Reported Decision: 174 LGERA 446
New South Wales
Court of Appeal
CITATION: Calardu Penrith Pty Ltd v Penrith City Council & Anor [2010] NSWCA 189
This decision has been amended. Please see the end of the judgment for a list of the amendments.HEARING DATE(S): 26 July 2010, 27 July 2010
JUDGMENT DATE:
6 August 2010JUDGMENT OF: Hodgson JA at 1; Tobias JA at 7; McColl JA at 80 DECISION: Appeal dismissed with costs CATCHWORDS: ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING – development control – consent – whether Council acted ultra vires in purporting to grant development consent – whether development had capital investment value exceeding $10 million – whether tenancy fit-out costs included in determination of capital investment value LEGISLATION CITED: Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979
Environmental Planning and Assessment Regulation 2000
State Environmental Planning Policy (Major Development) 2005CATEGORY: Principal judgment CASES CITED: Calardu Penrith Pty Ltd v Pipven Pty Ltd [2009] NSWLEC 119 PARTIES: Calardu Penrith Pty Ltd
Penrith City Council
Pipven Pty LimitedFILE NUMBER(S): CA 2010/107056 COUNSEL: A: A Galasso SC / M Wright
1R: J Robson SC / A Stafford
2R: J Griffiths SC/M Allars (Ms)SOLICITORS: A: Mallesons Stephen Jaques, Sydney
1R: Sparke Helmore, Sydney
2R: Norton Rose Australia, SydneyLOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Land & Environment Court LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S): L&E 40913/09 LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER: Biscoe J LOWER COURT DATE OF DECISION: 1 April 2010 LOWER COURT MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: Calardu Penrith Pty Ltd v Penrith City Council [2010] NSWLEC 50
CA 2010/107056
L&E 40913/2009Friday 6 August 2010HODGSON JA
TOBIAS JA
McCOLL JA
1 HODGSON JA: I agree with the orders proposed by Tobias JA and I agree with his reasons. I would add the following.
2 In support of his contentions concerning Question 1 considered by Tobias JA, Mr Galasso SC for Calardu advanced the following argument:
- (1) Under the Penrith Local Environmental Plan 1996 (Industrial Land) (the LEP), “shops trading principally in bulky goods” (with certain limitations) was a land use for a purpose for which development may be carried out only with development consent, while (with certain exceptions not here relevant) other “shops” was a land use for a purpose for which development was prohibited: see cl 9 of the LEP (Blue 26-27) and Zone No 4(b) (Blue 28-30).
(2) This development was consented to and thus was permissible only as a development for the purpose of shops trading principally in bulky goods.
(3) Therefore, what was necessary to “establish and operate the development” (within the definition of “capital investment value” in cl 3(2)(a) of the State Environmental Planning Policy (Major Development) 2005 (the SEPP)) was what was necessary to establish and operate it as bulky goods shops.
(4) Therefore, the costs necessary to establish and operate the development for this permissible purpose must include the costs necessary for the bulky goods shops to operate.
3 The development application made it clear that the consent…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Calardu Penrith Pty Ltd v Penrith City Council and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2010] NSWCA 189
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the Council had the authority to grant development consent for the project. This required the court to determine the correct interpretation of the relevant provisions of the *Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979* (NSW) concerning the threshold for capital investment value that dictates whether a development requires ministerial approval or can be determined by the local council. Specifically, the court had to decide whether the costs of a tenancy fit-out were to be included in the calculation of the capital investment value for the purposes of this threshold.
The Court of Appeal reasoned that the capital investment value of a development should be assessed at the time of the development application. It held that the costs of a tenancy fit-out, being integral to the overall development and its intended use, were properly included in the calculation of the capital investment value. Therefore, the court found that the development's capital investment value did not exceed the $10 million threshold, meaning the Council had the authority to grant development consent. The court applied the principle that the "capital investment value" encompasses all costs reasonably incurred in bringing the development to fruition, including those related to making the premises suitable for their intended tenants.
The appeal was dismissed, and Calardu Penrith Pty Ltd was ordered to pay the costs of Penrith City Council.
Orders
Orders of the court
Appeal dismissed with costs
Background
Background to the litigation
The dispute arose when the Council purported to grant development consent for the project. Calardu Penrith Pty Ltd argued that the Council acted beyond its statutory powers (ultra vires) by granting consent for a development with a capital investment value exceeding $10 million, a threshold that requires additional scrutiny and potentially different procedural requirements. The company contended that the tenancy fit-out costs incurred during the renovation of the existing building should be included in determining the capital investment value of the project. The Council, however, had not considered these costs in their assessment, leading to the contention that the consent was improperly granted.
Further complicating the matter, Calardu Penrith Pty Ltd submitted that the inclusion of the tenancy fit-out costs in the capital investment value calculation was crucial for the validity of the consent. They argued that without considering these costs, the Council's determination was flawed. This dispute led to an appeal to the court to determine the legitimacy of the Council's actions and the proper interpretation of the capital investment value in this context. The case focuses on the factual events and circumstances surrounding the application for development consent, the Council's assessment process, and the subsequent arguments presented by both parties regarding the valuation and procedural correctness of the consent granted.
The case of Calardu Penrith Pty Ltd v Penrith City Council arose from an application for special leave to appeal against a decision of the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales. The primary matter before the court involved whether the Penrith City Council acted beyond its statutory powers (ultra vires) when it granted development consent for a proposed development. This determination hinged on whether the development had a capital investment value exceeding $10 million, which would require ministerial approval under the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW). A significant point of contention was whether the costs associated with fitting out a tenancy should be included in calculating the capital investment value. The Land and Environment Court had previously dismissed the applicant's challenge, finding that the Council did not act beyond its powers. The applicant then sought special leave to appeal this decision, arguing that the primary judge erred in their interpretation of the statutory provisions and the inclusion of tenancy fit-out costs in the capital investment value calculation. Throughout the proceedings, various interlocutory applications were filed, and several orders were made concerning the admissibility of evidence and the scope of the appeal.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Council acted ultra vires in purporting to grant development consent for the subject development.
2. Whether the development in question had a capital investment value exceeding $10 million.
3. Whether the costs associated with the fit-out of the tenancy should be included in the determination of the capital investment value of the development.
Held
1. Whether the Council acted ultra vires in purporting to grant development consent for the subject development. The court concluded that the Council did not act ultra vires in granting the development consent. As a result, the appeal on this issue was dismissed.
2. Whether the development in question had a capital investment value exceeding $10 million. The court concluded that the development did not have a capital investment value exceeding $10 million. Consequently, the appeal on this issue was also dismissed.
3. Whether the costs associated with the fit-out of the tenancy should be included in the determination of the capital investment value of the development. The court concluded that the costs associated with the fit-out of the tenancy should not be included in the determination of the capital investment value of the development. The appeal on this issue was dismissed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Calardu Penrith Pty Ltd v Penrith City Council, the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) was tasked with determining whether the Council acted beyond its powers, or ultra vires, in granting development consent for a proposed development. The CAT commenced by examining the statutory framework governing the grant of development consent by local councils. It was established that the Council's power to grant such consent is subject to the conditions and limitations set out in the relevant planning legislation. The CAT found that the Council had followed the correct procedures and had not acted ultra vires by granting consent, as it was satisfied that the Council's actions were in accordance with the applicable law and the development met the criteria specified in the planning scheme. This reasoning underscores the importance of adherence to statutory mandates and procedural fairness in development consent decisions.
Turning to the second issue, the CAT had to determine whether the development in question had a capital investment value exceeding $10 million. The determination of capital investment value is a critical aspect of development assessment as it often triggers additional scrutiny and higher levels of oversight. The CAT examined the valuation reports and expert evidence provided by both parties and concluded that the capital investment value of the development did indeed exceed the $10 million threshold. The CAT's approach was meticulous, weighing the various valuation methodologies and expert opinions to arrive at a reasoned decision. The binding principle established here is that the determination of capital investment value is fact-specific and must be based on a thorough and objective analysis of all available evidence.
The third issue before the CAT was whether the costs associated with the fit-out of a tenancy should be included in the determination of the capital investment value of the development. This issue raised questions about the appropriate scope of capital investment value, particularly concerning ancillary costs that may not be directly attributable to the physical development. The CAT considered established case law and authoritative texts on the subject, which generally support the inclusion of such costs where they form part of the overall investment required to bring the development to fruition. The CAT found that the fit-out costs were integral to the overall investment strategy and should be included in the capital investment value determination. This decision aligns with the broader principle that the capital investment value encompasses all costs necessary to complete the development to a marketable state.
In distinguishing, following, or departing from prior authority, the CAT demonstrated a judicious application of precedent. While the CAT followed established jurisprudence in its interpretation of capital investment value, it also carefully distinguished its facts from those of previous cases where the fit-out costs were deemed not to be part of the capital investment. This nuanced approach ensures that the CAT's decision is both consistent with legal principles and tailored to the unique circumstances of the case. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the capital investment value of a development includes all necessary costs required to complete the development to a marketable state, and that a council's grant of development consent is valid if it adheres to statutory mandates and procedural requirements.