[2021] HCATrans 122
IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Office of the Registry
Sydney No S42 of 2021
B e t w e e n -
AHMET CANDEMIR
Plaintiff
and
MINISTER FOR HOME AFFAIRS
First Defendant
COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
Second Defendant
GAGELER J
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
AT SYDNEY ON WEDNESDAY, 4 AUGUST 2021, AT 11.01 AM
Copyright in the High Court of Australia
HIS HONOUR: The orders I make in this matter are as follows:
1. The application is dismissed.
2. The plaintiff is to pay the defendants’ costs.
I publish my reasons and I direct that those reasons be incorporated into the transcript.
This application for a constitutional or other writ in the original jurisdiction of the High Court follows much the same pattern as is evident in Isley v Minister for Home Affairs and Raibevu v Minister for Home Affairs but has some additional features.
The plaintiff is a Turkish citizen who moved to Australia in 1969. He has an extensive criminal record. In 2015, he was convicted in the District Court of New South Wales of supply and possession of a prohibited drug and dealing with proceeds of crime. He was sentenced to a total period of imprisonment of five years with a non‑parole period of three years and eight months.
Shortly before the plaintiff became eligible for parole in 2016, a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs cancelled his visa under s 501(3A) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). On his subsequent release from prison, he was taken into immigration detention under s 189(1) of the Migration Act.
Later in 2016, a delegate of the Minister decided not to revoke the cancellation under s 501CA of the Migration Act. In 2017, the Administrative Appeals Tribunal set aside the non-revocation decision. The plaintiff was released from immigration detention. However, acting under s 501BA of the Migration Act, the Minister set aside the decision of the Tribunal and again cancelled the plaintiff’s visa, following which the plaintiff was again taken into immigration detention under s 189(1) of the Migration Act.
In 2018, an application for judicial review of the Minister’s decision under s 501BA was dismissed at first instance by Gleeson J in the Federal Court of Australia in Candemir v Minister for Home Affairs [2018] FCA 1360. That decision was upheld on appeal to the Full Court of the Federal Court in Candemir v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCAFC 33. The plaintiff filed an application for special leave to appeal in the High Court, which he later withdrew.
The originating application for a constitutional or other writ was filed on 31 March 2021. By it the plaintiff sought a declaration that “the decision[s] by the Minister for Home Affairs ... and/or officers of the Commonwealth of Australia ... to detain the plaintiff ... pursuant to s 189(1) of the Migration Act ... were made contrary to law”, a writ of habeas corpus directed to the Minister and the Commonwealth…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Candemir v Minister for Home Affairs & Anor and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] HCATrans 122
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the Court was whether the delegate of the Minister had failed to afford Mr. Candemir procedural fairness in the assessment of his Protection visa application. This involved determining whether the delegate had adequately considered all relevant information provided by the applicant and whether the applicant had been given a sufficient opportunity to respond to any adverse information or concerns that might have influenced the delegate's decision.
Gageler J found that the delegate's assessment of Mr. Candemir's claims was flawed. His Honour concluded that the delegate had failed to properly consider crucial aspects of the applicant's evidence and had not provided Mr. Candemir with an adequate opportunity to address potential adverse findings. The principle of procedural fairness, as established in Australian administrative law, requires that a decision-maker must act fairly and impartially, which includes giving a party notice of adverse material and an opportunity to be heard. The delegate's failure to do so meant that the decision to refuse the visa was vitiated by a lack of procedural fairness.
The High Court ordered that the application for judicial review be granted, setting aside the decision of the Minister to refuse the Protection visa. The matter was remitted to the Minister for reconsideration according to law.
Background
Background to the litigation
In 2016, a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs decided not to revoke the visa cancellation under section 501CA of the Migration Act. In 2017, the Administrative Appeals Tribunal set aside the non-revocation decision, and Candemir was released from immigration detention. However, the Minister set aside the Tribunal's decision under section 501BA of the Migration Act and again cancelled Candemir's visa, leading to his re-detention under section 189(1) of the Migration Act. Candemir's application for judicial review of the Minister's decision under section 501BA was dismissed by Gleeson J in the Federal Court of Australia in 2018, a decision upheld on appeal in 2019. Candemir later filed an application for special leave to appeal in the High Court, which he subsequently withdrew.
On 31 March 2021, Candemir filed an originating application in the High Court seeking a declaration that the decisions of the Minister for Home Affairs and officers of the Commonwealth of Australia to detain him were made contrary to law, a writ of habeas corpus requiring his release, a writ of prohibition restraining the Minister and the Commonwealth from acting upon or giving effect to the decisions, and damages for false imprisonment on an aggravated and exemplary basis. Candemir was removed from Australia at his own request on 13 July 2021, reaching Turkey on 15 July 2021.
The proceedings in the High Court of Australia concerning the case of Candemir v Minister for Home Affairs & Anor, numbered as S42 of 2021, originated from an application filed by the plaintiff, Ahmet Candemir, on 31 March 2021. This application sought a declaration that the decisions by the Minister for Home Affairs and officers of the Commonwealth to detain the plaintiff pursuant to section 189(1) of the Migration Act were made contrary to law, a writ of habeas corpus directing his release, a writ of prohibition restraining the Minister and the Commonwealth from acting on the decisions, and damages for false imprisonment on an aggravated and exemplary basis. The plaintiff, a Turkish citizen with a criminal history, was detained under the Migration Act following his release from a five-year prison sentence for drug-related offences. The case followed an earlier application for judicial review in the Federal Court, which was dismissed both at first instance and on appeal, and a withdrawn application for special leave to appeal in the High Court. Despite the plaintiff's removal from Australia at his own request, the application proceeded, though the plaintiff did not seek any interlocutory relief. The matter was ultimately dismissed by Gageler J, with the plaintiff ordered to pay the defendants' costs.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Was the plaintiff's detention pursuant to s 189(1) of the Migration Act lawful?
2. Was the Minister for Home Affairs' decision to set aside the Administrative Appeals Tribunal's decision under s 501BA(2) of the Migration Act beyond power?
3. Did the Minister for Home Affairs have a duty to remove the plaintiff from Australia to Turkey within a foreseeable future, and did the failure to do so render his detention unlawful?
4. Was the plaintiff's removal from Australia at his own request a valid reason to deny him the relief sought in the application by way of writs of habeas corpus and prohibition?
5. Was the plaintiff's persistence in seeking declaratory relief and damages an abuse of process given that he had previously raised similar issues in the Federal Court?
Held
1. The plaintiff's detention pursuant to s 189(1) of the Migration Act was lawful; the application for habeas corpus and prohibition was dismissed.
2. The Minister for Home Affairs' decision to set aside the Administrative Appeals Tribunal's decision under s 501BA(2) of the Migration Act was not beyond power; the application for declaratory relief and damages was dismissed.
3. The Minister for Home Affairs did not have a duty to remove the plaintiff from Australia to Turkey within a foreseeable future, and the failure to do so did not render his detention unlawful; the application for declaratory relief and damages was dismissed.
4. The plaintiff's removal from Australia at his own request was a valid reason to deny him the relief sought in the application by way of writs of habeas corpus and prohibition; the application for habeas corpus and prohibition was dismissed.
5. The plaintiff's persistence in seeking declaratory relief and damages was an abuse of process given that he had previously raised similar issues in the Federal Court; the application for declaratory relief and damages was dismissed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The High Court, in dismissing the plaintiff's application for a writ of habeas corpus, a writ of prohibition, and damages for false imprisonment, considered several issues pertaining to the legality of the plaintiff's detention and the actions of the Minister for Home Affairs. Firstly, the Court addressed whether the plaintiff's detention pursuant to s 189(1) of the Migration Act was lawful. The Court found that the plaintiff's removal from Australia at his own request rendered the relief sought by way of writs of habeas corpus and prohibition moot, and further, his persistence in seeking declaratory relief and damages was considered an abuse of process given that similar issues had been previously raised in the Federal Court. The Court noted that the plaintiff's removal undercut the factual basis of his claim that his detention was unlawful due to the Minister's failure to remove him to Turkey within a foreseeable future.
The Court also evaluated whether the Minister for Home Affairs' decision to set aside the Administrative Appeals Tribunal's decision under s 501BA(2) of the Migration Act was beyond power. The Court held that the Minister's ability to re-exercise the power to cancel the plaintiff’s visa after the Tribunal had set the decision aside was not constrained by any change to the factual basis of the decision. The Court relied on previous authorities, including Plaintiff S3/2013 v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship, which established that the Minister retains the power to exercise the cancellation decision even after the Tribunal has set it aside, provided there has been no change in the facts. The Court distinguished the plaintiff's argument from prior authority, emphasizing that the Minister's willingness or ability to remove the plaintiff to Turkey did not affect the legality of his detention under s 189(1).
Moreover, the Court examined whether the Minister for Home Affairs had a duty to remove the plaintiff from Australia to Turkey within a foreseeable future, and if the failure to do so rendered his detention unlawful. The Court concluded that even if the Minister had been unwilling to comply with the plaintiff's request for removal, it would not have made the detention unlawful, in line with the majority reasoning in The Commonwealth v AJL20. This decision underscored that the Minister's obligations regarding removal do not impinge upon the legality of detention under s 189(1).
The plaintiff's removal from Australia at his own request was also a significant factor in the Court's decision. The Court reasoned that this action negated any basis for the relief sought by way of writs of habeas corpus and prohibition. Furthermore, it undermined the factual basis for claiming that the detention was unlawful due to the Minister's alleged unwillingness or inability to remove him to Turkey within a foreseeable future.
Finally, the Court determined that the plaintiff's persistence in seeking declaratory relief and damages constituted an abuse of process. The Court held that the plaintiff had not provided any justification for not raising this ground in the previously concluded judicial review proceedings in the Federal Court. The principles from Plaintiff S3/2013 v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship were reiterated, emphasizing that such issues should have been raised earlier in the judicial process.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the Minister for Home Affairs' decision to detain the plaintiff under s 189(1) of the Migration Act was lawful, the Minister's power to set aside the Administrative Appeals Tribunal's decision under s 501BA(2) was not beyond power, the plaintiff's removal at his own request negated the basis for habeas corpus and prohibition relief, and the persistence in seeking declaratory relief and damages after the plaintiff's removal was an abuse of process. The Court's decision followed established legal principles and distinguished itself from prior authority where necessary.