Capital and Equity Group Pty Ltd v Hilton Central Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeals: Civil)

CAPITAL AND EQUITY GROUP PTY LTD v HILTON CENTRAL LTD

[2010] SASC 197

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Kourakis

2 July 2010

PROCEDURE - INFERIOR COURTS - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - MAGISTRATES COURT

LANDLORD AND TENANT - CREATION OF RELATIONSHIP - PAYMENT OF RENT

LANDLORD AND TENANT - TENANCIES OTHER THAN FOR A TERM - LESSER PERIODIC TENANCIES - MONTHLY TENANCIES - OTHER MATTERS

Appellant commenced proceedings in Magistrates Court claiming to hold a lease from respondent over commercial premises – appellant sought interlocutory orders allowing it to continue to occupy premises until its claim finally determined – Magistrate dismissed interlocutory application on grounds that appellant held no more than a monthly periodic tenancy – no application for summary judgment before Magistrate – whether orders should be set aside because Magistrate made final orders on interlocutory application with respect to parties’ rights of occupancy and possession – whether legal controversy before Magistrate could have been adjudicated on affidavit evidence alone.

Held: Appeal allowed – appellant did not apply for final orders in interlocutory application – there was no application before Magistrate on which appellant’s proceedings could be summarily dismissed – there was a real and substantial dispute over the nature and terms of appellant’s tenancy – the appellant’s claim could not be disposed of summarily – Magistrate’s final orders on interlocutory application should be set aside.

Real Property Act 1886 s 69; Retail and Commercial Leases Act 1995 s 20B; Magistrates Court (Civil) Rules 1992 r 26A, r 63, r 64, referred to.
RM Hosking Properties Pty Ltd v Barnes [1971] SASR 100, applied.

CAPITAL AND EQUITY GROUP PTY LTD v HILTON CENTRAL LTD
[2010] SASC 197

Magistrates Appeal:  Civil

  1. KOURAKIS J:     The appellant (Capital and Equity) sought interlocutory orders against the respondent (Hilton Central) in the Magistrates Court allowing it to continue to occupy commercial premises (the premises) until its claim to hold a lease was finally determined.  Hilton Central is the proprietor of a suburban shop and office centre (the centre) on which the premises are located.  Hilton Central purchased the centre after its predecessor in title had leased the premises, for a term exceeding six months, to Capital and Equity.  The Magistrate dismissed Capital and Equity’s interlocutory application on the grounds that Capital and Equity held no more than a monthly periodic tenancy.  In the Magistrate’s opinion, it followed that Hilton Central, having given Capital and Equity notice to quit the premises, was entitled to possession of the premises.

  2. Capital and Equity appealed those findings on the ground that the Magistrate had erred in failing to find that it occupied the premises pursuant to a lease for a term of more than six months.  Capital and Equity contends that, because it held such a lease, occupation was protected by the Retail and Commercial Leases Act 1995 (the Act).

  3. On the hearing of this appeal it became apparent that the Magistrate had proceeded to make final orders with respect to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Capital and Equity Group Pty Ltd v Hilton Central Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] SASC 197
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Capital and Equity Group Pty Ltd v Hilton Central Ltd, the appellant, Capital and Equity, sought to establish that it held a lease over commercial premises from the respondent, Hilton Central. Capital and Equity sought interlocutory orders to continue occupying the premises until the dispute was finally determined. The Magistrate dismissed the application, ruling that Capital and Equity held no more than a monthly periodic tenancy. The appeal challenged the Magistrate's authority to make final orders on the parties' rights of occupancy and possession on an interlocutory application and questioned whether the legal controversy could have been adjudicated on affidavit evidence alone.

The central legal issues involved the nature of Capital and Equity's tenancy, whether the Retail and Commercial Leases Act or the Real Property Act governed the situation, and whether the Magistrate could make final orders on an interlocutory application. The appeal further questioned whether the legal controversy could have been resolved based solely on affidavit evidence.

The court found that the Magistrate did not have the authority to make final orders on the parties' rights of occupancy and possession in an interlocutory application. The court noted that while the Magistrate could dismiss the interlocutory application, he could not adjudicate on the underlying rights of the parties. The court also observed that there was no application for summary dismissal, and neither party had raised the issue of summarily disposing of the proceedings. Consequently, the appeal was allowed, and the Magistrate's final orders were set aside.

The court's decision resulted in the setting aside of the Magistrate's final orders and the allowance of the appeal, leaving the matter to be determined on its merits at a later stage.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The reasoning of the Magistrate appears in the following paragraphs:[17]Mr Swan for the defendant submitted that there was no basis upon which it might be suggested that the Retail and Commercial Leases Act would prevail against the provision of the Real Property Act. He said that if the lease had not been committed to writing and hence was not in registrable form, it could not prevail against the new registered proprietor unless the lease was for less than 12 months. He said that the scheme of the two acts was clearly consistent, namely that Parliament intended that if a lease was to prevail against a bona fide purchaser – even a bona fide purchaser with notice – that lease should be registered.[18]I note reference in the Stokes v MPC case to the only apparently then reported decision in South Australia on point, namely R.M. Hosking Properties Pty Ltd v Barnes & Ors [1971] SASR 100. Walters J. concluded – notwithstanding the fact that a purchaser had clear knowledge of the unregistered lease of the tenant – that the purchaser was entitled to evict the tenant upon requisite notice.Conclusion[19]I reject Mr Rigall’s submission that I must conclude that the oral unregistered lease prevails over the defendant’s unencumbered title. I accept Mr Swan’s submission that the defendant is entitled both under common law of property and pursuant to the provisions of the Real Property Act to give notice to Capital & Equity to quit and is entitled to take possession of the property. It follows that I find that the Notice to Quit was lawful and further that the plaintiff is not entitled to an order for relief from forfeiture.No application for summary dismissal It will be noticed that the findings in [19] of the Magistrate’s reasons purport to finally resolve the mutual rights and obligations of the parties over the occupancy of the premises. Even if the Magistrate had correctly reached his conclusion, the only order he properly could have made was to dismiss Capital and Equity’s application for interlocutory relief. I accept that the form of the interlocutory orders which were sought and the way in which submissions were put may have given the impression that what was in issue was the underlying right to occupy the premises. However, the only application before the Magistrate was one brought by Capital and Equity seeking interlocutory relief. I am informed by the affidavit of its solicitor that that was all it ever intended to seek. There was no conduct on the part of either party which expressly or implicitly raised for determination the summary disposition of the proceedings in favour of Hilton Central. For this reason, I would allow the appeal and set aside the Magistrate’s final orders.Application of s 20B of the Act I now turn to the ground on which Capital and Equity appealed the Magistrate’s decision. As I have explained in [27] above, there was a real and substantial dispute over the nature and terms of Capital and Equity’s tenancy. Capital and Equity claimed that s 20B of the Act operated on the lease or tenancy it held and extended it to a fixed term of five years. Section 20B provides:20B—Minimum 5 year term(1) The term for which a retail shop lease is entered into must be at least five years.The term of a retail shop lease is worked out under this section on the assumption that any right or option of renewal or extension under the lease or a collateral agreement will in fact be exercised. However, a right or option of renewal or extension will not be taken into account if it is given after the lease is entered into.(2)A lease is not invalidated by contravention of this section but the term of the lease is extended to bring the term (or aggregate term) to five years.Example—If a lease is entered into for a term of three years, its term is extended by two years to five years. If a lease is entered into for a term of two years with an option for a further one year after that initial two years, the term of the lease is extended to four years (with the option for a further one year after that initial four years).(3) This section does not apply to a lease if—(a) the lease is a short-term lease (ie a lease entered into for a fixed term of 6 months or less); or(b) the lease arises when the lessee holds over after the termination of an earlier lease with the consent of the lessor and the period of holding over does not exceed 6 months; or(c) the lease contains a certified exclusionary clause; or(d) the lessee has been in possession of the retail shop premises for at least 5 years; or(e) in the case of a retail shop lease that is a sublease—the term of the retail shop lease is as long as the term of the head lease allows; or(f) the lease is of a class excluded by regulation from the ambit of this Division.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.