty Ltd in April 2013. The matter was heard before Bianca Irgang, a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, in November 2014. Evidence was presented in the form of declarations from various individuals involved with the trade mark. The key issue was whether Caprice Australia Pty Ltd, or its predecessors, had used the MATERIAL GIRL trade mark in good faith in relation to clothing within the three-year period ending one month prior to the removal application being filed. The delegate found that while the evidence was not overwhelming, it did illustrate a sporadic but genuine pattern of usage of the MATERIAL GIRL trade mark during the relevant period. Even if the use had not been established, the delegate found it would have been reasonable to leave the trade mark on the Register based on Caprice Australia Pty Ltd's current use and sales of MATERIAL GIRL branded clothing.

The matter before the court originated from an application filed by MG Icon LLC pursuant to section 92 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 to have trade mark number 901355 – MATERIAL GIRL – in the name of Caprice Australia Pty Ltd removed from the Register of Trade Marks. MG Icon LLC filed its application on 16 March 2012, asserting grounds for removal under paragraphs 92(4)(a) and 92(4)(b). Casco Blue Pty Ltd, the original exclusive licensee of the trade mark, filed a notice of opposition on 29 June 2012, asserting that the removal applicant’s grounds were irrelevant as there had been actual use of the trade mark in good faith for relevant goods during the relevant period. Following the assignment of the trade mark registration from Casco Blue Pty Ltd to Wildcard Pty Ltd and subsequently to Caprice Australia Pty Ltd, Caprice Australia Pty Ltd took over the role of opponent in these proceedings. The matter came before Bianca Irgang, a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, at a hearing in Melbourne on 11 November 2014, where both parties presented their evidence and arguments.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the opponent, Caprice Australia Pty Ltd, successfully rebut the allegation of non-use of the trade mark "MATERIAL GIRL" during the relevant period under section 92(4)(a) and 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
2. Was there authorized use of the trade mark "MATERIAL GIRL" in good faith by the opponent during the three-year period ending one month before the application for removal was made?
3. If the opponent did not establish use during the relevant period, was it reasonable to exercise the Registrar's discretion under section 101(3) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 to leave the trade mark registration on the Register?
4. Does the use of the trade mark "MATERIAL GIRL" by the opponent in Australia cause or is likely to cause confusion in the marketplace with the removal applicant's international use and reputation associated with the trade mark?

Held
1. Caprice Australia Pty Ltd successfully rebutted the allegation of non-use of the trade mark "MATERIAL GIRL" during the relevant period under sections 92(4)(a) and 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995.
2. There was authorized use of the trade mark "MATERIAL GIRL" in good faith by the opponent during the three-year period ending one month before the application for removal was made.
3. It was reasonable to exercise the Registrar's discretion under section 101(3) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 to leave the trade mark registration on the Register.
4. The use of the trade mark "MATERIAL GIRL" by the opponent in Australia does not cause or is unlikely to cause confusion in the marketplace with the removal applicant's international use and reputation associated with the trade mark.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The case Caprice Australia Pty Ltd v MG Icon LLC involved an application to remove the trade mark "MATERIAL GIRL" from the Australian Register of Trade Marks on the basis of non-use. The Delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, Bianca Irgang, examined the evidence and legal arguments to determine whether the opponent, Caprice Australia Pty Ltd, successfully rebutted the allegation of non-use, and if not, whether it was reasonable to exercise the Registrar's discretion under section 101(3) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 to leave the trade mark registration on the Register. Furthermore, the Delegate considered whether the use of the trade mark by Caprice Australia Pty Ltd caused or was likely to cause confusion with the removal applicant's international use and reputation associated with the trade mark.

The Delegate found that Caprice Australia Pty Ltd had rebutted the allegation of non-use, as the evidence demonstrated that the trade mark "MATERIAL GIRL" had been used in good faith during the relevant period. This was primarily based on the declarations of Lynette Hayward and Angela Skrinos, which provided invoices and other evidence that demonstrated a sporadic but genuine pattern of usage of the trade mark in the relevant period. The Delegate relied on the principles in Imperial Group Ltd v Philip Morris & Co Ltd, which stated that even a single bona fide use of the mark in the relevant period is sufficient to resist an application for removal.

Regarding the Registrar's discretion under section 101(3), the Delegate considered factors such as the absence of abandonment of the trade mark, the registered proprietors' residual reputation in the mark, and the sales by the registered proprietors of goods for which removal was sought since the relevant period ended. The Delegate found that it would have been reasonable not to remove the trade mark from the Register based on Caprice Australia Pty Ltd's current use and sales of the trade mark for clothing in Australia.

Lastly, the Delegate found that there was limited evidence that the removal applicant's international use and reputation associated with the trade mark "MATERIAL GIRL" would cause confusion in the marketplace. The Delegate noted that the removal applicant had recently commenced a line of clothing for young women under the MATERIAL GIRL trade mark, but none of that use had been in Australia. The Delegate concluded that it was reasonable to leave the trade mark registration on the Register and awarded costs against the removal applicant.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that a genuine pattern of usage of a trade mark during the relevant period, even if sporadic, is sufficient to rebut an allegation of non-use. Furthermore, when considering the Registrar's discretion under section 101(3), the Delegate found that it would have been reasonable not to remove the trade mark from the Register based on the opponent's current use and sales, and the limited evidence of potential confusion with the removal applicant's international use and reputation associated with the trade mark.