Can Do Accounting Services Pty Ltd and Tax Practitioners Board (Practice and Procedure)

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

Can Do Accounting Services Pty Ltd and Tax Practitioners Board (Practice and Procedure) [2025] ARTA 24 (9 January 2025)

Applicant:Can Do Accounting Services Pty Ltd

Respondent:  Tax Practitioners Board

Tribunal Number:                2024/3871

Tribunal:General Member R Smith

Place:Adelaide

Date:9 January 2025

Decision:The application for a stay of the decision is refused. The interim stay order is discharged.

……………[SGND]………………………….

General Member R Smith

CATCHWORDS

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application to stay decision under review – termination of tax agent registration – whether stay necessary to secure the effectiveness of the review – whether the discretion to grant stay enlivened – stay refused – interim stay order discharged.

LEGISLATION

Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 (Cth)

The Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (Cth)

CASES

Kender v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2018] AATA 4445

Le’Sam Accounting Pty Ltd v Tax Practitioners Board [2020] AATA 890
Ridden v Tax Practitioners Board [2020] AATA 422
Scott v Australian and Securities and Investments Commission [2009] AATA 798

Statement of Reasons

INTRODUCTION

  1. On 9 May 2024, a decision was made by the Tax Practitioners Board (“the Respondent”) to terminate the tax agent registration of Can Do Accounting Services Pty Ltd (“the Applicant”, “the Company”) and to impose a two-year period during which the Applicant may not apply for registration. 

  2. The Applicant has applied for a stay of the decision of the Respondent until final determination of the review. 

  3. On 3 July 2024, the Tribunal ordered by consent that the Respondent’s decision be stayed on an interim basis until the Tribunal hears and determines the stay application or until further order. The interim stay order was made subject to a condition that the Applicant would not accept or contract with any new clients.  

  4. The Respondent opposes the stay application. 

    BACKGROUND

    Facts

  5. The following facts are uncontroversial and not disputed by the Applicant.

  6. The Company’s sole director and shareholder is Ruaidhri Carslake (Mr Carslake). On 28 May 2018, Mr Carslake, on behalf of the Applicant, applied for the Company to be registered as a tax agent. Mr Carslake in his personal capacity has never been a registered tax agent.

  7. As part of the application, the Applicant named Mr. Jeffrey Pringle (Mr Pringle) as the relevant supervising tax agent. Mr. Pringle did not work for the Company and never provided any supervisory functions.

  8. On 12 June 2018, the Applicant was registered as a tax agent. 

  9. On 26 May 2021, the Applicant lodged a tax agent registration renewal application which listed Mr Pringle and Selviana Schembari (Ms Schembari) as the supervising tax agents. The renewal application required the Applicant to make a declaration as to the truth and correctness of the information supplied.

  10. Mr Pringle was listed as a supervising tax agent for the Company between 28 May 2018 to 16 January 2024. 

  11. Ms. Schembari was listed as a supervising tax agent of the Applicant from 1 August 2019 to 31 January 2024. During this time the Applicant filed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Can Do Accounting Services Pty Ltd and Tax Practitioners Boa... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ARTA 24
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Can Do Accounting Services Pty Ltd v Tax Practitioners Board, the applicant sought a stay of the decision of the Tax Practitioners Board to terminate their tax agent registration and prohibit them from reapplying for registration for two years. The applicant argued that the termination decision should be stayed pending the outcome of the proceedings because the consequences of the termination would cause significant hardship to the applicant and the community they serve. The respondent opposed the stay application. The primary legal issues before the court were whether the Tribunal should exercise its discretion to grant a stay of the decision and, if so, on what terms. The court examined the relevant statutory provisions and case law to determine the appropriate exercise of its discretion. The court found that the onus was on the applicant to satisfy the Tribunal that a stay was desirable in the circumstances. The court considered the relevant factors, including the applicant's arguments and the respondent's findings. Ultimately, the court determined that the applicant had not satisfied the Tribunal that a stay was desirable. The court found that the applicant had made a false statement in their registration renewal application, had failed to ensure competent supervision of their tax agent services, and that the director was not a fit and proper person due to his involvement in the breaches. The court also found that the consequences of the termination for the applicant and the community, while significant, did not outweigh the importance of enforcing the statutory requirements and maintaining public trust in the tax profession. The court refused the stay application.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Respondent opposes the stay application. BACKGROUNDFacts The following facts are uncontroversial and not disputed by the Applicant. The Company’s sole director and shareholder is Ruaidhri Carslake (Mr Carslake). On 28 May 2018, Mr Carslake, on behalf of the Applicant, applied for the Company to be registered as a tax agent. Mr Carslake in his personal capacity has never been a registered tax agent. As part of the application, the Applicant named Mr. Jeffrey Pringle (Mr Pringle) as the relevant supervising tax agent. Mr. Pringle did not work for the Company and never provided any supervisory functions. On 12 June 2018, the Applicant was registered as a tax agent. On 26 May 2021, the Applicant lodged a tax agent registration renewal application which listed Mr Pringle and Selviana Schembari (Ms Schembari) as the supervising tax agents. The renewal application required the Applicant to make a declaration as to the truth and correctness of the information supplied. Mr Pringle was listed as a supervising tax agent for the Company between 28 May 2018 to 16 January 2024. Ms. Schembari was listed as a supervising tax agent of the Applicant from 1 August 2019 to 31 January 2024. During this time the Applicant filed 3790 lodgments with the Australian Taxation Office (ATO). Of those only 129 were reviewed by Ms. Schembari, the remainder were filed by Mr. Carslake on behalf of the Applicant. From 1 February 2024, Mr. Yoong Wee Low (“Mr. Low”) has been recorded as the supervising tax agent of the Applicant. On 3 June 2024, a company known as Can Do Advisory Pty Ltd was incorporated. The directors of that company are Mr. Low and Flynn Carslake - who is Mr. Carslake’s son. Can Do Advisory Pty Ltd was registered as a tax agent on 28 November 2024. On 2 December 2024, Mr. Carslake advised the Australian Taxation Office in writing that there had been a whole of practice transfer from the Applicant to Can Do Advisory Pty Ltd and that all the Applicant’s clients had agreed to become clients of the new company. The Decision Under Review The Respondent commenced an investigation following a complaint by Ms Schembari on 14 January 2024 and Mr Pringle on 16 January 2024. In broad compass, the complaints alleged the Company misrepresented to the Respondent that the Applicant had an authorised supervising agent and that the nominated agent provided supervisory functions between 2019 and 2023. By its decision dated 9 May 2024, the Respondent determined that there had been serious breaches of the Code of Professional Conduct under the Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (Cth) (the Code) by the Applicant, and that the Applicant ceased to meet the tax practitioner registration requirements under section 20-5(3)(a) of the Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (Cth) (the TASA) by virtue of the fact that the Director was no longer a fit and proper person. Each of these findings provided a basis for the Respondent to terminate the Applicant’s tax agent registration pursuant to sections 30-15(2)(d) and 40-15(1)(b) of the TASA. In addition to terminating the Applicant’s tax agent registration, the Respondent also decided, pursuant to section 40-25(1) of the TASA that the Applicant may not reapply for registration as a tax agent for two years from the date of termination.THE STATUTORY FRAMEWORK The TASA

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 2 December 2024, Mr. Carslake advised the Australian Taxation Office in writing that there had been a whole of practice transfer from the Applicant to Can Do Advisory Pty Ltd and that all the Applicant’s clients had agreed to become clients of the new company. The Decision Under Review The Respondent commenced an investigation following a complaint by Ms Schembari on 14 January 2024 and Mr Pringle on 16 January 2024. In broad compass, the complaints alleged the Company misrepresented to the Respondent that the Applicant had an authorised supervising agent and that the nominated agent provided supervisory functions between 2019 and 2023. By its decision dated 9 May 2024, the Respondent determined that there had been serious breaches of the Code of Professional Conduct under the Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (Cth) (the Code) by the Applicant, and that the Applicant ceased to meet the tax practitioner registration requirements under section 20-5(3)(a) of the Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (Cth) (the TASA) by virtue of the fact that the Director was no longer a fit and proper person. Each of these findings provided a basis for the Respondent to terminate the Applicant’s tax agent registration pursuant to sections 30-15(2)(d) and 40-15(1)(b) of the TASA. In addition to terminating the Applicant’s tax agent registration, the Respondent also decided, pursuant to section 40-25(1) of the TASA that the Applicant may not reapply for registration as a tax agent for two years from the date of termination.THE STATUTORY FRAMEWORK The TASA Section 2-5(1) of the TASA sets out the objects of the Act, namely, to support public trust and confidence in the integrity of the tax profession and system, ensuring that tax agent services are provided to the public in accordance with appropriate standards of professional and ethical conduct. This is achieved, in part, through the registration and regulation of entities that provide tax agent services by the Respondent, in conjunction with the Code for registered tax agents. For a company to be eligible for registration as a tax agent, the Respondent must be satisfied that the director is a fit and proper person.[1] In determining whether an individual is a fit and proper person, the Respondent must have regard to the matters set out in section 20-15 of the TASA which relevantly include “whether the individual is of good fame, integrity and character”.[1] Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (Cth) ("the TASA”) ss 20-5(3)(a). There is a further requirement that there be a sufficient number of individuals being registered tax agents to provide tax agent services to a competent standard and to carry out supervisory arrangements.[2] [2] Ibid ss 20-5(3)(d). These provisions are supported by the Code, which includes an obligation that a registered tax agent “must act honestly and with integrity”.[3][3] Ibid ss 30-10(1). The Respondent is empowered by Subdivision E of the TASA to undertake an investigation into conduct that may be in breach of the Act.[4] Upon completion of an investigation, if the Respondent finds the conduct breaches the Act, the Respondent must either make a decision to take no further action or to do one or more of items set out in subsection 60-125(2)(b). This extends to one or more of the sanctions under the Subdivision 30-B of the TASA, which include, but are not limited to: a caution, suspension of a tax agent’s registration and termination of the tax agent’s registration.[5] [4] More specifically section 60-95.[5] Section 30-15 of the TASA.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The onus of satisfying the Tribunal that a stay is desirable in the circumstances lies with the Applicant.CONSIDERATION OF FACTORSThe Respondent’s Findings The Respondent was satisfied on the balance of probabilities that the Applicant:a. breached the Code by:i.failing to act honestly and with integrity. In particular, the Applicant made a false or misleading statement in the application for renewal of tax agent registration lodged with the Board on 26 May 2012, by listing Mr Pringle as the supervising agent in circumstances where Mr Pringle never performed any services as a supervising agent for the Company; andii.failing to ensure that tax agent services provided by or on behalf the Company, were provided competently. More specifically, that between 1 August 2019 and 31 January 2024 there were no supervisory arrangements. During this period 3661 unsupervised lodgements were made by the Applicant. b. ceased to meet the tax practitioner registration requirement under paragraph 20-5(3)(a) of the TASA on the basis that the Director was not a fit and proper person as a consequence of:i.him facilitating the conduct that caused the Applicant to breach the Code (which they concluded demonstrated that Mr Carslake was not of good fame, integrity and character);ii.him personally preparing the lodgements without a tax agent registration or under the supervision of an appropriately authorised supervising agent;iii.that Mr Carslake knew or ought to have known that failing to understand or meet his obligations under the TASA would fall short of the expectations required by a sole director of a company; and iv.that Mr Carslake holds a position of influence and trust in a small community.The Applicant’s case The Applicant filed a very lengthy document with the Tribunal on 16 December 2024[13] and Mr. Carslake gave evidence at the interlocutory hearing. The contentions of the Applicant distilled from the material and evidence can be summarised as follows: [13] Exhibit A1: Applicant’s Bundle of Documents.·Mr Pringle was included in the application for registration as a tax agent by the Applicant as the supervising tax agent with his permission. However, he shortly thereafter decided not to join the Company. The Applicant admits that Mr Pringle never worked for the Company and was never a supervising tax agent. ·Mr Carslake acknowledged that Mr Pringle should have been removed as the supervising tax agent once it became apparent he was not going to be working for the Company and he should not have been included as part of the renewal application. However, at the time, he did not appreciate that he was required to advise the Respondent of any change in circumstance and the inclusion of Mr. Pringle in the renewal registration application was as a result of an oversight.·Mr. Carslake was aware that he needed to replace Mr. Pringle as a supervising tax agent of the Applicant. He advertised for registered tax agents through “Seek” and from this process he hired four registered tax agents including Ms. Schembari and Ms. Kelly Felter who registered herself as supervising agent of the Company for the duration of her employment.·At all times the Company employed registered tax agents who provided services to the clients of the Applicant, although the registration details of the Applicant did not always reflect this. Mr. Carslake acknowledged in his evidence that he did not fully appreciate the extent of his and the Applicant’s obligations in this regard, but had he done so he would have complied with them.·Ms Schembari had agreed from her commencement with the Company in 2019 to be a supervising agent for the Company. The Applicant did not advise the Respondent of this arrangement until the renewal application was lodged in 2021. ·Although no formal processes were in place, Ms Schembari did have unlimited access to the software used by the Applicant and could therefore access all the lodgements made on behalf of the Company. Ms Schembari and Mr Carslake spoke regularly, and Mr Carslake asserted she had confidence in his abilities and that he would seek her advice as required.·Ms Schembari and Mr Carslake initially had a close and trusted working relationship and were exploring partnership opportunities. The complaint lodged by Ms Schembari was precipitated by a breakdown in their personal and professional relationship during which Mr. and Ms Schembari engaged in conduct designed to undermine the Applicant’s and Mr Carslake’s reputation. This conduct has caused considerable harm to Mr Carslake and his family.·Prior to setting up the Company, Mr. Carslake worked under the supervision of a registered tax agent. This experience shaped what he thought was an appropriate level of supervision. He recounted that in that role not every lodgment was personally reviewed by the supervisor and some supervisory tasks were delegated to trusted colleagues.·Mr. Carslake stated in his evidence that the supervision provided by Ms Schembari was consistent with his past experience and that she was also comfortable with the arrangements until the break down in the relationship. He now, however, recognises the supervision provided was inadequate and has since implemented a more rigorous supervision process by Mr Low.·If the Tribunal were to refuse the stay application, in addition to the consequences to Mr. Carslake personally (in particular to his mental and physical health, financial position, damage to his reputation and potential further harassment by Mr. Schembari), there would be consequences for the community given the limited tax agent services currently provided to the community and his involvement in broader community activities.