Cantamessa v Queensland Building and Construction Commission (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Cantamessa v Queensland Building and Construction Commission (No 2) [2021] QCAT 213

PARTIES:

TYRON GUISEPPI CANTAMESSA

(applicant)

v

QUEENSLAND BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSION

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO:

APL265-19

MATTER TYPE:

Appeals

DELIVERED ON:

23 February 2021

HEARING DATE:

4 February 2021 and by subsequently provided written material from both parties.

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member Roney QC

ORDERS:

1.   Leave to appeal granted.

2.   Appeal dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – APPEAL – GENERAL PRINCIPLES – RIGHT OF APPEAL – WHEN APPEAL LIES – ERROR OF LAW - procedure – costs – Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 100, s 102(3), –discretion to award costs in administrative review matters to a successful Applicant - whether prima facie position in s 100 should be displaced and costs ordered against unsuccessful respondent under s 102 - building work - direction to rectify - residential property with defective works - costs of applications to review decisions which are initially resisted then conceded.

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (QCAT Act), s 20, s 21, s 100, s 102, s 121, s 142
Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld), s 72, s 77

Barry Pitt Constructions Pty Ltd v Smith & Anor [2014] QCATA 339
Commissioner for Children and Young People and Child Guardian v Eales [2013] QCATA 303
Commissioner for Children and Young People and Child Guardian vFGC [2011] QCATA 291
Fuge v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2014] QCAT 383
Jarvis v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2015] QCATA 18
McEwen v Barker Builders Pty Ltd [2010] QCATA 49
Ollier & Glubb v Kuhnemann [2015] QCATA 112
Omae v Queensland Building Services Authority (No 2) [2012] QCAT 151
Queensland All Codes Racing Industry Board v Abbott (No. 2) [2016] QCATA 49
Ralacom Pty Ltd v Body Corporate for Paradise Island Apartments (No 2) [2010] QCAT 412
Ricchetti v Lanbuilt Ply Ltd [2011] QCATA 266
Richards & Anor v Queensland Building and Construction Commission & Anor (No 2) [2019] QCAT 372
Stuart v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2016] QCATA 135
Till v Logan City Council (No. 2) [2020] QCATA 11

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

J Mould of Counsel, instructed by Mahoneys

Respondent:

S Hedger solicitor instructed by HWL Ebsworth Lawyers

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. In February 2014, the Applicant entered into a QBCC contract with Oliver Sabu and Rasmi Nair (‘the Homeowners’) to carry out an extension and renovations to their existing dwelling in Mackay. The works were 'building works' within the meaning of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld) (QBCC Act). The works commenced around 29 April 2014 and under the contract, the original date for practical completion was some 30 weeks from the date on which the works commenced. Later it was agreed that the dwelling was to be completed by the end of business on 31 July 2015, but it was not. On 10 August 2015, the Applicant was advised by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cantamessa v Queensland Building and Construction Commission... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QCAT 213
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Cantamessa v Queensland Building and Construction Commission (No 2) involved a dispute between the applicant, Cantamessa, and the Queensland Building and Construction Commission (QBCC). Cantamessa sought review of a decision by the QBCC to issue a Direction to Rectify and/or Complete No. 0101527, which required Cantamessa to rectify 11 items of defective or incomplete building work. Cantamessa argued that the decision was unfair, denied him natural justice, and was not in accordance with the Objects of the legislation. The matter was heard in the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT). The primary legal issue before the Court was whether it was unfair to direct Cantamessa to rectify the building works. The Court considered whether Cantamessa was afforded natural justice by the QBCC, and whether Cantamessa genuinely attempted to enable and help the QBCC to make the decision on the merits. The Court also examined whether the decision to issue the Direction was unfair, having regard to the amount owing to Cantamessa. The Court found that it was unreasonable to issue a Direction to Rectify because Cantamessa's final tax invoice remained unpaid, he was not informed of the inspections and was not given an opportunity to attend them, and there was considerable uncertainty surrounding the approach taken by the QBCC. The Court found that the decision by the QBCC to issue a Direction was unfair because of the failure by QBCC to clearly identify the purpose of the inspections. The Court held that the objective of the maintenance of building standards was not compromised by not issuing a Direction in the circumstances of this dispute. Conversely, issuing a Direction would not be striking a reasonable balance between the Homeowner and the Applicant.

The Court dismissed Cantamessa's application for leave to appeal, finding that the proceedings were not particularly or unusually complex. The Court found that the issues of fact and law which arose under the applications had some complexity and took two days to be heard, but they were not particularly or unusually complex. The Court also noted that Counsel was briefed for Cantamessa and the Respondent's advocacy was handled by a solicitor both here and below. The Court found that the fact that Cantamessa had to raise "additional various appropriate legal objections mostly arising from the Respondent's conduct of the case" did not make it particularly complex, particularly as he had experienced Counsel capable of dealing with them. The Court concluded that there were no compelling reasons to grant leave to appeal, and dismissed the application for leave to appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The fact that review applications also invoke different considerations to those in an ordinary inter partes dispute, may be seen from the fact that there are special considerations to be considered under s 102 of the QCAT Act when deciding whether to award costs in such cases. Where the proceeding is of a kind such as that here, relevant matters include whether the Applicant was afforded natural justice by the decision maker, and whether the Applicant genuinely attempted to enable and help the decision maker to make the decision on the merits. The Tribunal’s reasons for its decision The Tribunal below made the following findings as to whether it was unfair to direct the Applicant to rectify the building works at [147]-[162]:[147] These proceedings came about following a unilateral decision by a homeowner to take possession of his property after a dispute with his builder.[148] This dispute occurred at a time when the builder was approaching the completion of the contract for the building. There are various matters in dispute as to the events that occurred at that time.[149] It is clear that the Applicant sought payment of the amount of $58,500 on the basis that the property had reached Practical Completion. There is disagreement between the parties around whether the contract was repudiated by the homeowner and that the repudiation was accepted by the Applicant.[150] There is an issue as to whether the homeowner was being unreasonable in placing conditions on the Applicant’s access to the property to undertake any rectification work.[151] The discretionary power to issue a Direction to Rectify derives from s 72 of the QBCC Act that provides that:…if the Commission is of the opinion that building work is defective or incomplete, the Commission may direct the person who carried out the building work to rectify the building work within the period stated in the Direction.[152] Further, s 72(14) [sic] provides that:The Commission is not required to give a Direction under this section to a person who carried out building work for the rectification of the building work if the Commission is satisfied that, in the circumstances, it would be unfair to the person to give the direction.[153] In considering whether it would, in the circumstances of this case, be unfair to issue a direction, it is relevant to consider the Objects of the legislation. The Objects, relevantly, include ‘to achieve a reasonable balance between the interests of building contractors and consumers’.[154] In the Tribunal’s view, it was unreasonable to issue a Direction to Rectify because(a) The Applicant’s final tax invoice remains unpaid;(b) The Applicant was not informed of the inspections and was not given an opportunity to attend them.(c) There was considerable uncertainty surrounding the approach taken by the QBCC.[155] On 30 January 2017, QBCC issued the Applicant with a Direction to Rectify and/or Complete No. 0101527 requiring 11 items of defective or incomplete building work to be rectified. This Final Direction was received by the Applicant on 7 February 2017.[156] Following receipt of the Final Direction, the Applicant wrote to the Homeowner on 15 February 2017, requesting the release of all keys to the Property so that he could attend to the items of defective and incomplete work in the Final Direction.[157] On 7 March 2017, the Applicant filed an Application in the Tribunal seeking a review of the decision by the QBCC to issue Direction to Rectify and/or Complete, No 0101527 on 3 grounds:(a) The Applicant has been denied natural justice and procedural fairness by the QBCC and accordingly the decision made by the QBCC to issue the direction was inappropriate;(b) The decision to issue the Direction was unfair, having regard to the amount owing to the Applicant; and(c) The works are not defective works.[158] There was a clear disconnect between QBCC agreeing that the building was 85% completed and the amount subsequently identified to undertake rectification and complete the works between $300,000 and $500,000.[159] In the Tribunal’s view the decision by the QBCC to issue a Direction was unfair because of the failure by QBCC to clearly identify the purpose of the inspections by Sergon to assist QBCC with its assessment of the homeowner’s claim under the Statutory Insurance Scheme rather than to prepare a Scope of Works to rectify the alleged defective work and to decide if the Applicant ought to be directed to rectify the alleged defective building work.[160] In the Tribunal’s view, even if it was to find that the work was defective and that, therefore, the pre-conditions to the exercise of the discretion to issue the Direction had been met, it would [be] unfair to issue a Direction in these circumstances.[161] While an important object of the legislation is to maintain building standards, an equally important objective is to achieve a reasonable balance between the interests of building contractors and consumers.[162] In the Tribunal’s view, the objective of the maintenance of building standards is not compromised by not issuing a Direction in the circumstances of this dispute. Conversely, issuing a Direction would not be striking a reasonable balance between the Homeowner and the Applicant.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It may be seen from the findings above, that the findings go tantalisingly close to reaching a conclusion about whether the Applicant has been denied natural justice and procedural fairness by the QBCC but fail to do so.The Applicant’s arguments and the relevant considerations under s 102 The Applicant submits that leave to appeal should be granted because, he contends, “this is a case where a government authority has simply not abided by fundamental legal principles in the prosecution of a citizen who has incurred significant cost to defend himself" and the decision below “highlighted that the Respondent must adhere to the legislative requirements, common law, principles of natural justice and principles of fairness that bind them instead of embarking on a cavalier approach in reckless disregard of its duty to the Tribunal, to its opponent and to the law in general" and the “Respondent has breached natural justice". Section 100 presumes that ordinarily each party to a proceeding would bear that party’s own costs, irrespective of the result. On that basis there ought be no order for costs unless the interests of justice ought lead to a different result. The Applicant contends that the proceedings were complex, and the Applicant’s case was “strong” (even on what he submits was the scant evidence selected to be called by the Respondent) and “legal representation was required to achieve a just result especially given the Respondent was legally represented”. The Applicant contends that the matter was extremely legally complex as well by virtue of the Applicant having to raise “additional various appropriate legal objections mostly arising from the Respondent’s conduct of the case” including what he says was a “breach of natural justice; a breach of the rule in Makita v. Sprowles; a breach of Model Litigant Principles; a breach of the QCAT Practice Direction incorporating Rule 428 UCPR; a breach of various provisions of the QCAT Act; a breach of QBCC policy considerations; repudiation; and the requisite burden of proof.” In that regard the issues he refers to I discuss below as contentions in support of the proposition that the Applicant was disadvantaged. The Applicant submits that “To qualify as ‘complex’, an appeal should involve difficult or novel legal concepts or technical evidence that requires complex reasoning to enable the Tribunal to make a decision” and that is what occurred in the trial. He cites Queensland All Codes Racing Industry Board v Abbott (No. 2) [2016] QCATA 49 at [13] for that proposition. The quote just referenced concerns appeals not trial hearings. I am not convinced that it has application generally. The issues, both of fact, which arose under the applications had some complexity and took two days to be heard but they were not, in my view, particularly or unusually complex. I note that Counsel was briefed for the Applicant and the Respondent’s advocacy was handled by a solicitor both here and below. The issues of law which arose under the applications such as they were, were not in my view particularly complex. I do not consider that the fact, if it be one that the Applicant had to raise “additional various appropriate legal objections mostly arising from the Respondent’s conduct of the case” made it particularly complex, particularly as he had experienced Counsel capable of dealing with them.