Camarda (by her Litigation Guardian) v Allen (Trustee)

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Camarda (by her Litigation Guardian) v Allen (Trustee) [2025] FCA 1162

Appeal from: Application for extension of time and leave to appeal:  Allen (Trustee), in the matter of Camarda (Bankrupt) v Camarda [2024] FedCFamC2G 1238
File number: WAD 349 of 2024
Judgment of: JACKSON J
Date of judgment: 19 September 2025
Date of publication of reasons: 22 September 2025
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - application by litigation representative for approval of settlement - consideration of relevant factors for approval of settlement - best interests of a person under disability - independent legal opinion - settlement approved
Legislation:

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) ss 139ZQ, 139ZR, 139ZS

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 37AF, 37AG, 37AJ

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 1.34, 4.12, 9.63, 9.70, 9.71

Guardianship and Administration Act 1990 (WA)

Cases cited:

James v WorkPower Inc [2019] FCA 1239

Lewis v The State of Victoria (Department of Education and Training) [2019] FCA 714

Modra v State of Victoria (Department of Human Services Victoria & Department of Education and Early Childhood Development) [2013] FCA 1041

Scandolera v State of Victoria [2015] FCA 1451

Wade v State of Victoria (No 2) [2012] FCA 1080

West (by his litigation representative Toms) v State of Victoria (Department of Education and Training) [2024] FCA 871

Young v State of Victoria (Department of Education and Training) [2018] FCA 1124

Division: General Division
Registry: Western Australia
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: General and Personal Insolvency
Number of paragraphs: 36
Date of hearing: 19 September 2025
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr N Lucarelli KC with Mr J Paterson (pro bono)
Solicitor for the Appellant: Blackwall Legal LLP (pro bono)
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr N Ayliffe
Solicitor for the Respondent: KHQ Lawyers

ORDERS

WAD 349 of 2024
BETWEEN:

FRANCESCA CAMARDA (BY HER LITIGATION GUARDIAN)

Appellant

AND:

PAUL ANTHONY ALLEN (IN HIS CAPACITY AS TRUSTEE OF THE BANKRUPT ESTATE OF MARIA CAMARDA)

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JACKSON J

DATE OF ORDER:

19 SEPTEMBER 2025

THE COURT NOTES THAT:

A.The parties have agreed to a settlement of the proceeding and the disputes connected with it on the terms of a Deed of Settlement and Release dated 14 July 2025 executed by the litigation guardian of the appellant and by the respondent (Settlement).

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Pursuant to r 1.34 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), for the purposes of the application for approval of the Settlement, compliance with the requirement in r 9.71(2)(c) of the Rules is dispensed with.

2.Pursuant to r 9.70 of the Federal Court Rules, the Settlement (as set out in the Deed of Settlement and Release appearing at pages 6 to 29 of annexure EMC4 to the affidavit of Elena Maria Collica filed 16 September 2025 is approved.

3.Subject to paragraph 4 below, pursuant to s 37AF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), for a period of three years from the date of this order the affidavit of Gabrielle…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Camarda (by her Litigation Guardian) v Allen (Trustee) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FCA 1162
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Francesca Camarda, represented by her litigation guardian, Elena Maria Collica, sought the approval of a settlement agreement in a legal dispute against the respondent, Allen, the trustee of a bankrupt estate. The dispute arose from a notice issued under the Bankruptcy Act 1966, which sought payment of $783,200 from Mrs Camarda, related to a property transfer involving her daughter, Maria Camarda. The central issue before the court was whether the settlement agreement was in the best interests of Mrs Camarda, who is under a legal disability due to her advanced age and health conditions.

The court considered the factors necessary for approving the settlement, including the independent legal opinion provided by Mr Lucarelli and Mr Paterson, which concluded that the settlement was in Mrs Camarda's best interests and represented a reasonable compromise. The court acknowledged the importance of independent legal advice in such cases and gave considerable weight to the comprehensive and reasoned opinion of the lawyers. The court also noted the potential for significant ongoing litigation if the settlement was not approved, and the potential distress and expense this could cause to Mrs Camarda.

The court approved the settlement, considering the comprehensive opinion and the context of Mrs Camarda's health and age. The court made orders to ensure the confidentiality of the legal opinion and to prevent its disclosure to the other party. The court also allowed for the disclosure of the opinion to the State Administrative Tribunal of Western Australia to the extent necessary for proceedings concerning Mrs Camarda's affairs. No order was made regarding the costs of the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to r 1.34 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), for the purposes of the application for approval of the Settlement, compliance with the requirement in r 9.71(2)(c) of the Rules is dispensed with.

2. Pursuant to r 9.70 of the Federal Court Rules, the Settlement (as set out in the Deed of Settlement and Release appearing at pages 6 to 29 of annexure EMC4 to the affidavit of Elena Maria Collica filed 16 September 2025 is approved.

3. Subject to paragraph 4 below, pursuant to s 37AF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), for a period of three years from the date of this order the affidavit of Gabrielle Lindsay filed 15 September 2025 (including annexures) (Confidential Affidavit) is to be treated as confidential to the appellant and until further order:

(a) will be marked as confidential to the appellant on the Court's electronic court file; and

(b) will not be available for public inspection, disclosed in open court or disclosed in the open part of any court transcript.

4. The appellant (by her litigation guardian) may disclose the terms of the Confidential Affidavit to the State Administrative Tribunal of Western Australia, to the extent necessary in any proceeding concerning the administration of the affairs of the appellant pursuant to the Guardianship and Administration Act 1990 (WA).

5. There is no order as to the costs of and incidental to the application for approval of the Settlement.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an application to approve the terms of a settlement of the proceeding on behalf of the appellant, who is under a legal incapacity.Background The appellant, Francesca Camarda, is 91 years old. Mrs Camarda received a minimal primary school education in Sicily before she emigrated to Australia at the age of 16. She cannot read or write in English. She married her husband, Francesco Camarda, shortly after emigrating. Mrs Camarda is in poor physical health and suffers from dementia. She has lived in her home in Michael Street, Beaconsfield (Property), for over 35 years. During that time Mr Camarda passed away, and in 2022 Mrs Camarda also experienced the sudden death of a son. In October 2016, a sequestration order was made over the estate of one of Mrs Camarda's daughters, Maria Camarda. On 12 October 2022, the Official Receiver issued a notice under s 139ZQ of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) seeking payment of $783,200 to the bankrupt estate. The background to the notice, which needs only be sketched broadly, is that in 1999, Mrs Camarda allegedly transferred the Property to Maria Camarda, subject to an estate for life. In October 2015, Maria Camarda allegedly transferred the Property back to Mrs Camarda for no monetary consideration. By the s 139ZQ notice, Maria Camarda's trustee in bankruptcy, the respondent Mr Allen (Trustee), claimed that the 2015 transfer was void as against the Trustee, because it was at an undervalue and for the purpose of defeating Maria Camarda's creditors. There is a dispute about whether either of these transfers was legally ineffective due to fraud, and also a dispute about whether Mrs Camarda understood either transaction. Assuming the s 139ZQ notice was served on Mrs Camarda, its effect would have been to require her to pay the sum claimed, and also to create a charge of the Property in favour of the Trustee, giving him a power of sale: s 139ZQ(8) and s 139ZR. If Mrs Camarda wanted to avoid those consequences, it was incumbent on her to apply to a court under s 139ZS to set the notice aside. There is in fact a dispute about whether the s 139ZQ notice was ever served on her. At any rate, no application to set the notice aside was made. On 1 November 2024, a judge of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (Circuit Court) heard an application by the Trustee, relying on the s 139ZQ notice, for Mrs Camarda to be required to vacate the Property so that it could be sold. Mrs Camarda had no legal representation and did not appear at the hearing, although there was correspondence before the Court seeking an adjournment of the hearing on the basis of Mrs Camarda's health and difficulties that had been experienced in obtaining legal representation. Also before the Circuit Court was an email from the pro bono clearing house Law Access WA, saying that it could not organise legal assistance for Mrs Camarda because, after speaking to her on the telephone with an interpreter, Law Access could not be sure that Mrs Camarda could understand the service it provided and the legal issue confronting her. Law Access understood that the Circuit Court had invited an application for the appointment of a litigation guardian to represent Mrs Camarda in the Circuit Court proceeding. The Circuit Court was informed that Mrs Camarda's family was in the process of applying to have a guardian appointed for her.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court benefits from the lawyer's opinion, which is expected to be based on full access to relevant facts and evidence. But it is not obliged to agree with the opinion, and may still reject a settlement, even when the opinion supports it: see Scandolera at [28]. In the ordinary case, however, it is appropriate for the Court to give considerable weight to the assessment of the applicant's legal advisers, provided the opinion is seen to be independent and objective: Wade at [6]; Modra at [12]; Young at [12].Consideration The evidence filed on behalf of Mrs Camarda includes an affidavit of Ms Collica setting out the material facts and an affidavit of Mrs Camarda's solicitor attaching the Deed. The summary of the terms of settlement set out above is taken from the Deed. The solicitor's affidavit also attaches a copy of a written opinion of Mr Lucarelli and Mr Paterson dated 12 September 2025, to the effect that the settlement recorded in the Deed is for the benefit of Mrs Camarda, is in her best interests, and represents a reasonable compromise of the issues in the primary proceeding and this appeal. Ms Collica seeks an order that the opinion be treated as confidential to her and is not to be disclosed or publicly available. This is on the basis that it is provided in order to assist the Court in exercising its supervisory jurisdiction but, since it is possible that the settlement is not approved, that purpose is likely to be defeated if the opinion could become available to the Trustee as the other party to the litigation. The Trustee does not oppose this order. I am satisfied on the basis just outlined that it is necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice to protect the confidentiality of the opinion in the manner proposed: see e.g. James v WorkPower Inc [2019] FCA 1239 at [18] (Mortimer J). Orders to that effect will be made under s 37AF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), on the ground specified in s 37AG(1)(a). The duration of the order needs to be specified in it: s 37AJ. Three years is appropriate. The opinion of Mr Lucarelli and Mr Paterson is comprehensive, detailed and closely reasoned. My assessment is that it approaches the question from the perspective of an independent consideration of what is in Mrs Camarda's best interests. In the context of a matter of this kind, including the sum of money at stake, it is appropriate to dispense with the requirement of r 9.71(2)(c) of the Federal Court Rules. In view of the confidentiality order, it is appropriate not to disclose very much about the contents of the opinion. Suffice to say that I give it considerable weight in reaching the view that the settlement recorded in the Deed is indeed in Mrs Camarda's best interests. The circumstances set out at the beginning of this judgment provide important context for considering whether the settlement is in Mrs Camarda's best interests. While there may be some merit in the appeal, the reality is that without the settlement, it will still be open to the Trustee, in performance of his duties, to pursue enforcement of the judgment of the Circuit Court or, if that were to be set aside, to pursue the same outcome through other means. That would likely to produce significant ongoing litigation.