CATTCHWORDS
| Adminlstrative | Appeals | Tribunal | Act | - Appeal | from | Tribunal |
| afflrmatlon of | determmation | of | delegate of Commissioner for |
Employees Cornpensation - Aggravatlon of disease of hypertenslon -
| Definition | of | injury | in | 5.5 of | Compensation | (Commonwealth |
| Government Employees) Act | 1971 - Meaning and application of | 5 . 8 . |
| 5.44 |
| Compensation | (Commonwealth | Government | Emplovees) | Act | 1971, |
ss.5,8,27,29.
Commonwealth of Australia v. Whillock (1983) 48 ALR 433
| Reitano | v. The | Commonwealth, | unreported, | Full | Court, | Evatt, |
| Northrop and Burchett | JJ., 13/12/85. |
| CANBERRA COLLEGE | OF ADVANCED EOUCATION | -V- ALBERT EDbLQD CULPIN |
| ACT '3.11 of 1985 | ||
| Burchett J. Sydney 10 February 1986 |
c
| IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA | ) ) |
| 9rVEENSLIND DISTRICT | REGISTRY | ) | No. 11 of 1985 |
| ) | |||
| GENEFGL EIVISION | ) |
| BETWEEN | : |
CANBERRA COLLEGE OF
ADVANCED EDUCATION
Applicant
FLBERT EDI4ARD CULPIN
Respondent
MINrJTE OF ORDERS
| Judue Makinq Order: | Burchett J. |
| Pate of Order: | 10 February 1986 |
-
| [There Made : | Sydney |
| THE CCIUF.T OFOERS THAT: |
| (1) | The | appeal | is | allowed | and | the | decision | of | the |
| Administratlve | Appeals | Tribunal | aff | irming | the |
| determinations of the delegate | of the Commissioner for |
| Employees Compensation of | 9 March 1983, | 5 April 1983 and |
6 April 1983 is set aside.
| ( 2 ) | The matter | be | remitted | to | the | Administrative | Appeals |
| Trlbunal for decision | of the respondent's claim based | on |
| 5.29 | of | the | Compensatlon | (Commonwealth | Government |
Emplovees) Act 1971.
| ( 3 ) | The applicant Canberra College | of | Advanced Education pay |
| the respondent's costs. |
| NOTE: | Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with by Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules. |
| IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA | ) ) | |||
| FUEENSLEND DISTPICT REGISTRY |
| |||
| GENERAL DIVISION | ||||
| BETWEEN : |
CANBERRA COLLEGE OF ADVANCED EDUCATION
Applicant
ALBERT EDWERD CULPIN
Respondent
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
BURCHETT J.
| This is an | appeal | brouglit | under | 5.44 | of | the |
| 1975 m respect of a decision |
| of | the Administrative Appeals Tribunal constituted by Mr. J.O. |
| Ballard, Senior Member. The appeal is, | of | course, limited to |
| questions of law. |
| Thp matter | arises | out | of a claim | for | compensatlon |
pursuant to the Compensation (Commonwealth Government Employees!
1971 made by the respondent, Mr. Culpin. Mr. Culpin, who was
| born on 5 January 1921, was employed as an Assistant Bursar by the applicant, Canberra College of Advanced Education. On | 12 |
| August 1980, during his lunch. break, he enjoyed, as was his |
| custom, a game | of squash with | a friend at the Canberra College | of |
- - .
Advanced Education Sports Centre, which was sltuated within the
| College grounds some | 300 metres from Mr. Culpin's crffice and was |
under the control of the Sports Union, though the building was
maintained by the College. During the game Mr. Culpin suddenly
| collapsed, losing | consciousness | for about ten seconds. He was |
taken to Royal Canberra Hospital at Acton by ambulance and
| remained off work from | 1 2 August to | 12 September 1980. | His |
| resumption of | work | on | 12 September | 1980 | was | unfortunately |
| short-lived, and he went on sick leave on | 10 November 1980.… |
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Canberra College of Advanced Education v Culpin, A.E and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1986] FCA 20
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court centred on the interpretation and application of the Compensation (Commonwealth Government Employees) Act 1971, specifically sections 5, 8, 27, and 29, as well as section 44 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975. The primary issue was whether Mr Culpin's condition, identified as an aggravation of hypertension, constituted an injury under the Act, or if it should be considered a disease requiring evaluation under a different section of the Act. The court also needed to determine whether the Tribunal's decision contained any errors of law that warranted the setting aside of its determination.
The court found that the Administrative Appeals Tribunal had erred in its interpretation of the law. The Tribunal had considered the incident as an injury occurring at the place of employment, which triggered compensation under section 8 of the Act. However, the court held that the incident should have been assessed under section 29, which pertains to diseases. According to the court, the Tribunal's failure to correctly identify the nature of the claim as a disease rather than an injury constituted a material error of law. The court emphasised that the definition of 'injury' in the Act excluded diseases, thereby mandating a different approach under section 29 for conditions such as hypertension. The court concluded that it was open to the Tribunal to decide whether the employment had contributed to the aggravation of Mr Culpin's hypertension, a matter to be resolved on the evidence.
The Federal Court allowed the appeal, set aside the Tribunal's decision, and remitted the matter back to the Tribunal for reconsideration under the correct legal framework. The Court also ordered that the College pay Mr Culpin's costs, in accordance with the applicant's undertaking.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi