Camozzato v Stansfield & Ors No. DCCIV-97-803 Judgment No. D137

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

Sandra CAMOZZATO  v  Arthur STANSFIELD, Serena PACE,
David JOHNSON, Nicholas BIRDSEYE,
Elbio PEREZ and King of Croissant Pty Ltd
[1999] SADC 137

Civil
Judge Kitchen

1 At the time of the events which give rise to this action the plaintiff was nearly 21 years old.  She had left school during Year 10, completed a six months secretarial course in 1991 and then obtained work involving typing, telephonist and reception duties, including some book-keeping, in a position she held for about four years.  During the last six months of that period of employment, the plaintiff obtained part-time work in the evening at Caf_ Va Bene a restaurant of 160 seating capacity.  At the end of the six months she took up full-time work at that caf_ and that was her employment at the time of the events the subject of this action; by that time, the plaintiff described, she was in the role of supervisor of the twenty or so persons employed there and also, as I understand her evidence, controlled the "front of shop" activities of the business.
2 In the latter part of 1996 the plaintiff sought to purchase the Caf_ Va Bene from the proprietor, a company effectively controlled by Mr and Mrs Delorso, both of whom worked in the caf_ as cooks or chefs.  In connection with her efforts to purchase the caf_, the plaintiff was introduced to the first defendant Stansfield who, it is agreed for the purposes of these proceedings, conducted the business Solution Partners a commercial managerial consultant providing, as he described in evidence, "commercial advice in relation to restructuring, re-financing, equity partnerships etc".  For reasons which appear later, the plaintiff's plan to purchase Caf_ Va Bene did not proceed, but through Stansfield the plaintiff was then presented with the opportunity to purchase, what I will for the moment call, the business of the sixth defendant, King of Croissant Pty Ltd, (which was effectively controlled by the fifth defendant Perez) known as the Caf_ King of Croissant.  In connection with that purchase, the plaintiff engaged the services of Johnson Lawyers, as her solicitor, the proprietor of which was the third-named defendant, Johnson, by whom the second-named defendant Pace was employed as a solicitor and who provided legal services to the plaintiff.  The fourth-named defendant Birdseye is an accountant, who provided services to the plaintiff concerning the purchase of Caf_ King of Croissant.
3 The plaintiff claims:-
.    that Stansfield acted as her agent in the purchase of the Caf_ King of Croissant, that he was in beach of his contractual duties to the plaintiff as her agent, that he was negligent and he was also in breach of fiduciary duties he owed to the plaintiff;

.    that the defendants Pace and Johnson were in breach of their duties as the plaintiff's solicitor, and further that the defendant Pace was in breach of fiduciary duties she owed to the plaintiff;
.    that the defendant Birdseye received from the plaintiff $25,000, part of the price for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Camozzato v Stansfield & Ors No. DCCIV-97-803 Judgment No. D... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] SADC 137
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Sandra Camozzato commenced proceedings against Arthur Stansfield, Serena Pace, David Johnson, Nicholas Birdseye, Elbio Perez and King of Croissant Pty Ltd, seeking damages for breach of fiduciary duty, negligence and misrepresentation in relation to a contract for the sale of a business. The defendants denied liability and Stansfield counterclaimed for $21,000 as a fee. The primary issue was whether the defendants breached their fiduciary duties or acted negligently, causing the plaintiff to suffer loss. The court found that Stansfield breached his fiduciary duties by making misrepresentations and misappropriating the plaintiff's funds. Pace was also found to be in breach of her fiduciary duties to the plaintiff for failing to properly advise her. The court held that the plaintiff was entitled to damages for the breach of fiduciary duties, as well as for negligence. The plaintiff was awarded $38,238 in damages, and the defendants were ordered to contribute to the judgment in proportion to their liability. The court also dismissed Stansfield's counterclaim for fees.

The court found that Stansfield breached his fiduciary duties by misrepresenting the financial position of the business the plaintiff intended to purchase and misappropriating the plaintiff's funds. Pace was found to be in breach of her fiduciary duties for failing to properly advise the plaintiff and for having a conflict of interest due to her relationship with Stansfield. The court held that the plaintiff was entitled to damages for the breach of fiduciary duties and for negligence. The court awarded the plaintiff $38,238 in damages and ordered the defendants to contribute to the judgment in proportion to their liability. The court also dismissed Stansfield's counterclaim for fees. The parties were to be heard on the question of costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established