Cantone and Telstra Corporation Limited (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

Cantone and Telstra Corporation Limited (Compensation) [2015] AATA 534 (22 July 2015)

Division GENERAL DIVISION

File Number

2014/5285

Re

Salvatore Cantone

APPLICANT

And

Telstra Corporation Limited

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Miss E A Shanahan, Member

Date 22 July 2015
Place Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

............[sgd]............................................................

Miss E A Shanahan, Member

WORKERS’ COMPENSATION – intracerebral haemorrhage resulting in right hemiparesis – severe speech defect – complete spastic paralysis of the right arm – partial recovery of right lower limbs with spasticity and contractures – remedial massage – liability for cost of travel to relocated masseur denied – whether cost reasonably occurred – availability of alternative therapists within a 25 kilometre radius of the Applicant’s home – decision affirmed

Legislation

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988, sections 14 and 16

Cases

Stevens and Comcare [1995] AATA 310
Paul Peter Corfield and Australian Postal Corporation [2000] AATA 533

Mecke and Comcare [2006] AATA 593

REASONS FOR DECISION

Miss E A Shanahan, Member

22 July 2015

  1. Mr Cantone suffered an intracerebral haemorrhage at the level of the left basal ganglia at work on 28 October 2004.  This intracerebral haemorrhage resulted in right spastic hemiparesis and severe aphasia. With the passage of time, there has been some improvement in his right lower limb and his speech, although he has developed clawing of his fingers and toes and a contracture in his right ankle.

  2. Mr Cantone, who lives in Wallan, has received reimbursement of travel costs arising from his weekly remedial massage treatment.  While this treatment has been approved and administered since 14 July 2006, Mr Cantone commenced travelling in excess of a 50 kilometre round trip to receive the treatment in August 2013.  Mr Cantone’s treating remedial masseur, Mr Sam Papaleo had been providing this therapy in Whittlesea but moved his practice to South Morang in late 2013. 

  3. On 18 August 2014 a claims manager of Telstra, the Respondent, determined that it was not liable to pay compensation for the travel costs associated with the massage treatment as this treatment was still available in Whittlesea (the determination).

  4. The reasonableness of the massage treatment was not challenged by the Respondent, only the travel costs.  Following a request for review, the determination was affirmed by a compensation reconsideration officer. Mr Cantone sought a review by this Tribunal of the decision made by the reconsideration officer.

  5. The sole issue before this Tribunal is the reasonableness of Mr Cantone’s travel to South Morang for remedial massage when such or similar treatment is available closer to his home. 

  6. Mr Cantone was represented by Mr Mark Carey of counsel, instructed by Patrick Robinson and Co. Mr John Wallace of counsel appeared for the Respondent, instructed by Sparke Helmore Lawyers. 

  7. Mrs Carmen Cantone gave evidence in person and Dr John Griffiths, Mr Sam Papaleo and Dr Peter Stevenson gave their evidence by telephone.  Mr Cantone did not attend because of his medical incapacity. 

  8. The Tribunal was provided with the documents filed pursuant to s 37 of the Administrative…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cantone and Telstra Corporation Limited (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] AATA 534
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Cantone and Telstra Corporation Limited (Compensation), the parties involved were Mr. Cantone, the applicant, and Telstra Corporation Limited, the respondent. The dispute centered around the compensation for Mr. Cantone's injuries and ongoing treatment costs following a severe intracerebral haemorrhage in 2004. The matter was heard by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT), which was tasked with deciding on the reasonableness of the compensation claimed by Mr. Cantone, including the cost of remedial massages provided by Mr. Sam Papaleo.

The primary legal issues that the AAT had to address were whether the remedial massages provided by Mr. Papaleo were reasonably required for Mr. Cantone's rehabilitation and whether the travel costs associated with these massages were justified. Mr. Wallace, representing the respondent, argued that the massages provided by Mr. Papaleo were not necessary for Mr. Cantone’s rehabilitation and that the travel costs were excessive. He further contended that the effectiveness of the massages was likely due to a placebo effect and that similar benefits could be achieved by other masseurs in the area.

The AAT deliberated on the evidence presented, including the testimonies of Mrs. Cantone, Dr. Griffiths, and Mr. Papaleo. They considered the impact of the massages on Mr. Cantone's symptoms and functional capacity. The Tribunal concluded that Mr. Cantone had exhibited signs and symptoms consistent with a dense right hemiparesis following the intracerebral haemorrhage. The Tribunal found that Mr. Papaleo's massages provided short-term relief of pain and hypertonicity, as well as improved sleep and walking ability. However, the Tribunal also acknowledged the lack of specialist training of Mr. Papaleo and the limited improvement duration post-massage. The Tribunal ultimately accepted that the therapeutic massages were functionally beneficial, but they questioned the necessity of Mr. Papaleo's specific involvement and the associated travel costs.

The AAT determined that while the massages provided some benefit, the travel costs incurred for these sessions were not reasonable. The Tribunal noted the presence of other masseurs in the vicinity, suggesting that similar benefits could potentially be achieved by another practitioner closer to Mr. Cantone's home. The Tribunal rejected the respondent's argument that the travel costs could not be considered separately from the reasonableness of the underlying treatment, emphasizing that the primary focus should be on the necessity and reasonableness of the treatment itself.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Tribunal was provided with the documents filed pursuant to s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Exhibit R1). Both parties tendered further documentation which are listed in the Appendix to this decision. BACKGROUND TO THE APPLICATION Following the intracerebral bleed of 28 October 2004, Mr Cantone was hospitalised at the Royal Melbourne Hospital followed by rehabilitation totalling several months. During the rehabilitation period and for most of 2005 he received Botox injections into his right calf as treatment for the spasticity and developing contractures. This treatment ceased later in 2005 as it was determined that a maximum response had been achieved. Mr Cantone had speech therapy for a period of two years and still has a degree of nominal aphasia. Mrs Cantone is now able to anticipate what he wants to say and she frequently finishes his sentences for him. The Respondent accepted liability in accordance with s 14 of the Safety,Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the SRC Act) for the injury of intracerebral haemorrhage and for Mr Cantone’s treatment, rehabilitation and ongoing support. Mrs Cantone confirmed that her husband had developed clawed toes and fingers on the right side, his right ankle was stiff and he had a contracture of his Achilles tendon. She described his right thigh as being tight. Mr Cantone also suffered uncontrolled movements of his right leg and arm. If he sneezes or yawns, his right leg uncontrollably kicks out from the hip. He is now able to walk with some assistance from Mrs Cantone or using a stick. The right arm remains totally paralysed, hypertonic, hyper-reflexic and spastic. Mr Cantone commenced attending a masseur for massage to his right upper and lower limbs in 2006. He attended a Mr Ward in Whittlesea. Initially, Mr and Mrs Cantone paid for this treatment as they had not realised it was covered under the SRC Act. Mr Ward died about six months into this provision of treatment and Mr Cantone transferred to another clinic in Whittlesea where he was treated by Mr Sam Papaleo and occasionally by Mr Papaleo’s mother, Mrs Maria Handley, principal of the practice. Mrs Handley is now approximately 70 years of age, only works four days per week and has recently placed her practice on the market for sale. While there had been another masseur in the practice, the current staffing level is uncertain. EVIDENCE BEFORE THE TRIBUNALMrs Maria Cantone Mrs Cantone provided all the details of her husband’s stroke and his current status. She has to cut up his food for him as he eats using his left hand. He can cope with his toileting and is able to walk with her assistance or a walking stick. When away from home, he wears a brace on his right lower limb. Mrs Cantone believes her husband suffers a considerable amount of pain which is cramp-like in nature and disturbs his sleep. When his pain is severe his mood changes and he becomes irritable or what she described as snappy. Mrs Cantone noted that after massage by Mr Papaleo, her husband was much happier, had less pain and was more upright in his stance. His sleep also improved. This improvement lasted two to four days depending on his level of activity. If he exerted himself more, such as in his vegetable garden, his pain recurred more rapidly. Mrs Cantone informed the Tribunal that her husband had not attended any specialists such as a neurologist or neurosurgeon, speech therapist or the like since about 2006 when his rehabilitation providers assessed him as having achieved maximal improvement. She was of the opinion that Mr Papaleo’s massage was the most beneficial of any they had tried, including Mr Ward and Mrs Handley and the other masseur in Mrs Handley’s practice, all of whom treated him for only a few months. Mr Sam Papaleo

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Cantone commenced attending a masseur for massage to his right upper and lower limbs in 2006. He attended a Mr Ward in Whittlesea. Initially, Mr and Mrs Cantone paid for this treatment as they had not realised it was covered under the SRC Act. Mr Ward died about six months into this provision of treatment and Mr Cantone transferred to another clinic in Whittlesea where he was treated by Mr Sam Papaleo and occasionally by Mr Papaleo’s mother, Mrs Maria Handley, principal of the practice. Mrs Handley is now approximately 70 years of age, only works four days per week and has recently placed her practice on the market for sale. While there had been another masseur in the practice, the current staffing level is uncertain. EVIDENCE BEFORE THE TRIBUNALMrs Maria Cantone Mrs Cantone provided all the details of her husband’s stroke and his current status. She has to cut up his food for him as he eats using his left hand. He can cope with his toileting and is able to walk with her assistance or a walking stick. When away from home, he wears a brace on his right lower limb. Mrs Cantone believes her husband suffers a considerable amount of pain which is cramp-like in nature and disturbs his sleep. When his pain is severe his mood changes and he becomes irritable or what she described as snappy. Mrs Cantone noted that after massage by Mr Papaleo, her husband was much happier, had less pain and was more upright in his stance. His sleep also improved. This improvement lasted two to four days depending on his level of activity. If he exerted himself more, such as in his vegetable garden, his pain recurred more rapidly. Mrs Cantone informed the Tribunal that her husband had not attended any specialists such as a neurologist or neurosurgeon, speech therapist or the like since about 2006 when his rehabilitation providers assessed him as having achieved maximal improvement. She was of the opinion that Mr Papaleo’s massage was the most beneficial of any they had tried, including Mr Ward and Mrs Handley and the other masseur in Mrs Handley’s practice, all of whom treated him for only a few months. Mr Sam Papaleo Mr Papaleo is qualified as a remedial massage therapist and naturopath and has been in full time practice for 27 years. Initially, he practiced with his mother in Whittlesea. He has treated Mr Cantone since 14 July 2006 and sees him on a weekly basis. The treatment lasts for 35 to 45 minutes. Mr Papaleo treats the right and left sides, as apparently Mr Cantone overuses his left side and develops symptomatology related to overuse. Mr Papaleo provided several reports (T23 and T24) and more recently a short report outlining his experience (Exhibit A2). Mr Papaleo said he measured the efficacy of the massage given in terms of Mr Cantone’s functional capacity and in particular the blood flow in his right-sided limbs and the movement in his arms and legs. The lessening of the degree and strength of the clawing was also a pointer to the remedial effect of the massage.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Wallace contended that Mr Carey’s approach was misconceived in that it was impossible to separate the reasonableness of the payment of travel costs from the reasonableness of the underlying treatment. He contended that if long term massage was not effective, travel costs could not be considered reasonable. Mr Wallace pointed out that at the time the decision was made, namely, 18 August 2014 there were two therapists providing massage in Whittlesea. It was contended that the only effect relating to the therapeutic massage was a placebo one and that similar effect may be achieved by another masseur once rapport was established.TRIBUNAL’S DELIBERATIONS Mr Cantone has exhibited signs and symptoms of a relatively dense right hemiparesis since suffering an intracerebral bleed at the level of the left basal ganglia in late October 2004. The Tribunal accepts the evidence provided by Dr Stevenson when he examined Mr Cantone in April 2005, that the left basal ganglia haemorrhage had resulted in a dense right hemiparesis with hypertonicity, hyper-reflexia and spasticity. The Tribunal rejects Dr Griffiths’ evidence that there was no hyper-reflexia. The physical signs listed by Dr Stevenson are classical findings following basal ganglia haemorrhage as described in any text book of physiology or neurology. Over the years, there has been some improvement in the function of Mr Cantone’s right lower limb to the extent that he can walk with some assistance or supervision and is able to tend to his vegetable patches. He continues to suffer from nominal aphasia and has developed clawing due to contractures in both his right hand and right foot and apparently a contracture at his right ankle. There has been no specialist treatment in the form of attendance at a neurologist since 2005 when it was determined that his rehabilitation had reached its maximal level despite the use of Botox in the treatment of his Achilles tendon contracture. Since 2006, Mr Cantone has received remedial massage with short-term relief of pain, hypertonicity and improvement in his mood as evidenced by his improved sleep and walking. Mr Papaleo also reported a 10 degree increase in the range of movement of his right ankle following massage. However, the improvement is limited to two to four days and the greater his level of activity the lesser the period of improvement. As it is more than 10 years since his intracerebral haemorrhage, medical evidence indicate that it appears unlikely he will improve further and treatment is being directed at retaining what mobility Mr Cantone currently has. Mrs Cantone, Dr Griffiths and Mr Papaleo believe that the therapeutic massage is functionally beneficial. This functional improvement has only been attained by Mr Papaleo and not by other masseurs who have treated Mr Cantone in the past. Clearly, Mr Papaleo and Mr Cantone have developed an excellent clinical relationship. Mr Papaleo does not have any specialist training, knowledge or experience in the treatment of hemiplegic patients who have suffered intracerebral haemorrhages. Despite his 27 years of practice he has only treated four people with such intracerebral vascular catastrophes. Mr Papaleo was unable to assist the Tribunal in terms of recommending another therapeutic masseur closer to Mr Cantone’s home in Wallan. Similarly, Dr Griffiths was not able to nominate any particular masseur who might be able to provide the level of treatment and develop the rapport that exists between Mr Cantone and Mr Papaleo, although he gave evidence that there were numerous masseurs practicing in Wallan and nearby.