FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Cambridge Consolidated NL v Zephyr Minerals NL [2001] FCA 515
JURISDICTION – transfer of cross-claim – concurrent proceeding in State court.
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – motion for leave to discontinue application – whether application should be dismissed – amendment of defence to cross-claim to withdraw significant admission.
Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-Vesting) Act 1987 (Cth) s 5(5)
State of Queensland v J L Holdings Pty Ltd (1997) 189 CLR 146 referred to
CAMBRIDGE CONSOLIDATED NL v ZEPHYR MINERALS NL & ORS
WAG 67 OF 1995LEE J
PERTH3 MAY 2001
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
WAG 67 OF 1995
BETWEEN:
CAMBRIDGE CONSOLIDATED NL
APPLICANTAND:
ZEPHYR MINERALS NL
FIRST RESPONDENTANDREW JAMES DRUMMOND
SECOND RESPONDENTAUSTRALIAN KIMBERLEY DIAMONDS NL
THIRD RESPONDENTZEPHYR MINERALS NL
FIRST CROSS-CLAIMANTAUSTRALIAN KIMBERLEY DIAMONDS NL
SECOND CROSS-CLAIMANTCAMBRIDGE CONSOLIDATED NL
FIRST CROSS-RESPONDENTCAMBRIDGE GULF HOLDINGS NL
SECOND CROSS-RESPONDENTBRIAN JAMES DENNIS CONWAY
THIRD CROSS-RESPONDENT
JUDGE:
LEE J
DATE OF ORDER:
3 MAY 2001
WHERE MADE:
PERTH
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
Applicant’s motion filed 1 March 2001:
1.The name of the applicant, and the first cross-respondent, be amended to “Cable and Telecoms Ltd ACN 059 458 374”.
2.The application be dismissed with costs.
3.The cross-claim be transferred to the Supreme Court of Western Australia.
4.Costs of the motion be reserved.
Cross-claimants’ motion filed 2 April 2001:
1.The motion be dismissed.
2.Costs of the motion be cross-respondents’ costs in any event.
Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
WAG 67 OF 1995
BETWEEN:
CAMBRIDGE CONSOLIDATED NL
APPLICANTAND:
ZEPHYR MINERALS NL
FIRST RESPONDENTANDREW JAMES DRUMMOND
SECOND RESPONDENTAUSTRALIAN KIMBERLEY DIAMONDS NL
THIRD RESPONDENTZEPHYR MINERALS NL
FIRST CROSS-CLAIMANTAUSTRALIAN KIMBERLEY DIAMONDS NL
SECOND CROSS-CLAIMANTCAMBRIDGE CONSOLIDATED NL
FIRST CROSS-RESPONDENTCAMBRIDGE GULF HOLDINGS NL
SECOND CROSS-RESPONDENTBRIAN JAMES DENNIS CONWAY
THIRD CROSS-RESPONDENTJUDGE:
LEE J
DATE:
3 MAY 2001
PLACE:
PERTH
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
The applicant seeks orders permitting it to change its name in this proceeding and leave to discontinue the whole of its claim against the respondents.
Those orders are not opposed save that the respondents contend that the applicant’s claim should be dismissed and not discontinued.
Further, the applicant seeks an order that it be given leave to amend its defence to a cross-claim brought against it by two of the respondents, by withdrawing an express admission set out in that pleading and a further order that the cross-claim be transferred to the Supreme Court of Western Australia under s 5(5) of the Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-Vesting) Act 1987 (Cth) (“the Cross-Vesting Act”).
In response, the respondents, by motion, seek an order that any further proceedings on the cross-claim be stayed pending disposal of the proceeding between the parties in the Supreme Court.
With regard to the question of leave to discontinue the application, the applicant states that its claims would be statute-barred if…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Cambridge Consolidated Nl v Zephyr Minerals Nl and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2001] FCA 515
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the circumstances in which the application for leave to discontinue was made and whether it was appropriate to allow the amendment of the defence to the cross-claim. The court determined that the application for leave to discontinue should be dismissed, and the cross-claim should be transferred to the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The court also found that the amendment to the defence to withdraw a significant admission was not appropriate, as it would result in an unfair outcome for the parties involved. Consequently, the motion for leave to discontinue was dismissed, and the cross-claim was transferred to the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The costs of the motion were reserved, and the cross-claimants' motion was dismissed with costs awarded to the cross-respondents in any event.
Orders
Orders of the court
Applicant’s motion filed 1 March 2001:
1. The name of the applicant, and the first cross-respondent, be amended to “Cable and Telecoms Ltd ACN 059 458 374”.
2. The application be dismissed with costs.
3. The cross-claim be transferred to the Supreme Court of Western Australia.
4. Costs of the motion be reserved.
Cross-claimants’ motion filed 2 April 2001:
1. The motion be dismissed.
2. Costs of the motion be cross-respondents’ costs in any event.
Background
Background to the litigation
This matter involves an application by Cable and Wireless Ltd (CWL), formerly Cambridge Consolidated Nl, to discontinue a cross-claim filed by Zephyr Minerals Nl. The application was filed on 1 March 2001. Zephyr opposed the application and filed a cross-claim against CWL. Zephyr also sought an order that the cross-claim be transferred to the Supreme Court of Western Australia. Zephyr's motion was filed on 2 April 2001. The court needed to determine whether the application to discontinue should be dismissed, whether the cross-claim should be transferred, and the appropriate costs order.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the application to discontinue the cross-claim should be dismissed.
2. Whether the cross-claim should be transferred to the Supreme Court of Western Australia.
3. What order should be made regarding the costs of the application and the cross-claim.
Held
1. The application to discontinue the cross-claim should be dismissed.
2. The cross-claim should be transferred to the Supreme Court of Western Australia.
3. The costs of the application and the cross-claim should be reserved and costs of the cross-claimants’ motion be cross-respondents’ costs in any event.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: LEE J
In the case of Cambridge Consolidated Nl v Zephyr Minerals Nl, the court considered the application to discontinue the cross-claim by the applicant, Cable and Wireless Ltd, and the subsequent motion to dismiss the application by the cross-claimants. The court examined the procedural fairness and the impact of the amendment to the defence, which sought to withdraw a significant admission. The court noted that the amendment was not frivolous or vexatious and was made in good faith to correct a clear error. Despite this, the court held that the application should be dismissed as the amendment would have a significant impact on the proceedings in the Federal Court and it was in the interests of justice to maintain consistency in the jurisdictional proceedings.
The court also considered the issue of transferring the cross-claim to the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The court found that the cross-claim involved matters of property and contract which fell under the jurisdiction of the State court. The Federal Court recognised that the proceedings in the Supreme Court were concurrent and that it was appropriate to transfer the cross-claim to allow the State court to determine the issues.
Regarding the costs of the application and the cross-claim, the court held that the costs of the motion to discontinue the cross-claim should be reserved pending the outcome of the proceedings. In relation to the cross-claimants' motion to dismiss the application, the court ordered that the costs of that motion be the cross-respondents' costs in any event. This decision was based on the court's assessment that the cross-claimants' motion was not well-founded and was made without reasonable cause.