Canatan Holdings Pty Ltd v Audori Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read
l0TC 73
JUDGMENT No. ... ........ ....... / ..,.,.,,.,,

TRADE PRACTICES - licence of business and lease of premises - false representations as to past takings and expected future profits of the business - misleading and deceptive conduct - breach of warranty - wrongful ejectment - moneys not accounted for - cross claim for unpaid lease and licence fees and breach of contract

DAMAGES - causation of damage - contribution by applicant to claimed loss in trade practices actions

Trade Practices Act 1977 (Cth) ss 52, 82

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) S. 51A

McRae v Commonwealth DispoSalS Commission [l9511 84 CLR 377
Rea Glass Ptv Ltd v Rivers Lockina Svstems Ptv Ltd [l9681 120
CLR 516
Shevill v Builders' Licensing Board [l9821 149 CLR 620
Progressive Mailina House Ptv v Tabali Ptv Ltd [l9851 157 CLR
17

Gates v The Citv Mutual Life Assurance Societv Limited [l9861

160 CLR 1
- . . - -.. -

Elna Australia Ptv Ltd v International Computers (Australia1

Ptv Ltd [l9871 16 FCR 410 -p-
Sutton v-~hom~son [l9871 73 ALR 233
Munchies Manaaement Ptv Ltd v Belperio [l9881 84 ALR 700
Lowe & Anor v Cudal Nominees Ptv Ltd & Anor [l9911 NSW ConvR
55-585
Frith v Gold Coast Mineral Sprinas Ptv Ltd [l9831 65 FLR 213
Pavich v Bobra Nominees Ptv Ltd French J, unrep. 4 August 1988
Howe v Teefy [l9271 27 SR (NSW) 301
Austin v United Dominions Corvoration Ltd [l9841 2 NSWLR 612
Lombardo v Henne NSW Court of Appeal, unrep. 2 December 1973
Yorkshire Dale Steamshiv CO Ltd v Minister of War Transport
[l9421 AC 691

Carter, Breach of Contract 2nd ed. (Law Book Company, 1991) Cheshire & Fifoot's L-5th ed. (Butterworths, 1988)

CANATAN HOLDINGS PTY LIMITED V AUDORI PTY LIMITED AND CYRIL
EDWARDS
Einfeld J
Sydney
16 July 1993
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA)
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY) NO. G 23 of 1992
GENERAL DIVISION 1

Between: CANATAN HOLDINGS PTY

LIMITED

Applicant

And: AUDORI PTY LIMITED

First Respondent
CYRIL EDWARDS

Second Respondent

MINUTE OF ORDERS AND FINDINGS

1.  The amount of the loss and damage of the applicant is $112,233.

2.   The amount of the loss and damage of the respondents on the cross claim is $14,458.

3.  The respondents are to pay the applicant the sum of $97,775.

4.  Any party seeking costs is to apply in writing within fourteen days stating the bases and grounds upon which costs are sought.

Note: 

Settlement and entry of orders are dealt with in accordance with Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

Einfeld J 
Sydney 

16 July 1993
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA)
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY) NO. G 23 of 1992

GENERAL DIVISION 1

Between: CANATAN HOLDINGS PTY

LIMITED

Applicant

And: AUDORI PTY LIMITED

First Respondent
CYRIL EDWARDS

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

EINFELD SYDNEY 16 JULY 1993

The applicant, Canatan Holdings Pty Limited (Canatan), claims damages for misleading and deceptive conduct and false representations said to have been made by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Canatan Holdings Pty Ltd v Audori Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1993] FCA 1076
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Canatan Holdings Pty Ltd v Audori Pty Limited & Cyril Edwards involves a claim for damages by Canatan against Audori Pty Limited and its director, Cyril Edwards. Canatan alleges that it was induced by false representations made by Audori and Edwards to enter into agreements for the conduct and operation of a door manufacturing business located at Hurstville. The legal issues revolve around whether the representations made by Audori and Edwards constituted misleading and deceptive conduct, whether Audori breached express warranties, and whether Canatan was wrongfully evicted from the property. The court found that Audori and Edwards made false and misleading representations regarding the business's sales figures and potential profits, leading to Canatan's damages. The court awarded Canatan $112,233 in damages and ordered Audori to pay Canatan $97,775. The cross claim by Audori for unpaid lease and licence fees and breach of contract was also dismissed. Any party seeking costs must apply in writing within fourteen days stating the bases and grounds upon which costs are sought.

Background

Background to the litigation

In May or June 1991, Mr and Mrs Stoodley met Mrs Edwards and were informed that the Hurstville property, where the St George Door Centre was located, would be sold or leased. Mr Edwards subsequently showed the Stoodleys a sales journal, invoices, and figures for past takings and profits of the business, allegedly representing that these figures were true. On 24 June 1991, Mr Stoodley instructed his solicitor to draft a lease and a licence for Canatan to operate the business, with an option to purchase. Mr Edwards wrote out figures for the years 1988, 1989, 1990, and the first six months of 1991, which were included in the warranty clause of the licence agreement. The final agreements were executed in July 1991, and Canatan commenced operating the business on 1 July 1991. After taking over the business, Canatan realised that the takings were significantly lower than those represented by Mr Edwards. Mr Stoodley informed Mr Edwards not to come to the business anymore on 26 November 1991. Audori subsequently repossessed the property on 2 January 1992.

The case was heard by Einfeld J in the Federal Court of Australia, New South Wales District Registry. The hearing took place over three days from 7 to 9 December 1992. Written submissions were completed by 23 December 1992, and the judgment was delivered on 16 July 1993.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did Audori make false, misleading, or deceptive representations about the gross takings and profits of the business?
2. Did Audori breach an express warranty contained in the licence agreement?
3. Did Mr Edwards fail to account for moneys received from customers?
4. Was Canatan wrongfully evicted from the premises by Audori?

Held
1. The court held that Audori made false, misleading, or deceptive representations about the gross takings and profits of the business, leading to damages awarded to Canatan under section 82 of the Trade Practices Act 1977 (Cth).
2. The court found that Audori breached an express warranty contained in the licence agreement regarding the gross takings of the business.
3. The court determined that Mr Edwards failed to account for moneys received from customers, and these amounts must now be brought to account in any award of damages.
4. The court ruled that Canatan was wrongfully evicted from the premises by Audori, who wrongfully repudiated the lease and licence agreements.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined each issue in detail, applying principles of commercial law and statutory interpretation. Regarding the misleading representations about gross takings and profits, the court found that Audori's conduct was deceptive and misleading, as they failed to accurately reflect the true income of the business. The representation concerning the $100,000 profit was deemed not materially false or misleading as it was too vague and did not account for the expenses and obligations Canatan would incur. The express warranty breach was clear, as the figures provided for the gross takings in the warranty were proven incorrect. The failure to account for moneys received from customers was straightforward, as there was no dispute that these amounts were not accounted for by Audori. Finally, the wrongful eviction was determined based on the terms of the lease, which required Audori to provide notice before re-entering the premises. Since Canatan had not been in arrears for two months as of the date of repossession, Audori's actions were deemed wrongful. The ratio decidendi of this case is that false, misleading, or deceptive conduct in commercial transactions, breaches of express warranties, and wrongful evictions without proper notice are actionable under the Trade Practices Act and common law, respectively. The court distinguished between the types of misrepresentations and their impact on the contractual and statutory obligations of the parties.