Calanca v Parole Board Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Calanca v Parole Board Queensland [2024] QSC 199

PARTIES:

DAMON FRANK CALANCA

(applicant)

v
PAROLE BOARD QUEENSLAND

(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

BS 4330 of 2024

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

28 August 2024

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

22 July 2024

JUDGE:

Copley J

ORDER:

Application dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – JUDICIAL REVIEW – GROUNDS OF REVIEW – GENERALLY – where the applicant was sentenced to life imprisonment for murder – where the applicant was released on parole subject to conditions imposed by the Parole Board – where the applicant breached or allegedly breached conditions of parole – where the applicant filed an application under s 20(2)(e) of the Judicial Review Act 1991 (Qld) on the basis that the making of the decision to cancel the parole order pursuant to s 205 of Corrective Services Act 2006 (Qld) was an improper exercise of power – whether irrelevant considerations were taken into account – whether relevant considerations were not taken into account – whether the decision in accordance with policy without regard to the merits of the case – whether the decision was so unreasonable no reasonable person could have made the decision

Corrective Services Act 2006 (Qld), ss 3(1), 200, 205, 216, 242E

Judicial Review Act 1991 (Qld), ss 20(2)(e), 23

Calanca v Parole Board [2019] QSC 34, cited
Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Ltd (1986) 162 CLR 24, cited
Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Li (2013) 249 CLR 332, cited

WA Pines Pty Ltd v Bannerman (1980) 30 ALR 559, cited

COUNSEL:

The applicant appeared on his own behalf

S B Robb KC for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

The applicant appeared on his own behalf

Parole Board Queensland Legal Services for the respondent

  1. On 5 February 2024 the Parole Board decided to cancel the applicant’s parole.  The applicant has applied for a statutory order of review of that decision.

  2. The application is made on the ground that the making of the decision was an improper exercise of power,[1] for the reasons that:

    (a)irrelevant considerations were taken into account in making the decision;[2]

    (b)relevant considerations were not taken into account;[3]

    (c)the decision was made in accordance with a policy without regard to the merits of the applicant’s case;[4] and

    (d)the decision was so unreasonable that no reasonable person could have arrived at the decision.[5]

    [1]Judicial Review Act 1991 (Qld), s 20(2)(e).

    [2]Judicial Review Act, s 23(a).

    [3]Judicial Review Act, s 23(b).

    [4]Judicial Review Act, s 23(f).

    [5]Judicial Review Act, s 23(g).

  3. Reasons explaining why the Board decided to cancel the parole order were provided on 30 April 2024.[6] 

    [6]Affidavit of Makenzie Brennan at paragraph 21 and Exhibit MB-17.

  4. The reasons concluded:[7]

    “The Board reasonably believed you posed an unacceptable risk of committing an offence, in accordance with s 205(2)(a)(iii) of the CS Act, and reasonably believed you failed to comply with the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Calanca v Parole Board Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QSC 199
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Calanca v Parole Board Queensland, the applicant, a prisoner who was serving a life sentence for murder, challenged the decision of the Parole Board of Queensland to cancel his parole, arguing that the decision was an improper exercise of power. The applicant's parole was suspended on 5 January 2023, and the Board subsequently confirmed this decision on 9 January 2023. The applicant argued that the Board's decision to cancel his parole was unreasonable and based on irrelevant considerations.

The legal issues before the court included whether the Board had taken into account irrelevant considerations, failed to consider relevant ones, acted according to policy without regard to the merits of the case, or made a decision so unreasonable that no reasonable person could have made it. The court examined the Board's reasons for its decision, focusing on the applicant's failure to disclose intimate relationships and comply with other parole conditions. The court found that the Board's decision was justified by the applicant's admitted failures to comply with the parole conditions, which were relevant to the Board's belief that the applicant posed an unacceptable risk of committing an offence.

The court also rejected the applicant's argument that the Board had taken into account irrelevant considerations by examining a schedule he provided for the week commencing 1 January 2023. The court found that the Board had relevant information showing that the applicant's relationship had ended prior to his submission of the schedule, making the schedule's accuracy a material consideration in determining if condition (r) had been complied with. The court concluded that the Board's decision to cancel the applicant's parole was not an improper exercise of power and dismissed the application.

The final order of the court was to dismiss the application, affirming the Board's decision to cancel the applicant's parole.

Orders

Orders of the court

Application dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons set out below the decision to cancel parole was not an improper exercise of power. Background On 11 February 1994 the applicant was sentenced to imprisonment for life for a count of murder. On 1 October 2019 he was released on parole subject to conditions. On 5 January 2023 a prescribed Board member suspended the applicant’s parole. The applicant was returned to custody on 6 January 2023. On 9 January 2023 the Board confirmed the prescribed Board member’s decision to suspend parole. Between then and 5 February 2024 the Board met and considered the decision to suspend parole on nine occasions. The conditions of parole relevant to this application are:[8]“(r)You must submit and discuss a schedule of your planned, proposed and any additional past activities, including the provision of verifying materials or documents on a weekly basis or as otherwise directed by an authorised corrective services officer;(x)You must not commit any act of domestic violence.(aa)You must report any personal or intimate relationship with anyone, to an authorised corrective services officer at the commencement of the relationship.(bb)You must make complete disclosure of the terms of your order and the nature of your past offences to any person as nominated by an authorised corrective services officer. Further, you are to provide full contact details for any such person to an authorised corrective services officer to verify that full disclosure has occurred.(ff)You must not have access to a device with Internet access without first obtaining the written approval of the corrective services officer or the Board. Any such approval will be conditional upon your agreement to having any device you access randomly examined, by whatever means are necessary, to determine whether the device has been used for any unacceptable purpose.(gg)You are prohibited from accessing or utilising any social media, websites, technology, applications, or personal introductory systems whereby you can find and contact individuals over the internet (or by any other means) with the objective of developing a personal, romantic or sexual relationship without the prior approval of the corrective services officer.(kk)You must respond truthfully and fully, to enquiries by a corrective services officer and the Board about activities, relationships, whereabouts and movements generally.” [8]Exhibit MB-17, pages 84-86, paragraph 171.Relevant legislation The Board is established pursuant to s 216 of the Corrective Services Act 2006 (Qld) (“the Act”). Pursuant to s 217 of the Act its functions are to decide applications for parole orders, other than court-ordered parole orders, and to perform other functions given to it under the Act or another Act. Section 200 of the Act provides:“200 Conditions of parole(1)A parole order must include conditions requiring the prisoner the subject of the order–(a) to be under the chief executive’s supervision–(i)until the end of the prisoner’s period of imprisonment; or (ii)if the prisoner is being detained in an institution for a period fixed by a judge under the Criminal Law Amendment Act 1945, part 3–for the period the prisoner was directed to be detained; and(b) to carry out the chief executive’s lawful instructions; and(c) to give a test sample if required to do so by the chief executive under section 41; and(d) to report, and receive visits, as directed by the chief executive; and(e) to notify the chief executive within 48 hours of any change in the prisoner’s address or employment during the parole period; and(f) not to commit an offence.(2)A parole order may contain a condition requiring the prisoner to comply with a direction given to the prisoner under section 200A.(3)A parole order granted by the parole board may also contain conditions the board reasonably considers necessary–(a) to ensure the prisoner’s good conduct; or(b) to stop the prisoner committing an offence.Examples–·a condition about the prisoner’s place of residence, employment or participation in a particular program·a condition imposing a curfew for the prisoner·a condition requiring the prisoner to give a test sample (4)The prisoner must comply with the conditions included in the parole order.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

This ground of review has not been made out.Decision so unreasonable that no reasonable person could have arrived at the decision The applicant asserts that no reasonable person could have arrived at the decision to cancel his parole. He contends that it was unreasonable for the Board to decide to cancel parole on the basis of a belief that he posed an unacceptable risk of committing an offence when the President of the Board had commended him for following a relapse prevention plan. He also relies upon the arguments that have been advanced under other grounds of review that an irrelevant consideration was taken into account in the Board being satisfied he had breached condition (gg), and, upon the failure to inspect his proposed accommodation and interview his housing sponsor. There was an evident and intelligible justification[35] for the Board’s decision to cancel parole on the basis of a reasonable belief both that the applicant had failed to comply with the parole order and posed an unacceptable risk of committing an offence. In these respects it is sufficient to notice the matters set out below.[35]Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Li (2013) 249 CLR 332 at 367 [76]. Opinions and recommendations of psychiatrists and psychologists provided prior to the applicant’s release on parole in 2019 had indicated that a major risk to the community related to the applicant’s responses to any breakdown in personal relationships. However, the risk was regarded as manageable through stringent conditions.[36] The Board imposed conditions to allow for the monitoring of contact the applicant had with others and conditions imposing obligations to disclose intimate relationships with female persons and to submit a schedule of intended activities.[37][36]Exhibit MB-17, page 78, paragraph 169(d).[37]Exhibit MB-17, pages 78-79, paragraph 169(e). The examination of the applicant’s mobile phone on 6 January 2023 revealed that he had been engaged in intimate relationships.[38] The applicant admitted that he had not informed his parole officer about the intimate relationships he had with three women.[39][38]Exhibit MB-17, pages 82-83, paragraph 169(u).[39]Exhibit MB-17, page 65, paragraphs 130(s)-(v) and page 77, paragraph 167(f). The Board stated:[40]“The information before the Board showed that over a significant period of time, you had repeatedly failed to make frank and open disclosures to Community Corrections, particularly regarding intimate female relationships and to comply with other stringent conditions of your parole order imposed by the Board to enable Community Corrections to monitor you closely, particularly in the case of a relationship breakdown which the Board considered may increase the level of risk you may pose to the community.Accordingly, the Board reasonably believed you posed an unacceptable risk of committing an offence, and reasonably believed you failed to comply with the conditions of your parole order.”[40]Exhibit MB-17, page 84, paragraphs 169(aa)-170.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The applicant admitted to the Board that he had not informed an authorised corrective services officer about intimate relationships he had commenced and pursued with three women whilst on parole. The Board said these admitted failures constituted failures to comply with conditions (aa) and (bb) of the parole order.[19] The Board stated that these failures, together with other failures to make frank and open disclosures to community corrections, had occurred over a significant period of time. The Board went on to state that such conditions had been imposed to monitor the applicant, particularly in situations of relationship breakdowns, which it considered might increase the level of risk the applicant might pose to the community.[20] The reasons provided by the Board show that the admitted failures were among the reasons why the Board formed the beliefs that the applicant posed an unacceptable risk of committing an offence and that he had failed to comply with conditions of parole.[21] These admitted failures to comply with conditions of parole were relevant to the decision to cancel parole.[19]Exhibit MB-17, page 85, paragraphs 171(c) and (d).[20]Exhibit MB-17, page 84, paragraph 169(aa).[21]Exhibit MB-17, page 84, paragraph 170.Taking irrelevant considerations into account The applicant submitted that in being satisfied that there had been a breach of condition (r)[22] the Board erred in taking into account the weekly schedule he provided for the week commencing 1 January 2023. His argument was that in preparing the schedule he could not be expected to anticipate events or circumstances not foreseen at the time it was completed and therefore the schedule was “irrelevant”.[22]Exhibit MB-17, pages 84-85, paragraph 171(a). The Board’s conclusion that condition (r) had not been complied with was based on the following matters:[23]“On 1 January 2023, you submitted a weekly planner (for your movements from 2 January 2023 to 8 January 2023) in which you stated you would be going to Ms [X’s] home on 3 January 2023, you would be having dinner with her at your home on 5 January 2023, you would stay at her home on 6 January 2023, and you would both visit your sister on 7 January 2023. Your parole order was suspended on 5 January 2023. Following the suspension and prior to your return to custody, you sent two (2) emails to the Board (on 5 January 2023 at 10:57pm and 11:53 pm) advising that your relationship with Ms [X] ended four (4) days earlier. You were returned to custody on 6 January 2023. The Board had regard to your emails received by the Board on 5 January 2023 and to other information indicating your relationship with Ms [X] broke down prior to 1 January 2023.”[23]Exhibit MB-17, pages 81-82, paragraphs 169(p)-(r). The Board had received information which showed that the applicant’s relationship had ended prior to his submission of the schedule. This information was relevant to whether condition (r) had been complied with. The submission of a schedule containing activities that the applicant knew were not going to occur was a material consideration in determining if condition (r) had been complied with. Condition (r) required the applicant to provide a schedule of planned or proposed activities. The accuracy of the schedule was relevant to the effectiveness of the supervision of the applicant.