Camilleri and Repatriation Commission (Veterans’ entitlements)

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

Camilleri and Repatriation Commission (Veterans’ entitlements) [2015] AATA 822 (26 October 2015)

Division

VETERANS' APPEALS DIVISION

File Number

2014/5435

Re

Paul Camilleri

APPLICANT

And

Repatriation Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Senior Member A C Cotter

Date 26 October 2015
Place Brisbane

The decision under review is affirmed.

..................................[Sgd]......................................

Senior Member A C Cotter

CATCHWORDS

VETERANS’ AFFAIRS – disability pension – operational service – depressive disorder – alcohol abuse – whether defence caused – causal connection required – whether Depressive Disorder SoP upholds contention – “persistent pain” relevant factor – evidence to the contrary – medical reports suggest pain not interfering with work or leisure activities – Depressive Disorder SoP not satisfied – whether Alcohol Abuse SoP upholds contention – whether clinically significant psychiatric condition at relevant time – requirement not met – not service related and not defence-caused – decision under review affirmed.

LEGISLATION

Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth), ss 70(5), 120(4), 120B(3),196B(3)

CASES

Roncevich v Repatriation Commission (2005) 222 CLR 115

Repatriation Commission v Gorton (2001) 65 ALD 609

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Statement of Principles concerning Depressive Disorder (Instrument No. 84 of 2015)

Statement of Principles concerning Depressive Disorder (Instrument No. 28 of 2008)

Statement of Principles concerning Alcohol Dependence and Alcohol Abuse (Instrument No. 2 of 2009)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member A C Cotter

26 October 2015

INTRODUCTION

  1. Mr Paul Camilleri served in the Australian Army from 6 August 1974 to 12 December 1994. He rendered eligible defence service for the whole of that period.

  2. In July 2012, Mr Camilleri lodged a claim for disability pension for depressive disorder and alcohol abuse, neither of which had previously been accepted as service related. In his application form, it was stated that the depressive illness was the result of chronic pain that he had experienced for a long time, and that the alcohol abuse was associated with that depressive illness and chronic pain.[1]

    [1] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T 6, pages 15-17.

  3. On 18 June 2013, the Commission decided that the depressive disorder and alcohol abuse were not related to service.[2] The Veterans’ Review Board subsequently affirmed that decision.[3]  Dissatisfied with that decision, Mr Camilleri seeks a review of that decision by this Tribunal.

    [2] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T 17, pages 61-65.

    [3] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T 2, pages B1-B7.

  4. Before dealing with the issues raised in this matter, it is convenient to outline the key legislative provisions which are relevant to my determination.

    THE LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK

  5. Section 70 of the Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth) (“Act”) deals with, amongst other things, the eligibility for pensions where a member of the Forces is incapacitated from a defence-caused injury or defence-caused disease. In particular, s 70(5) relevantly provides that an injury suffered by a member of the Forces shall be taken to be a defence-caused injury, or a disease contracted by such a member shall be taken to be a defence-caused disease if:

    a)    the … injury or disease, as the case may be, arose out of, or was attributable…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Camilleri and Repatriation Commission (Veterans’ entitlement... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] AATA 822
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Camilleri and Repatriation Commission (Veterans’ Entitlements) involved the applicant, Mr Camilleri, seeking a review of a decision by the Repatriation Commission denying his claim for a disability pension related to depressive disorder and alcohol abuse. The case was heard in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). Mr Camilleri argued that his depressive disorder and alcohol abuse were caused by his operational service, entitling him to a pension under the relevant legislative framework.

The primary legal issues revolved around whether Mr Camilleri’s depressive disorder and alcohol abuse were service-related and defence-caused, as required by the applicable Statements of Principles (SoPs). Specifically, the tribunal had to determine if the Depressive Disorder SoP and the Alcohol Abuse SoP were satisfied. These SoPs outline the conditions and factors necessary to link a psychiatric condition or alcohol abuse to operational service. The tribunal needed to assess if Mr Camilleri's conditions met the criteria stipulated in these SoPs.

In examining the evidence, the tribunal found that while Mr Camilleri had a diagnosed depressive disorder and alcohol abuse, these conditions did not meet the criteria set out in the relevant SoPs. The Depressive Disorder SoP requires that the relevant factors of the disorder be service-related, and the tribunal concluded that this was not the case for Mr Camilleri. Similarly, the Alcohol Abuse SoP requires that the alcohol abuse be linked to a clinically significant psychiatric condition at the relevant time, a requirement that was also not met. As such, the tribunal held that neither condition was service-related or defence-caused, affirming the original decision of the Repatriation Commission.

The tribunal's decision was affirmed, and Mr Camilleri's claim for a disability pension was denied. This outcome was based on the tribunal's determination that neither the Depressive Disorder SoP nor the Alcohol Abuse SoP was satisfied, as the evidence did not establish a causal connection between his conditions and his service.

Orders

Orders of the court

The decision under review is affirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

While Dr Holm provided a diagnosis that would fall within this description, that needs to be viewed (in accordance with s 8) in the context of the Depressive Disorder SoP, as the relevant factors include a disease which itself is the subject of a SoP. I have already concluded that, by reference to the Depressive Disorder SoP, the relevant psychiatric condition is not service related. Therefore, I do not believe that the requirements of this SoP are met, in that the relevant factors here are similarly not service related, as required by s 7. Consequently, Mr Camilleri’s contention is not upheld by the Alcohol Abuse SoP.CONCLUSION For the reasons outlined above, I do not believe that either of Mr Camilleri’s conditions, Depressive Disorder and Alcohol Abuse, are upheld by the relevant SoPs. They are therefore not service related and not defence-caused. The reviewable decision is therefore affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In deciding those issues, I will need to consider the Statement of Principles concerning Depressive Disorder (Instrument No. 84 of 2015) (“Depressive Disorder SoP”) and the Statement of Principles concerning Alcohol Dependence and Alcohol Abuse (Instrument No. 2 of 2009) (“Alcohol Abuse SoP”), which are the relevant Statements of Principles in force at the time of this decision. As it is open to Mr Camilleri to rely on the Statement of Principles which preceded the Depressive Disorder SoP and which was in force at the time of the Commission’s decision,[8] I will also refer to it (Instrument No. 28 of 2008).[8] Repatriation Commission v Gorton (2001) 65 ALD 609.CONSIDERATION I deal below with the two conditions claimed by Mr Camilleri, namely Depressive Disorder and Alcohol Dependence, by reference to the matters required to be considered under s 120B(3).Depressive DisorderConnection between the injury/disease and service? Mr Camilleri’s previously accepted condition are:(a)rupture medial meniscus and anterior cruciate ligament, left knee;(b)lumbar spondylosis; and(c)osteoarthritis of the left knee.[9]There was a considerable amount of medical evidence produced to the Tribunal which verified those conditions.[9] Exhibit 1, Veteran Community Details Report printed 27 October 2014. In his statement lodged in these proceedings, Mr Camilleri gave a history of his knee and back complaints.[10][10] Exhibit 5, statement of Paul Camilleri (undated). He first suffered an injury to his left knee in 1978 in an Australian Rules football game during a sports afternoon at Wacol in Brisbane, where he was then based. His statement records his leg getting worse over time from physical training, exercises and battle efficient tests, and his regular work. He started to experience his knee locking on different occasions and suffer chronic pain to the leg. Initially, he was treated with physiotherapy and Panadeine Forte, before having an X-ray in November 1980. That led to him having an arthroscopy in February 1981, followed by surgery in April 1981. Over the ensuing years, he continued to experience problems and pain with his knee, having a number operations before undergoing a total knee replacement a few months before the hearing.[11][11] See Exhibit 5, statement of Paul Camilleri (undated) and Exhibit 6, AAT telephone conference February 2015. In 1989, Mr Camilleri first experienced pain to his lower back when he dismounted his truck incorrectly. He first attributed this to his bending down and loading and unloading stores over time, but was subsequently referred to a specialist after he continued to experience back pain. He was told to do swimming and to have physiotherapy. While consulting a specialist about the constant pain in his left leg which was becoming “unbearable”, he also saw another specialist for his chronic back pain which he had been experiencing more frequently. A CT scan revealed that he had major back problems that needed fixing before his knee operation. He therefore underwent a spinal fusion operation in 1993. Following that surgery, he was diagnosed with 20% loss of use of his back.[12][12] See Exhibit 5, statement of Paul Camilleri (undated).